The eye-test GOAT top 10

[Mr. Jabbar]

1-Jordan
2-Magic
3-Kobe
4-KAJ
5-Shaq
6-Bird
7-Olajuwon
8-Wilt
9-Russell
10-Duncan

[plowking]

You forgot one OP:

0.9 - Lebron

I got you doe. Don't sweat it.

[Deuce Bigalow]

George is rolling over in his grave :cry:

[LongLiveTheKing]

Eye test = youtube videos

How is does Tim Duncan pass the eye test lol?

[TheMilkyBarKid]

Op was kicked in the head as a young child

[funnystuff]

Op is a young child

[LongLiveTheKing]

OP was just waiting for someone to say Lebron should be there :oldlol:

[215Philly]

Eye test = youtube videos

How is does Tim Duncan pass the eye test lol?
:roll: same with Wilt & Russell, he never seen them play. This is weak trolling :no:

[ImKobe]

Eye test?

1.Kobe



































2. MJ
3.Kareem
4.Bird
5.Magic
6.Shaq
7.Duncan
8.Hakeem
9.Lebron
10.Wilt

[Eric Cartman]

Iverson has to be there if the criteria is the eye test.

[JohnFreeman]

1-Jordan
2-KAJ
3-Magic
4-Bird
5-Russell
6-Shaq
7-Duncan
8-LeBron
9-West
10-Olajuwon
15. Kobe

[Trentknicks]

You can be funny at times OP but your a 5 year old little bitch when it comes to anything Kobe/Dwight related.

[cos88]

the only kind of top 10 that kobe is top 5 ... the eye test.

[alenleomessi]

t-mac would be there

[JUDGE WITNESS]

1-lebron
2-Magic
3-jordan
4-KAJ
5-Shaq
6-Bird
7-Olajuwon
8-Wilt
9-Russell
10-Duncan

[the mesiah]

1.that guy from Wilmington,NC who wore 23 at Laney
2.earvin Johnson
3.larry bird
4.lew Alcindor
5.wilton chamberlain
6.oscar Robertson
7.kobe bean
8.william Russell
9.big fundamental
10.big Aristotle

[#number6ix#]

How can you put guys that you never seen play, outside of highlights, in your top ten???

[TheOne]

1. MJ
2. KAJ
3. Magic
4. Bird
5. LJ
6. Shaq
7. Wilt
8. Russell
9. Duncan
10. Dream

[Nick Young]

1-Jordan
2-Magic
3-Kobe
4-KAJ
5-Shaq
6-Bird
7-Olajuwon
8-Wilt
9-Russell
10-Duncan
amazing list
10/10
will read again


Only qualm is Jordan over Kobe. IMO Jordans only advantage on mamba is stats.

Kobe takes harder shots and does more miraculous plays on a game by game basis then jordan did.

[dabigbaws]

1. jordan
2. magic
3. kaj
4. bird
5. wilt
6. shaq
7. russell
8. perkins
9. kobe
10. duncan

[LAZERUSS]

I wonder how many living opposing players that actually played against him would have Wilt ranked as low as the posters here that didn't see him play?

[dr.hee]

Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt, my god, a hobbled Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt, H2H against Thurmond Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt, lowest teammate's TS%...Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt, hell even Bill Russell, Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt , worst supporting cast Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt, no case for Hakeem, Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt, dominating Kareem H2H Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt , Olajuwon not outplaying Shaq Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt, so we're not counting FG%? Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt Wilt

:applause:

[salwan]

1. Rondo
2. Jordan
3. kaj
4. bird
5. wilt
6. magic
7. russell
8. shaq
9. kobe
10. duncan
11. hakeem

[kurple]

whos eyes? cause kobe isnt even top 15 with my eye-test

[Odinn]

I won't be even bothering about weak trolling attempt about Jordan-Bryant-James. But still it's an eye-test but Magic>Bird? Right. :lol

[GOATbe]

1-Jordan
2-Magic
3-Kobe
4-KAJ
5-Shaq
6-Bird
7-Olajuwon
8-Wilt
9-Russell
10-Duncan
:roll: :roll: :roll:

[dr.hee]

I don't know...eye-test is nice and everything...but isn't there strong empirical evidence that Wilt slept with at least 20,000 mountain lions and killed a woman with his bare hands?

[kuniva_dAMiGhTy]

I don't know...eye-test is nice and everything...but isn't there strong empirical evidence that Wilt slept with at least 20,000 mountain lions and killed a woman with his bare hands?

:roll:

[dr.hee]

:roll:

Why are you laughing? What about bowing down to Wilt's greatness instead? There's a newspaper article (will post later) about Wilt receiving the ten commandmends. When his teammates continued to shoot a horrible TS% (even though the 5th article clearly stated "Thou shall not shoot worse than the league average"), he dunked his point guard so hard through a basket that he broke his toe (the player, not Wilt). You can even visit the site of the impact today if you want to :cheers:

http://web.ard.de/galerie/content/nothumbs/default/1033/media/16609_05krater.jpg

[SexSymbol]

Im not doing top 10, but from what I've seen or heard I could say these are interchangeble:

MJ, Kobe, Barkley, Iverson, Carter, Rodman
MJ and Kobe obviously for superior athletic abilities and skill to go with it, Jordan's leaps were more interesting, Kobe's long range shooting is a thing of beauty.
Barkley just for the fact that he looked like a fat midget and outrebounded everybody, that's some funny shit.
Carter no explanation needed, best dunker ever and it's not even close.
Rodman, basically a homer pick, as I think he's really underrated all-time, have him in my top 25. He's not helping his image with the recent meltdowns tho

[Flush]

Im not doing top 10, but from what I've seen or heard I could say these are interchangeble:

MJ, Kobe, Barkley, Iverson, Carter, Rodman

:coleman:
Those new guys ain't impressing me.

[ArbitraryWater]

So this is most aesthetically pleasing/highlight reel top 10?

How do you explain Duncan being 10 then? Please stick to the better material.

[SexSymbol]

:coleman:
Those new guys ain't impressing me.
So you're saying that VC and Iverson have no cases for the eye-test top 10? That's basically top 10 in which people impress you the most with things they do on the court, no accomplisments, stats or anything of that stuff included.

I could understand picking on Rodman as he's a defensive player, and that's just a homer pick from me, because I love to watch games of him playing. He used to pass up on lay-ups, how is that not entertaining

[Psileas]

I wonder how many living opposing players that actually played against him would have Wilt ranked as low as the posters here that didn't see him play?

You may even forget players. Just google phrases like "I've seen Wilt play" by fans in various message boards and see where they rank him. He's almost invariably either at or very close to the very top.

[Genaro]

No order
MJ
Magic
Kobe
Bird
Dr J
Iverson
Shaq
Hakeem
Dirk
Garnett

[Mr. Jabbar]

guys, this is the top 10 goat ordered by eye test, not the eye test goaat 10, anyway, i negged everyone dissing my rank, will do again after 24 hrs

[Thechosen1]

eye test?

MJ
Hakeem
Allen Iverson
Chris Paul
Kobe Bryant
Lebron James
Shaq
Tim Duncan
Dirk

[Black and White]

Good list Mr.Jabbar, I would put Hakeem higher though, he had one of the most beautiful games to watch.

[ArbitraryWater]

guys, this is the top 10 goat ordered by eye test, not the eye test goaat 10, anyway, i negged everyone dissing my rank, will do again after 24 hrs

accepting criticism isn't your thing huh?

[bigkingsfan]

#1 Parsons, who cares about the rest.

[fpliii]

Hm, I don't know which way I'd go with this. So, we're throwing accolades, numbers, and rings out the window...if I'm putting together an eye test only list, what impresses me more? Skillset or dominance? Obviously both would matter, but how much I weight each would change the makeup of the list drastically.

I think it's rather likely this list would look very different than posters' top 10s. Might be little or no overlap.

[shaq2000]

Mikan
Cousy
Pettit
Oscar
Russell
Wilt
Baylor
Arizin
Fulks
Schayes

From my own two eyes.

[BuffaloBill]

Frobe >

[Eric Cartman]

Mikan
Cousy
Pettit
Oscar
Russell
Wilt
Baylor
Arizin
Fulks
Schayes

From my own two eyes.

You old bastard :lol