If melo wins MVP and finals MVP this season does he pass wade all-time?

[Umad101]

Does he passes wade all-time? Lets be real for the next 5 years melo going to continue the same level of play while d-wade is going down hill. If melo wins MVP and f-MVP doing it in New York would bring him a higher status than wade winning his in Miami


Melo(MVP + fmvp) > wade(1.5 rings)

[kNicKz]

This is a tall order

[longhornfan1234]

Melo this season >>>> any Wade season.

[winwin]

Wade is not top 100 all-time

melo is

[LEFT4DEAD]

Melo this season >>>> any Wade season.
:roll: :roll:

And no, not even close. Wade has 2 rings and one of the greatest finals performances of all times, and would have 2 FMVPs if Lebron performed a bit better. Melo needs more than 1 ring and 1 FMVP to surpass him.

[swi7ch]

Yep. All Wade has done is win one title + FMVP which Melo will tie if the OP's conditions are met. Wade's other title was because of riding LBJ's coattails so it doesn't say anything about Wade individually.

[Nash]

What's so different about Melo this season? I mean really, so his team is winning. People talk about him being this new player and he's not even averaging more than 2 apg. Wade at his prime used to average the same amount of ppg while dishing out 5-6 assists.

[LongLiveTheKing]

Melo this season >>>> any Wade season.
:roll:
08-09 Wade>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Any Melo season.

[kNicKz]

What's so different about Melo this season? I mean really, so his team is winning. People talk about him being this new player and he's not even averaging more than 2 apg. Wade at his prime used to average the same amount of ppg while dishing out 5-6 assists.

Watch a game instead of looking at the numbers.He looks different out there defensively, and is making the people around him better for the first time in his career. He's looking like a leader instead of just a scorer

[FreezingTsmoove]

Watch a game instead of looking at the numbers.He looks different out there defensively, and is making the people around him better for the first time in his career. He's looking like a leader instead of just a scorer

Explain to me how Wade isn't a leader then?

[PJR]

Watch a game instead of looking at the numbers.He looks different out there defensively, and is making the people around him better for the first time in his career. He's looking like a leader instead of just a scorer

So you mean he's finally doing things consistently in his 10th year (like defending/playmaking), that he should've done YEARS ago?

Hoo-****ing-ray!!! :roll:

[NewYorkNoPicks]

What's so different about Melo this season? I mean really, so his team is winning. People talk about him being this new player and he's not even averaging more than 2 apg. Wade at his prime used to average the same amount of ppg while dishing out 5-6 assists.

Is Wade better than David Robinson because he never dished out 5 assist per?

Different positions. Not every small forward plays like a point guard, on Lebron does. Every other small forward plays....like a small forward.

[Nash]

Watch a game instead of looking at the numbers.He looks different out there defensively, and is making the people around him better for the first time in his career. He's looking like a leader instead of just a scorer
Melo has always been this player, a fantastic scorer. His teammates are doing much better now, thats the difference. They are playing good team ball.

Also, almost 15 games into this season doesn't make Melo better than prime Wade. I'm sorry, but he's not. Wade is a better playmaker, more all round scorer and played elite defense.

People need to stop these knee jerk reactions.

[TinselTime12]

If my uncle had a vag, he would be my aunt and if my aunt had balls, she would be my uncle.

Moot question.

[Umad101]

Melo has always been this player, a fantastic scorer. His teammates are doing much better now, thats the difference. They are playing good team ball.

Also, almost 15 games into this season doesn't make Melo better than prime Wade. I'm sorry, but he's not. Wade is a better playmaker, more all round scorer and played elite defense.

People need to stop these knee jerk reactions.
Lol, ur actually going to tell me you'll take a current wade over current melo now:facepalm

[Dictator]

Only ish.

[LEFT4DEAD]

Cant wait until February when Wade steps up and silences critics.

[28renyoy]

well Carmelo has a 0% chance of winning regular season MVP, so who cares

[Nash]

Lol, ur actually going to tell me you'll take a current wade over current melo now:facepalm
Current Wade in the playoffs > Current Melo

I have no doubts in my mind that Wade will be more valuable when playoffs come around.

And he's just 30, people act as if he's 34.

[upside24]

Watch a game instead of looking at the numbers.He looks different out there defensively, and is making the people around him better for the first time in his career. He's looking like a leader instead of just a scorer
Exactly.

Some people focus too much on stats/boxscores and not enough on actually watching the game.

Melo's approach to the game is much better this year. Top 5 player without a doubt IMO.

[lebeast666]

lol what the Fuh! Wade >>> melo. Melos team is just deeper and much better now. Melo ain't done sh!t other than score and smile when he loses

[Sarcastic]

lol what the Fuh! Wade >>> melo. Melos team is just deeper and much better now. Melo ain't done sh!t other than score and smile when he loses


Kind of like how Wade won all his rings. He won with prime Shaq and prime Lebron. Who's Melo's best teammate? Tyson Chandler?

[DirkNowitzki41]

Melo is a great player but this isnt even close.

wade >>>>>

Melo can never do what Wade did in 06. goat finals performance and dont bring up shaq.. it was all dwade

Other than that, wade has always been the better player till this season

[plowking]

Not Wade. But he passes Kobe all time.

[TheeBeast]

Melo is to Kobe as Kobe is to Jordan, so yes.

[kNicKz]

Melos team is just deeper

:roll: :roll: :roll:

[DaSeba5]

Melo this season >>>> any Wade season.

:roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll:

[B-hoop]

lol what the Fuh! Wade >>> melo. Melos team is just deeper and much better now. Melo ain't done sh!t other than score and smile when he loses

Never go full retard

[fpliii]

definitely not

[longtime lurker]

Yeah he'll move from ahead of Wade from 150 to 149 on the all time list. Both of these guys have considerable holes in their career resumes.

[longtime lurker]

Exactly.

Some people focus too much on stats/boxscores and not enough on actually watching the game.

Melo's approach to the game is much better this year. Top 5 player without a doubt IMO.

That would actually require them to use their brains. A very tall order for the majority of posters on this site.

[red1]

sure. if melo is actually better than wade then he will be ranked better. lemme know if it happens

[Money 23]

Wade's 2006, 2009, 2010, and possibly 2011 are better than any Melo season thus far.

So no, why would he be ranked above Wade all-time? Wade has 2x Rings, FMVP, and a few LEGIT MVP caliber seasons already on his resume.

In just a few seasons KD already surpassed Melo at his own game.

Melo has been an evolutionary version of Glenn Robinson. Nothing more, nothing less.

[pnyozzzoo]

100%, If he does that he is prob. MVP FMVP, and leading a worse team to a chip in a better competition. That's IF big IF.

[NumberSix]

If Melo puts up a '06 Wade level performance in the finals, then it's debatable....

But that's not very likely. Not even LeBron or Kobe has balled out like that in a finals.

[fpliii]

100%, If he does that he is prob. MVP FMVP, and leading a worse team to a chip in a better competition. That's IF big IF.

:wtf:

[Young X]

SMH at this disrespectful thread. Melo has never been a top 5 player, Wade in his 2nd year was better than Melo ever was.

[BEAST Griffin]

Worse supporting cast and better competition in the playoffs than Kobe ever faced. He'd surpass Kobe.

:bowdown:

[scandisk_]

maybe :confusedshrug:

[Umad101]

SMH at this disrespectful thread. Melo has never been a top 5 player, Wade in his 2nd year was better than Melo ever was.
:roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll:

























:facepalm

[Money 23]

SMH at this disrespectful thread. Melo has never been a top 5 player, Wade in his 2nd year was better than Melo ever was.
Truth.

Heat were a non injury to Wade away v.s. the Pistons from being in the Finals. Thanks all to Wade.

Who at that point had become the superior player to Shaq.

[krayziejcs]

No...

[Dresta]

Not

Even


Close

[derb2k2]

ridiculous thread. Melo will never surpass Wade.

[Dresta]

Kind of like how Wade won all his rings. He won with prime Shaq and prime Lebron. Who's Melo's best teammate? Tyson Chandler?Prime Shaq? Are you 10?

[PJR]

Op is a phaggit.

[Legends66NBA7]

Even if Melo wins MVP (as of now, don't think it will happen... I got Durant winning it), Wade's been consistently the better player when healthy and much more potent in the playoffs, so I just can't see it happening with the MVP+Finals MVP+Championship, even with a dominant run. It's just the case of being more consistent than a 1 year dominance, which Wade has probably had like 4-5 years better than the 12-13 Melo so far.

It does push Melo in the Top 50, quite easily.


Melo has been an evolutionary version of Glenn Robinson. Nothing more, nothing less.

I've actually seen that comparison before too with Melo and Robinson before, but yeah Melo's offensive skillset just puts him at an elite level over Robinson as players.

[LockoutOver11]

wade took down the mighty pistons.... and a pretty good dallas team.

wade was like a crazy 6'3 point guard skilled baller that could score with the best sg's and block your shiiiiiitttt...

so far i agreed that durant has surpassed anything melo's accomplished, and wade is not gonna be touched by melo this season...


but then theres always the factor of New York.

He gets New York a championship... then... you know how that is. Knicks have been starving for this, and so has the league.

To be in even top 25 for me, he's gotta go to at least 3 more conference finals. Beat Heat, beat a legit contender DRose Chicago team, and Beat the Thunder or even the Spurs.

But how many years can the Knicks stay at a contender level Let's say they win a chip. Tyson will get hurt sooner or later. Smith will not be resigned. Kidd will retire.

Felton Iman Melo ____ and ____ ? Those blanks gotta end up being ****ing Al Horford and some other emerging Center.

[Sarcastic]

Prime Shaq? Are you 10?


Shaq was still a 20/10 player in Miami, and capable of much more, but he took a back seat to Wade for the good of the team. He was 33 years old. He was not at his peak, but he was certainly still in his prime.

[Halipender]

Wade has all star mvp, scoring titles besides 2 rings. Melo is levels behind

[hon]

http://cdn.hollywoodgrind.com/images/2008/4/carmelo-anthony.jpg


He's got a mean mugshot...

[Purch]

:roll:
08-09 Wade>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Any Melo season.
This. Melo fans have a weird sense of history


:biggums:

[Chrono90]

IF

Just trying to show people its a big "if."

[Dresta]

Shaq was still a 20/10 player in Miami, and capable of much more, but he took a back seat to Wade for the good of the team. He was 33 years old. He was not at his peak, but he was certainly still in his prime.If you don't think Shaq was on a steep downslope at that time then you are ****ing brainless.

[Human Error]

Hmm this is an interesting thread. Let's see if Carmelo wins the Finals MVP!

[Coolaak]

Wade played with Lebron & Prime Shaq
You give Melo those 2, he would win 2 more rings then what wade has now

[PJR]

Wade played with Lebron & Prime Shaq
You give Melo those 2, he would win 2 more rings then what wade has now

No he wouldn't. Speculative conjecture.