Stephen A Smith: Melo will Likely leave the Knicks

[RoundMoundOfReb]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cEiMFA3ao-o

Discuss.

[STATUTORY]

Best news for the Knicks since we drafted ewing

[RoundMoundOfReb]

Also LeBron views Knicks as "straight garbage" and has crossed them off his list.

[CanYouDigIt]

http://content.sportslogos.net/logos/6/228/full/ifk08eam05rwxr3yhol3whdcm.gif

[CanYouDigIt]

In-depth thread on why Carmelo Anthony will leave New York and join the Dallas Mavericks.

http://www.insidehoops.com/forum/showthread.php?t=317350

[iDunk]

Lol , not happening.

[RoundMoundOfReb]

SAS is a terrible analyst but he does seem to have sources with the players. He predicted Doc to clippers, Miami big 3..

[niko]

He's on some Net propoganda shit lately so I'm not sure whether this is what people told him or this is what he wants to push to discredit the Knicks. For about the last week he's refused to criticize the Nets except for 30 seconds of the show then back to Knick bashing. If you came out of last night's games with 95% of your criticism at the Knicks and "don't worry about the Nets, they are fine" I'm thinking you might be biased.

[JMT]

It's America. Everyone should have the opportunity to destroy the future of as many NBA franchises as they can.

[It's A VC3!!!]

Lol at SAS "The Knicks are straight garbage". He's always degrading the Knicks and bailing the Nets out. He even said yesteday that the Nets are "not done" but the Knicks are "done". :lol



He's on some Net propoganda shit lately so I'm not sure whether this is what people told him or this is what he wants to push to discredit the Knicks. For about the last week he's refused to criticize the Nets except for 30 seconds of the show then back to Knick bashing. If you came out of last night's games with 95% of your criticism at the Knicks and "don't worry about the Nets, they are fine" I'm thinking you might be biased.
Him and Charles Barkley are the same. They shred the Knicks when they under-perform and bail the Nets out when they under-perform. It's hilarious.:lol

[SilkkTheShocker]

Also LeBron views Knicks as "straight garbage" and has crossed them off his list.



:oldlol: :oldlol: :oldlol: :oldlol: :oldlol: :oldlol: :oldlol:

[niko]

Lol at SAS "The Knicks are straight garbage". He's always degrading the Knicks and bailing the Nets out. He even said yesteday that the Nets are "not done" but the Knicks are "done". :lol



Him and Charles Barkley are the same. They shred the Knicks when they under-perform and bail the Nets out when they under-perform. It's hilarious.:lol
He's doing it to basically push the agenda that PP and KG are heroically trying their best but the other Nets are not helping them. KG COULD HAVE RETIRED BUT NO, HE CAME BACK - JUST FOR THE OTHER NETS AND THEY ARE NOT HELPING HIM. He said that about 20 times the other day.

[longtime lurker]

I question if any team would offer Melo the max at this point in his career? I could see him staying in NY if they throw tons of money at him and ask him to wait a year till all the contracts expire

[RoundMoundOfReb]

I question if any team would offer Melo the max at this point in his career? I could see him staying in NY if they throw tons of money at him and ask him to wait a year till all the contracts expire
LA? Would you want him on the lakers?

[hawkfan]

hawkfan first said Melo will leave for LA, but of course Jim Buss and the Lakers were planning for this when they tendered their offer to Dwight Howard.

[niko]

hawkfan first said Melo will leave for LA, but of course Jim Buss and the Lakers were planning for this when they tendered their offer to Dwight Howard.
You do realize no one listens to you at all, right?

[NugzFan]

I'm surprised people don't get what he's doing.

If melo leaves then he can say "I was first to know! I called it back in November!!" And we will never hear the end of it. He will proclaim himself the guy who first broke the news.

If melo stays he will never bring it up again. It's win win for him

[longtime lurker]

LA? Would you want him on the lakers?

I'm not an idiot like the majority of other fans so of course I'd want him on the Lakers. The questions is though is it worth paying max dollars to Melo when he'll be 30 and you're essentially getting a 1a/1b option instead of a clear cut franchise changing player. With his reputation and the way the rest of the league sees him I can't see a lot of teams throwing max money his way.

[bagelred]

OK, let's be honest. Do I want Melo to resign? Yes. If Melo's on your team, the team will automatically be relevant, he's still fairly young etc.

Would I be upset if he left? No. Because, for the same reason, he isn't THAT young, he has shoulder issues, AND if Melo leaves....the Knicks have MEGA MEGA cap space in summer 2015. Almost a blank slate. So I'm not too worried either way.

But if you asked me...and if I had to place a bet right now, Melo is staying. The ONLY viable option is the Lakers...which is possible. But after you sign Melo AND Kobe...how much cap space will there be? Um....almost zero I'm thinking....so Melo's gonna play with Kobe for 2 years as his skills degrade? Then what?

Melo will stay a Knick next summer, and then Knicks will try to rebuild summer 2015, either with resigning Tyson, going after Love, or whoever else.....

[el gringos]

There's a 100% chance he opts out and then signs a new max deal

There's about a 90% chance he is staying in ny

There's a 10% chance it's a sign and trade somewhere else

0% chance he flat out leaves ny in free agency

Knicks will get Carmelo back or something in return.

[niko]

I'm surprised people don't get what he's doing.

If melo leaves then he can say "I was first to know! I called it back in November!!" And we will never hear the end of it. He will proclaim himself the guy who first broke the news.

If melo stays he will never bring it up again. It's win win for him
I don't think it's that now, i honestly think that he is just trying to make the Knicks look bad and the Nets look good. He's been doing it all season. He made new rules for the Knicks, where even if they win he can bash them (a win is not a win unless he says so). Note that if they lose, they lose, but a win can be a loss too. The Nets, not under this rule. The knicks lose, they suck, the Nets lose - it's early. He even said (exactly this) the Knicks are in a worse situation than the Nets because THEY GAVE UP SO MANY DRAFT PICKS. No team in history has given up more years of picks than the Nets right now. They have no control of their draft for 5 years.

[bagelred]

You guys are forgetting the obvious too. Melo is repped by CAA. CAA and the Knick organization are VERY tight, ridiculously intertwined. It should almost be "The New York Knicks brought to you by CAA". Woodson, Houston, Warkenstein, Melo, JR Smith, Chris Smith, Bargnani, on and on. So you think after establishing this relationship where CAA basically does whatever it wants with the Knicks, CAA will say "Thanks anyway, Dolan! Bye!" You think Melo isn't going to be swayed to stay? AND get more money? AND stay in New York City?

To go to Dallas? What? Why? LaLa wants to go there?

It's Knicks, with outside chance at Lakers. That's it.

[hawkfan]

You do realize no one listens to you at all, right?

Except you, and the proof is that you responded to my post.

:banana:

[RoundMoundOfReb]

What about the Clippers? Not to familiar with their cap situation though.

[RoundMoundOfReb]

I'm not an idiot like the majority of other fans so of course I'd want him on the Lakers. The questions is though is it worth paying max dollars to Melo when he'll be 30 and you're essentially getting a 1a/1b option instead of a clear cut franchise changing player. With his reputation and the way the rest of the league sees him I can't see a lot of teams throwing max money his way.
I sort of agree. Will he be worth 30 some odd million in his mid 30s?? I seriously doubt it.

[DMAVS41]

http://content.sportslogos.net/logos/6/228/full/ifk08eam05rwxr3yhol3whdcm.gif

Please God no.

He's exactly what we don't need.

:facepalm :facepalm :facepalm

[hawkfan]

I don't think it's that now, i honestly think that he is just trying to make the Knicks look bad and the Nets look good. He's been doing it all season. He made new rules for the Knicks, where even if they win he can bash them (a win is not a win unless he says so). Note that if they lose, they lose, but a win can be a loss too. The Nets, not under this rule. The knicks lose, they suck, the Nets lose - it's early. He even said (exactly this) the Knicks are in a worse situation than the Nets because THEY GAVE UP SO MANY DRAFT PICKS. No team in history has given up more years of picks than the Nets right now. They have no control of their draft for 5 years.

Most of their own picks would supposed to be in the 20s range. So when they traded them, they figured they could buy their way back into the draft (which isn't that hard, so long as they offer money to teams).

But if they don't make the playoffs, and lose out on a top lottery pick, yea, then that will be bad.

[niko]

Most of their own picks would supposed to be in the 20s range. So when they traded them, they figured they could buy their way back into the draft (which isn't that hard, so long as they offer money to teams).

But if they don't make the playoffs, and lose out on a top lottery pick, yea, then that will be bad.
Still, i don't see how a valid criticism of the Knick's situation being worse than the Nets being a result of losing picks when they've lost far more picks and we have the same record.

[ispin69]

He should go to a young team like 76ers.

[hawkfan]

He should go to a young team like 76ers.

Detroit is ideal, because they don't have a franchise scorer.
He can play that role.
Then he would have Jennings - the point guard who can get to the rim; Singler - the outside shooter to spread the floor; Smith - the versatile power forward; and Drummond - the big who can score and rebound.

[R.I.P.]

You guys are forgetting the obvious too. Melo is repped by CAA. CAA and the Knick organization are VERY tight, ridiculously intertwined. It should almost be "The New York Knicks brought to you by CAA". Woodson, Houston, Warkenstein, Melo, JR Smith, Chris Smith, Bargnani, on and on. So you think after establishing this relationship where CAA basically does whatever it wants with the Knicks, CAA will say "Thanks anyway, Dolan! Bye!" You think Melo isn't going to be swayed to stay? AND get more money? AND stay in New York City?

To go to Dallas? What? Why? LaLa wants to go there?

It's Knicks, with outside chance at Lakers. That's it.

If Melo had a brain, he

[TheMarkMadsen]

[QUOTE=R.I.P.]If Melo had a brain, he

[R.I.P.]

Detroit is ideal, because they don't have a franchise scorer.
He can play that role.
Then he would have Jennings - the point guard who can get to the rim; Singler - the outside shooter to spread the floor; Smith - the versatile power forward; and Drummond - the big who can score and rebound.

No. Exactly where he doesn

[Brokenbeat]

Still, i don't see how a valid criticism of the Knick's situation being worse than the Nets being a result of losing picks when they've lost far more picks and we have the same record.


this was just posted on hoopsrumors

[QUOTE]Here

[PickernRoller]

People still doubting he's coming to LA...:oldlol: :oldlol:

Although I do hope Dumbtoni gets fired before the fact. Not sure how much we will still owe him if he gets canned.

[R.I.P.]

[QUOTE=Brokenbeat]this was just posted on hoopsrumors: Here