PDA

View Full Version : HOF with no all nba selections?



get these NETS
12-24-2013, 07:38 PM
nba players who made basketball hof with no all nba selections?


you figure that reggie miller would not have any nba first team selections cause of MJ


Rodman won't have any all nba selections


I don't know if there were 2 all nba teams selected in Wilt's day and not sure when it was changed to 3 full all nba teams but can you think of other players who got int the hall without making first team ever......or without making any of the teams?

do you think that you're a legit hof without ever being one of the best five players in the league? (with the defensive specialists as exceptions)

NumberSix
12-24-2013, 07:53 PM
Has Wade had any 1st team selections?

Yankstar
12-24-2013, 07:54 PM
Has Wade had any 1st team selections?

He has a legit excuse: Kobe Bean Bryant
:bowdown:

NumberSix
12-24-2013, 07:56 PM
He has a legit excuse: Kobe Bean Bryant
:bowdown:
Wade has been jobbed quite a few times. If Durant ever does deserve it, he'll get jobbed too.

moe94
12-24-2013, 07:57 PM
Wade is only first team twice.

fpliii
12-24-2013, 08:00 PM
Wade is only first team twice.

Huge travesty. Shawn Marion never making an All-Defensive Team is probably worse, though.

L.Kizzle
12-24-2013, 08:12 PM
nba players who made basketball hof with no all nba selections?


you figure that reggie miller would not have any nba first team selections cause of MJ


Rodman won't have any all nba selections


I don't know if there were 2 all nba teams selected in Wilt's day and not sure when it was changed to 3 full all nba teams but can you think of other players who got int the hall without making first team ever......or without making any of the teams?

do you think that you're a legit hof without ever being one of the best five players in the league? (with the defensive specialists as exceptions)
There are tons of Hall of Famers without a First team selection.

Nate Thurmond comes to mind, but him having to battle Kareem, Wilt and Russell there is an exception made for him. He has no second teams either.

Jame Worthy has none, Robert Parsih none I don't think. Sam Jones, Hal Greer, Dave DeBusschere, Baily Howell, Joe Dumars, ect.

Hamtaro CP3KDKG
12-24-2013, 08:18 PM
Huge travesty. Shawn Marion never making an All-Defensive Team is probably worse, though.
No it isnt
In 05 he wasnt at that level
In 06 Kobe and Nash were better in the RS
In 07 and 08 he was injured
In 09 and 10 he got it he robbed CP3 in 09 he was better
In 11 CP3, Kobe and Rose were better in the RS
In 12 CP3 and Kobe were better
Last season there were a few better

fpliii
12-24-2013, 08:19 PM
No it isnt
In 05 he wasnt at that level
In 06 Kobe and Nash were better in the RS
In 07 and 08 he was injured
In 09 and 10 he got it he robbed CP3 in 09 he was better
In 11 CP3, Kobe and Rose were better in the RS
In 12 CP3 and Kobe were better
Last season there were a few better

What the **** is wrong with you?

Hamtaro CP3KDKG
12-24-2013, 08:21 PM
What the **** is wrong with you?
Everything I said was fact. You Wade fans are fcking delusional.
Of course yous the same nikka who thinks Anthony Davis is better than KD:roll: :roll: :roll:

moe94
12-24-2013, 08:25 PM
No it isnt
In 05 he wasnt at that level
In 06 Kobe and Nash were better in the RS
In 07 and 08 he was injured
In 09 and 10 he got it he robbed CP3 in 09 he was better
In 11 CP3, Kobe and Rose were better in the RS
In 12 CP3 and Kobe were better
Last season there were a few better
:biggums:

get these NETS
12-24-2013, 08:26 PM
Shawn Marion never making an All-Defensive Team is probably worse, though.

marion never made all defense??

looking it up and bowen and ak-47 seemed to have gotten knod consistently over marion??? raja bell?

nba is really a joke


hard to take this shit seriously

Hamtaro CP3KDKG
12-24-2013, 08:27 PM
marion never made all defense??

looking it up and bowen and ak-47 seemed to have gotten knod consistently over marion??? raja bell?

nba is really a joke


hard to take this shit seriously
AK and Bowen were better defenders than Marion:biggums:
how the fck is that a joke:biggums:

get these NETS
12-24-2013, 08:30 PM
There are tons of Hall of Famers without a First team selection.

Nate Thurmond comes to mind, but him having to battle Kareem, Wilt and Russell there is an exception made for him. He has no second teams either.

Jame Worthy has none, Robert Parsih none I don't think. Sam Jones, Hal Greer, Dave DeBusschere, Baily Howell, Joe Dumars, ect.

thanks there are about 6-8 centers of the early 70s era who are in the hall...exceptional amount of players of the same position and roughly same era


Thurmond, in my opinion, is in the ben wallace rodman mold where they largely made/will make the hall because of defense




interesting that worthy has none though

dumars was never a superstar to me.....



interesting list

moe94
12-24-2013, 08:33 PM
AK and Bowen were better defenders than Marion:biggums:
how the fck is that a joke:biggums:

Look at Kobe's all defensive first team nods. Is he really the GOAT perimeter defender?

get these NETS
12-24-2013, 08:35 PM
AK and Bowen were better defenders than Marion:biggums:
how the fck is that a joke:biggums:


bowen was over rated..and dirty

ak was pretty good defender....great instincts....foot speed.and long limbs


marion to me was a better defender than either guy..better all around player also

marion is the closest thing to pippen since pippen......not quite the ball handler or distributor but to me not that far from pipp defensively

Yankstar
12-24-2013, 08:35 PM
Look at Kobe's all defensive first team nods. Is he really the GOAT perimeter defender?


Yes, most all nba first defensive teams seems to indicate that he is indeed up there with the GOAT defenders :pimp:

moe94
12-24-2013, 08:39 PM
Yes, most all nba first defensive teams seems to indicate that he is indeed up there with the GOAT defenders :pimp:

Would you say Kobe is a top 5 perimeter defender of all time? His accolades suggest he's of that caliber, at worst.

get these NETS
12-24-2013, 08:42 PM
kobe kg and duncan got some accolades off of reputation


seeing that marion has never gotten an all defense selection makes it a joke

Stringer Bell
12-24-2013, 08:44 PM
nba players who made basketball hof with no all nba selections?


you figure that reggie miller would not have any nba first team selections cause of MJ


Rodman won't have any all nba selections


I don't know if there were 2 all nba teams selected in Wilt's day and not sure when it was changed to 3 full all nba teams but can you think of other players who got int the hall without making first team ever......or without making any of the teams?

do you think that you're a legit hof without ever being one of the best five players in the league? (with the defensive specialists as exceptions)

It's not just because of Jordan. All-NBA teams just pick 2 guards and 2 forwards regardless of PG or SG, SF or PF.

There were a number of guards better than Reggie so it's no surprise.


Dennis Rodman: 3rd Team- 1991-92 and 1994-95
Reggie Miller: 3rd Team- 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1997-98.

NumberSix
12-24-2013, 08:44 PM
Would you say Kobe is a top 5 perimeter defender of all time? His accolades suggest he's of that caliber, at worst.
Fffffffcuk no. :roll:

Most of the best perimeter defenders are defensive specialists. Not the superstar scoring guys.

The Heat alone have 3 guys who are better all time perimeter defenders than Kobe. Michael and Scottie are both better than Kobe. Tony Allen in his prime is way better than Kobe ever was. Artest is better. Payton is better. Stockton is better. Moncrief. Kobe is not even close to sniffing top 10.

moe94
12-24-2013, 08:45 PM
Kobe is not even close to sniffing top 10.

I know, which makes it that much funnier.

fpliii
12-24-2013, 08:48 PM
Would you say Kobe is a top 5 perimeter defender of all time? His accolades suggest he's of that caliber, at worst.

Definitely not. To be fair, most superstar offensive wings are overrated defensively. I don't know if MJ is a top 5 perimeter defender all=time either (though he was a much better help defender than Kobe, so that helps his case).

The top 5 perimeter defenders ever are most likely defensive specialists/role players.

NumberSix
12-24-2013, 08:54 PM
Definitely not. To be fair, most superstar offensive wings are overrated defensively. I don't know if MJ is a top 5 perimeter defender all=time either (though he was a much better help defender than Kobe, so that helps his case).

The top 5 perimeter defenders ever are most likely defensive specialists/role players.
Its kinda hard to compare defenders across different eras because the rules are so different. If LeBron and Wade were allowed to play physical defense like Jordan's era, they'd be so much better man defenders than they are currently allowed by the rules.

fpliii
12-24-2013, 08:56 PM
Its kinda hard to compare defenders across different eras because the rules are so different. If LeBron and Wade were allowed to play physical defense like Jordan's era, they'd be so much better man defenders than they are currently allowed by the rules.

Probably, but they're both great help defenders, and team D is more impactful than help D.

Either way, they're both tremendous two-way players who would be great in any era.

get these NETS
12-24-2013, 09:02 PM
It's not just because of Jordan. All-NBA teams just pick 2 guards and 2 forwards regardless of PG or SG, SF or PF.

There were a number of guards better than Reggie so it's no surprise.


Dennis Rodman: 3rd Team- 1991-92 and 1994-95
Reggie Miller: 3rd Team- 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1997-98.

thanks for correction

inclinerator
12-24-2013, 09:25 PM
What the **** is wrong with you?
:lol

Stringer Bell
12-24-2013, 09:46 PM
thanks for correction

No problem, I like this topic.

Adrian Dantley: 2nd Team in 1980-81 and 1983-84.
Bill Bradley: Never made any All-NBA teams.
Dave DeBusschere: 2nd Team in 1968-69
Calvin Murphy: Never made any All-NBA teams.
Frank Ramsey: Never made any All-NBA teams

Droid101
12-24-2013, 09:51 PM
No problem, I like this topic.

Adrian Dantley: 2nd Team in 1980-81 and 1983-84.
String laying down the knowledge.

La Frescobaldi
12-24-2013, 11:16 PM
Probably, but they're both great help defenders, and team D is more impactful than help D.

Either way, they're both tremendous two-way players who would be great in any era.
So was Bryant.

get these NETS
12-24-2013, 11:35 PM
No problem, I like this topic.

Adrian Dantley: 2nd Team in 1980-81 and 1983-84.
Bill Bradley: Never made any All-NBA teams.
Dave DeBusschere: 2nd Team in 1968-69
Calvin Murphy: Never made any All-NBA teams.
Frank Ramsey: Never made any All-NBA teams


the same way I wrote about a group of hof centers playing around the same time


those 2nd team all nba years of dantley's roughly coincide with golden era for small forwards

even though all nba team isn't specific about 1 small f 1 power f. would be interesting to see how many of those 1980s beast small forwards ever made all nba and which ones got into the hall....

bird is hof, alex english is in, dantley, nique is in, i think king just got in..has to be 6-7 more who put up big numbers that are borderline hof worthy...

L.Kizzle
12-24-2013, 11:39 PM
the same way I wrote about a group of hof centers playing around the same time


those 2nd team all nba years of dantley's roughly coincide with golden era for small forwards

even though all nba team isn't specific about 1 small f 1 power f. would be interesting to see how many of those 1980s beast small forwards ever made all nba and which ones got into the hall....

bird is hof, alex english is in, dantley, nique is in, i think king just got in..has to be 6-7 more who put up big numbers that are borderline hof worthy...
Marques Johnson is the only one not in, and he made a First team. How about those apples.

Doc is in, Mullin is in, Pippen is in. Aguirre is the only one who never made a team and rightfully so, he was the worst of the bunch.

Micku
12-24-2013, 11:39 PM
No problem, I like this topic.

Adrian Dantley: 2nd Team in 1980-81 and 1983-84.
Bill Bradley: Never made any All-NBA teams.
Dave DeBusschere: 2nd Team in 1968-69
Calvin Murphy: Never made any All-NBA teams.
Frank Ramsey: Never made any All-NBA teams

No way! I could've sworn he had more than that.

Anyway, Artis Gilmore technically never received any all "NBA" team. All of his selection was for the ABA.

L.Kizzle
12-24-2013, 11:40 PM
No way! I could've sworn he had more than that.

Anyway, Artis Gilmore technically never received any all "NBA" team. All of his selection was for the ABA.
Kareem and Moses had something to do with that.

Micku
12-24-2013, 11:46 PM
Kareem and Moses had something to do with that.

Yeah. Those are the main ones. He also had a prime Bill Walton in the 70s and Robert Parish 80s. He had some competition.

HurricaneKid
12-25-2013, 12:04 AM
No it isnt
In 05 he wasnt at that level
In 06 Kobe and Nash were better in the RS
In 07 and 08 he was injured
In 09 and 10 he got it he robbed CP3 in 09 he was better
In 11 CP3, Kobe and Rose were better in the RS
In 12 CP3 and Kobe were better
Last season there were a few better

Nash?? Better defender??? Did you know we were talking about defense?

HurricaneKid
12-25-2013, 12:19 AM
Look at Kobe's all defensive first team nods. Is he really the GOAT perimeter defender?

Kobe's career RAPM is NEGATIVE. Which means when you adjust for the players he is against, pace, etc he was a slightly below average defender. Now we all know he was an outstanding M2M defender when motivated. But in his ~100,000+ defensive possessions in the regular season he was statistically a hair below avg as a defender.

All time great? HAHAHAHHAHHHHHhaaahahahaha

Yankstar
12-25-2013, 12:22 AM
Kobe's career RAPM is NEGATIVE. Which means when you adjust for the players he is against, pace, etc he was a slightly below average defender. Now we all know he was an outstanding M2M defender when motivated. But in his ~100,000+ defensive possessions in the regular season he was statistically a hair below avg as a defender.

All time great? HAHAHAHHAHHHHHhaaahahahaha

You Lebron stans and your stats. Kobe was clutch defensively when it mattered and the NBA recognized that. With such an offensive powerhouse which he was and his incredible longevity considering his play style you can't expect him to be on every possession in every regular season same. 5 rings proves he can defend :no:

get these NETS
12-25-2013, 12:51 AM
Marques Johnson is the only one not in, and he made a First team. How about those apples.

Doc is in, Mullin is in, Pippen is in. Aguirre is the only one who never made a team and rightfully so, he was the worst of the bunch.

thanks....forgot about Dr. J......

when a bunch of ringless and not LOCK alltime greats gt into the hall...it makes some of the omissions like Johnson's look suspicious

Aguirre was unguardable...just played in wrong years..as a scorer he was just as skilled as any of those guys..and he had the power/post game too

biggest omission in hof is sidney moncrief...who I always thought was a 3....a legit great two way player.....multiple all nba.....they basically CREATED the dpoy for him

pre-Jordan you could be great at ONE thing..scoring....and never be criticized...Melo is just born in the wrong era...his skillset belongs to that 80s small forward era....he'd be in the HOF...

jlip
12-25-2013, 12:54 AM
I know a couple of Bill Russell's "hall of fame" teammates, Frank Ramsey and K.C. Jones were never even all stars let alone had any all nba selections.

L.Kizzle
12-25-2013, 01:01 AM
thanks....forgot about Dr. J......

when a bunch of ringless and not LOCK alltime greats gt into the hall...it makes some of the omissions like Johnson's look suspicious

Aguirre was unguardable...just played in wrong years..as a scorer he was just as skilled as any of those guys..and he had the power/post game too

biggest omission in hof is sidney moncrief...who I always thought was a 3....a legit great two way player.....multiple all nba.....they basically CREATED the dpoy for him

pre-Jordan you could be great at ONE thing..scoring....and never be criticized...Melo is just born in the wrong era...his skillset belongs to that 80s small forward era....he'd be in the HOF...
Maybe worst is bad wording when describing Aguirre. I would take him last out of the top SFs of the 80s. He'd come behind Bird, Doc, King, Wilkins, English, Dantley and Johnson. You could argue that Kiki Vandeweghe was better than Aguirre.

La Frescobaldi
12-25-2013, 01:19 AM
I know a couple of Bill Russell's "hall of fame" teammates, Frank Ramsey and K.C. Jones were never even all stars let alone had any all nba selections.
how is Ramsay, a guard, going to get on an all-nba team with a league carrying Bill Sharman & Bob Cousy just ON HIS OWN TEAM

How is KC going to make a team sitting behind those two then with a teammate named Sam Jones and with Jerry West & Oscar Robertson to boot in that same league?

La Frescobaldi
12-25-2013, 01:20 AM
Maybe worst is bad wording when describing Aguirre. I would take him last out of the top SFs of the 80s. He'd come behind Bird, Doc, King, Wilkins, English, Dantley and Johnson. You could argue that Kiki Vandeweghe was better than Aguirre.

Early days Kiki was heading towards legendary. Back problems changed that and it is truly too bad.

L.Kizzle
12-25-2013, 01:24 AM
how is Ramsay, a guard, going to get on an all-nba team with a league carrying Bill Sharman & Bob Cousy just ON HIS OWN TEAM

How is KC going to make a team sitting behind those two then with a teammate named Sam Jones and with Jerry West & Oscar Robertson to boot in that same league?
They shouldn't be in the Hall of Fame period. Unless you want to base there selection on there collegiate career.

Ramsey is in as being the first great sixth man, so I give him that. But KC Jones, always wondered about that. I know he was known more as a defender, so he must have been that great to be in the Hall.

ILLsmak
12-25-2013, 01:52 AM
nba players who made basketball hof with no all nba selections?


you figure that reggie miller would not have any nba first team selections cause of MJ


Rodman won't have any all nba selections


I don't know if there were 2 all nba teams selected in Wilt's day and not sure when it was changed to 3 full all nba teams but can you think of other players who got int the hall without making first team ever......or without making any of the teams?

do you think that you're a legit hof without ever being one of the best five players in the league? (with the defensive specialists as exceptions)

I think an All-NBA D, esp many of them, counts as something. It's still an all-nba selection.

I'd say nobody in the HOF has made it without ever being on an all-nba team, but I could be wrong.

-Smak

scm5
12-25-2013, 07:16 AM
Phil Jackson