Who'd you take??

[mrhoopfan]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

[Maggot]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

Iguodala, Roy, Horford, Williams, Bosh

[Slim Rick]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

My list:
Iverson or T-mac
KG or Duncan
Dirk or Amare
Kevin Durant og Greg Oden
Josh Smith or Igoudala

[Godfather]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson (young vs older)
Al Jefferson or Al Horford (please...)
Deron Williams or Baron Davis (...)
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh (lol)

Only one of these comparisons is debatable. And lol @ the person taking Horford over Jefferson.

[Maniak]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh


Iverson or T-mac
KG or Duncan
Dirk or Amare
Kevin Durant og Greg Oden
Josh Smith or Igoudala

:cheers:

[RoseCity07]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

[Anti404]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh
Iggy is a better defender, since Deron will have the ball in his hands most of the time a spot up shooter such as JJ is better than a PG/SG in Roy, Al Jefferson has a much better offensive game, Deron Williams is just flat out better than Davis, Chris Bosh is better defensively I think.

[CakeorDeath]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh


Iverson or T-mac
KG or Duncan
Dirk or Amare
Kevin Durant og Greg Oden
Josh Smith or Igoudala

:cheers:


Agree.

[majorhops]

Agree.
I second that notion.

[Maniak]

i feel loved :lol

[mrhoopfan]

I'd take Rudy(gonna be a big time star, and Iggy looked suspect vs. Pistons last year), Jefferson( Horford is like antonio Davis) Johnson( Shoots that deep ball real well) Davis( if healthy) Gasol( if he's paired with a defensive minded center)

[Godfather]

I'd take Rudy(gonna be a big time star, and Iggy looked suspect vs. Pistons last year), Jefferson( Horford is like antonio Davis) Johnson( Shoots that deep ball real well) Davis( if healthy) Gasol( if he's paired with a defensive minded center)

:roll:
Rudy Gay may be a solid scorer (.1 pt more than Iggy), but he is a terrible defender and facilitator compared to Iggy. Yes Jefferson is better than Horford, but no way in hell is Horford like Antonio Davis (much better rebounder and defender. Just because Joe shoots the deep ball "really well" doesn't mean he is better than Roy who has nearly identical stats, but is 3 years younger and is a true team leader. Deron Williams is much younger and a better passer and equally good defender as Baron...And Bosh paired with a defensive minded center is just as good as Gasol paired with one...Only difference is Bosh is 4 years younger and a better defender +scorer.

[danumber88]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

Obvious answers (based on skill not youth)

Iggy
Johnson
Williams
Bosh

[mrhoopfan]

:roll:
Rudy Gay may be a solid scorer (.1 pt more than Iggy), but he is a terrible defender and facilitator compared to Iggy. Yes Jefferson is better than Horford, but no way in hell is Horford like Antonio Davis (much better rebounder and defender. Just because Joe shoots the deep ball "really well" doesn't mean he is better than Roy who has nearly identical stats, but is 3 years younger and is a true team leader. Deron Williams is much younger and a better passer and equally good defender as Baron...And Bosh paired with a defensive minded center is just as good as Gasol paired with one...Only difference is Bosh is 4 years younger and a better defender +scorer.


Iggy averaged 13 pts on 33% shooting in playoffs including 14% from 3:roll: ....Rudy is much better off the dribble AND plays in the west AND is younger......When Antonio Davis played 30+ minutes/ game he was a 13, 9 and 1.5 guy and a GREAT help defender like Horford.....did you watch the last Olympic game?? Pau scored when he wanted

[LJJ]

Only one of these comparisons is debatable. And lol @ the person taking Horford over Jefferson.

I'll take Horford over Big Al too. Jefferson is a center who can't play D. That sucks.

[PacerRaptor]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh
Iguodala
JJ
Baron
Bosh

[basketballer4]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh
..


My list:
Iverson or T-mac
KG or Duncan
Dirk or Amare
Kevin Durant or Greg Oden
Josh Smith or Iguodala

[3.2.1.]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh
Iguodala
Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson
Baron Davis
Chris Bosh

[NotALakerTroll]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

Iggy
Horford
Deron Williams
The last one is a tossup. I would rather have Gasol if the position that's needed is center, and I would rather have Bosh if you need a PF.

[EricGordon23]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh


Rudy Gay
Brandon Roy
Al Jefferson
Deron Williams
Pau Gasol

[fiddy]

Whats up with yall choosing Bosh over Pau?

[eprizzle14]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh
gay
johnson
jefferson
williams
bosh

[eprizzle14]

Whats up with yall choosing Bosh over Pau?
Pau dominates against a weaker defender. Pau can dominate using his finnesse but I like Bosh's altheticism over Paus skill set. Bosh defense> Pau defense.

[AppleNader]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

these

[3.2.1.]

My list:
Iverson or T-mac
KG or Duncan
Dirk or Amare
Kevin Durant og Greg Oden
Josh Smith or Igoudala
Iverson
Duncan
Amare
Durant
Igoudala

[danumber88]

YOU are STUPId to take Al Horford over AL Jefferson :violin:

[catzhernandez]

the entire left side

[Godfather]

I'll take Horford over Big Al too. Jefferson is a center who can't play D. That sucks.

He is a PF...He was playing out of position all of last season and still gave a valid effort on that side of the ball.

[1~Gibson~1]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Boshthe bolded ones

[AppleNader]

YOU are STUPId to take Al Horford over AL Jefferson :violin:


:rolleyes: Why?

I have Williams/Roy/Bosh, which is plenty of offensive firepower.

I want strong post defense if Bosh is playing 4.

[danumber88]

I mean realistically..

Horford over JEFFERON?

Horford is a 10/9 guy almost a 10/10.. 49%

Your meaning to tell me ur gonna take a 10/10 guy over a 21/11 guy. 50%.

[A.M.G.]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala - Gay is more of a legit sized SF.
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson - Roy is younger, and plays with more leadership and passion. This is a toss-up though.
Al Jefferson or Al Horford - Horford is nice, but Jefferson is 21 and 11.
Deron Williams or Baron Davis - younger, less injury prone, better.
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh - Bosh is my brewmide. Can't choose some faggy Spaniard over my man Chris Bosh. Seriously, Bosh is just better than Pau.


Iverson or T-mac - So I can finally get Big Mac a First-Roundianship.
KG or Duncan - Best Center or Best Power Forward? I take the center.
Dirk or Amare - Battle of the stat-stuffing, non-defending PFs! Dirk has been psychologically scarred by Wade and Baron, and is older. Amare is a STUD, whose knees are in danger of shattering.
Kevin Durant or Greg Oden - um, Center or scrawny, chucking Tweener.
Josh Smith or Igoudala - same reason I take Gay ahead of Iggy.

[AppleNader]

I mean realistically..

Horford over JEFFERON?

Horford is a 10/9 guy almost a 10/10.. 49%

Your meaning to tell me ur gonna take a 10/10 guy over a 21/11 guy. 50%.

Realistically, I'm building a starting 5, not basing things on statistics.

Horford is a better fit for my other 4 guys. I'd prefer to not have a terrible defensive player at the 5. Plus, my entire lineup is an excellent defensive unit, which I place much more emphasis on.

[Nets fan 93]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

[Godfather]

Realistically, I'm building a starting 5, not basing things on statistics.

Horford is a better fit for my other 4 guys. I'd prefer to not have a terrible defensive player at the 5. Plus, my entire lineup is an excellent defensive unit, which I place much more emphasis on.

I don't think the point of this thread was necessarily a starting 5 but w/e. Saying Jefferson is a terrible defender is way off base. AL was defending out of position last season and still managed to save some face. Horford is not a good defender by any means and lacks the footwork to do so. Jefferson came into this league as a powerforward and should stay that way. Expect him to show his defensive worth next year with love defending the opponents bigger big man.

[AppleNader]

I don't think the point of this thread was necessarily a starting 5 but w/e.

Well I made it like that since he gave us 2 choices for PG, G/F, and post players.


Saying Jefferson is a terrible defender is way off base. AL was defending out of position last season and still managed to save some face.

yea, and again I was basing it off the fact that it was going to be a starting 5. With Bosh at the 4, Jefferson would have to play the 5 like in Minnesota, where he is a very bad defender.


Horford is not a good defender by any means and lacks the footwork to do so.

but still a better defender than Jefferson

[MastahX]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

Gasol and Baron vs Bosh & Williams? WTF Not even debatable.

[Kobe_6/8]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

D-Will
Joe Johnson
Rudy Gay
Pau Gasol
Al Horford

[Dr Hawk]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

:)

[Dr Hawk]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

Gasol and Baron vs Bosh & Williams? WTF Not even debatable.

You take Bosh over Gasol????????? and not even debatable??????? :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: my ****ing god

[atljonesbro]

I was wondering why people were taking Jefferson over horford, then I noticed the date on the posts

[senelcoolidge]

Rudy Gay or Iguodala
Brandon Roy or Joe Johnson
Al Jefferson or Al Horford
Deron Williams or Baron Davis
Pau Gasol or Chris Bosh

Baron Davis was pretty good for a time. I just like him more than D. Williams.

[Fallen Angel]

Joe Johnson, Al Horford, and Deron Williams were the right choices.

Rudy Gay vs. Andre Iguodala and Pau Gasol vs. Chris Bosh are a wash.