Who's better: Paul Pierce or Manu Ginobili

[#number6ix#]

It's too close for me to call I need you guys thoughts

[BlackVVaves]

It's too close for you to call?

:roll:

Did someone let loose Manu's relatives on ISH? Good god.

[kobron23]

both are proven winners and it is a very close comparison although pierce couldnt win until he got garnett. manu won before he got duncan

[DTreats]

I'll take Manu.

What did Pierce ever win without KG carrying him?

[#number6ix#]

both are proven winners and it is a very close comparison although pierce couldnt win until he got garnett. manu won before he got duncan
Exactly people act like Manu is a bum or something from where I see Manu is just as clutch as Paul pierce and if he went to Boston b4 kg and Allen got there it wouldn't be a big difference in their w/l totals

[JohnnySic]

Pierce >>>

[Rasheed1]

I'd rather have Paul Pierce... he's older now, but mostly before garnett & ray allen, Pierce was a beast. He could shoot from distance, drive the lane real tough.. I was jealous that we missed out on him and Boston got him. Dude is nasty

[chips93]

manu won before he got duncan

what, you mean in europe? we really countin those?

[k0kakw0rld]

The Truth:pimp:

[FKAri]

At their peak, it's close but I'll go with Pierce. But Ginobli's been too inconsistent due to injuries throughout his career.

[imnew09]

As much as I hate Pierce, I'd take him because of his clutchness

[Xiao Yao You]

Manu

[Rubio2Gasol]

Right now or Career?

Right now I'd take Manu

[Real Men Wear Green]

Present day is close. NBA career is Pierce easily. Overall career is an interesting question, you have to give Manu a lot of credit for leading Argentina to the World Championship.

[swi7ch]

I'll take Manu

[jThrow'd]

I'll take Manu

Nothin' but The Truth.

[wigwan]

The one that has won the Olympic Gold..

[kobron23]

The one that has won the Olympic Gold..

eggggactly

[Dwyane Rose]

I'll take Manu.

What did Pierce ever win without KG carrying him?

:facepalm

[usdmef9]

This has to be a joke question. One of them is a career 6th man lol.

[kNicKz]

manu won before he got duncan
As if the team was bad before they had Duncan

David Robinson...what a scrub

:biggums:

Pierce no contest

[kNicKz]

What did Pierce ever win without KG carrying him?
Pierce carried an entire organization, through thick and thin

[SpecialQue]

The Truth is...Manu is better.

[usdmef9]

The Truth is...Manu is better.

The truth is you are biased to white/european players

[tpols]

So let me get this straight.. AI in the other thread is thrashed and many say Manu is better, but then you have most here saying Pierce is ahead of Manu?:lol Newsflash AI was considered better than Pierce every year during their primes.

[SpecialQue]

The truth is you are biased to white/european players

But my 2nd and 3rd favorite players are Westbrook and Artest!

[L.Kizzle]

P-Dub

[StateOfMind12]

P-Dub
:applause: First time I've ever seen you take Pierce in a comparison.

[kNIOKAS]

Rank them top 50 all time and you'll see..:coleman:

[noosaman]

Manu. He could have averaged 25-5-5 as a lead guy.

[noosaman]

Pierce carried an entire organization, through thick and thin

In the East and to a shitty record.

[Flash31]

Don't Like PP,But he's better than Ginobli

22,000pts,NBA Championship,higher career avgs

one of the greatest celtics and longest tenured,

It's close but Pierce is clearly better

[kobron23]

Don't Like PP,But he's better than Ginobli

22,000pts,NBA Championship,higher career avgs

one of the greatest celtics and longest tenured,

It's close but Pierce is clearly better

pierce couldnt win until he got garnett and ray

[Pushxx]

pierce couldnt win until he got garnett and ray

And what was Manu gonna do without the GOAT PF?

[Mr. Jabbar]

It's too close for you to call?

:roll:

Did someone let loose Manu's relatives on ISH? Good god.


Lolol exactly my thoughts, manus relatives roam ish with no shame

[Donnybrook]

This has to be a joke question. One of them is a career 6th man lol.

Haha, thank you! Pierce is clearly the best choice. Manu is good, but come on...

[Donnybrook]

manu is a proven winner without duncan you must be dumb

Paul Pierce's team impact/leadership > anything Manu can do.

Seriously, though. You're telling me that if you had to choose one of those guys to be a leader on your team that you would choose Manu as the leader over PP? Look at the situation objectively and don't post until you do so.

[SourPatchKids]

Chris Paul will be better than both of them

[EricGordon23]

Thats tough.

Change my mind pierce is better but I like manus game more.

[bdreason]

For a single game give me prime Manu.



For a season give me PP, because Manu is just too injury prone.

[Rooster]

Thats tough.

Change my mind pierce is better but I like manus game more.

Same for me. I think Pierce is better overall because he is better defensively but I just like the way Ginobili play, very unorthodox.

[AK47DR91]

Manu is the better player.

But Pierce had the better career and should be ranked higher because his accomplishments came as the #1 option.

[Nero Tulip]

As if the team was bad before they had Duncan

David Robinson...what a scrub

:biggums:

Pierce no contest

See that ISH? Retarded people who don't know anything pick Pierce.

The correct answer is Manu.

[Kews1]

It's quite clear its Paul Pierce, this thread is a joke :facepalm

[Nero Tulip]

It's quite clear its Paul Pierce, this thread is a joke :facepalm

This guy looks trustworthy and not biased at all.

[CJ Mustard]

So let me get this straight....Most people here have Manu as a better player than Pierce, yet 90% of you (idiotically) say that Pierce was the "lead dog" on the 2008 Celtics with Kevin Garnett (who finished 3rd in MVP voting in the regular season and lead the Celtics in scoring in the Playoffs, not to mention anchored their defense) on the team?

:oldlol: I swear 98% of the posts on this site are made to fit an agenda.

[roffie]

switch out pierce with manu before the big 3 era. i'm positive with manu being the no.1 option, he would have been much more successfully.

[Rubio2Gasol]

Paul Pierce's team impact/leadership > anything Manu can do.

Seriously, though. You're telling me that if you had to choose one of those guys to be a leader on your team that you would choose Manu as the leader over PP? Look at the situation objectively and don't post until you do so.

What do you mean a leader? Manu is a leader as well....

First option...yea I'll go with Pierce but right now I think Manu is just a better player.

[JohnnySic]

I'd rather have Paul Pierce... he's older now, but mostly before garnett & ray allen, Pierce was a beast. He could shoot from distance, drive the lane real tough.. I was jealous that we missed out on him and Boston got him. Dude is nasty
If the Sixers had PP in '01, they would have had a good chance to beat that Lakers team, which is regarded as the best team of the decade. Yup, I said that.

PP would have been the scoring punch that Sixers team lacked, to take some pressure off AI. The starting forwards on that team were Tyrone Hill and Jumaine Jones. :coleman:

[Optimus Prime]

Manu easily. What did Pierce do before KG and Ray Ray got him a ring? :rolleyes:

[Horatio33]

I love the Spurs and Manu but the only answer is Pierce. Manu never been first option on his NBA team where Pierce has. Pierce stats are better, would give Manu clutch lead over Pierce but not by much. 05-06 Pierce is better than any version of Manu.

[Horatio33]

Manu easily. What did Pierce do before KG and Ray Ray got him a ring? :rolleyes:

What has Manu done? Second option behind Timmy?

[JohnnySic]

Championships are a team accomplishment. Barkley, Malone, and Ewing never won titles; is Manu better than them too?

What did PP do before he had KG and Allen? How about put up 25/6/4 over the course of 10 years?

Manu is a glorified Hedo Turkoglu. I never got why he is so highly regarded. Put Manu on those early 2000's Celtics teams with Antoine Walker, Eric Willaims, Tony Battie, etc, and what would he have done?

[Richie2k6]

Manu easily. What did Pierce do before KG and Ray Ray got him a ring? :rolleyes:
but Manu has always had Tim Du--.... nevermind

[Kews1]

This guy looks trustworthy and not biased at all.

Its not biased at all. Swap PP & Manu around for their entire career and you tell me who would do better and worse in the other persons situation.

[Kews1]

What has Manu done? Second option behind Timmy?

*Third.

[kNIOKAS]

so one guys thinks out of making a ridiculous thread and then the bunch on them quickly picks up. it's like that bruceleebowen guy all over