Most discussion worthy top 10 list EVER? LMAO (NBA.com)

[TheMarkMadsen]

This ****ing list :roll:


1) Magic
2) Shaq
3) MJ
4) Kobe
5) Lebron
6) Hakeem
7) Bird
8) Oscar
9) KAJ
10) Duncan

11) Wilt
12) Russell


If you read the descriptions and reasoning behind the pick it honestly sounds like it was written by a 14 year old

The entire Jordan section basically just says "media hype"

Shaqs sections says he would average 50 points and 20 rebounds per game in the 60's, then leaves Wilt out of the top 10 (the guy who actually did it)

Describes KAJ as if he was Robert Horry

here's this ****ing logical gem for explaining why Oscar Robertson is # 8

[QUOTE][B] I wasn

[Smook A.]

NBA is on some drugs

[RightToCensor]

:biggums:






























Kobe > Lebron?

[sd3035]

seems pretty good, except I would bump Bird up to #5

[kuniva_dAMiGhTy]

OP only made this topic, because he got excited seeing Kobe top 4. :oldlol:

[sd3035]

Jordan was a glorified Carmelo Anthony playing in a cupcake league, he'd be a good 2nd option in today's NBA

[Eric Cartman]

Kareem at 9 is mind****ing me right now ...

[funnystuff]

OP only made this topic, because he got excited seeing Kobe top 4. :oldlol:
This x100

[Marlo_Stanfield]

Jordan was a glorified Carmelo Anthony playing in a cupcake league, he'd be a good 2nd option in today's NBA
http://cdn.niketalk.com/2/2f/350x700px-LL-2ff5111e_michael-jordan-laughing.gif

[SilkkTheShocker]

Wilt, Kobe, and Russell are way too high

[Illuminati]

Lmao @ Kobe over LeBron.

[TheMarkMadsen]

OP only made this topic, because he got excited seeing Kobe top 4. :oldlol:

Damn, caught red handed


can't believe NBA.com posted this

:facepalm

[Mr. Jabbar]

decent ranking, 4 tweaks needed; shaq goes lower, jordan at 1 and kaj goes higher, wipe lebron out of the list, rest is kinda good.

[215Philly]

Jordan was a glorified Carmelo Anthony playing in a cupcake league, he'd be a good 2nd option in today's NBA
:lol

[Smook A.]

Jordan was a glorified Carmelo Anthony playing in a cupcake league, he'd be a good 2nd option in today's NBA
One of the dumbest comments I've read in the month of February

[Warfan]

About Kareem:

The only thing that diminishes Kareem was the fact that he never definitively was the best player on any of his championship teams

:biggums: :facepalm

[fpliii]

It would be discussion worthy if the guy had any credibility. This is just some random guy throwing shit against the wall and hoping it sticks.

[Prometheus]

"[LeBron] has instinctive court vision that only Magic Johnson can rival." :facepalm :facepalm :facepalm :facepalm :facepalm

LeBron is a great passer, but my god this is blasphemy. Writer obviously has tip-of-the-iceberg knowledge of NBA history.

[NumberSix]

"[LeBron] has instinctive court vision that only Magic Johnson can rival." :facepalm :facepalm :facepalm :facepalm :facepalm

LeBron is a great passer, but my god this is blasphemy. Writer obviously has tip-of-the-iceberg knowledge of NBA history.
Why exactly?

[TheMarkMadsen]

It would be discussion worthy if the guy had any credibility. This is just some random guy throwing shit against the wall and hoping it sticks.

Being on NBA.com unfortunately gives it some sort of credibility, at least to some uninformed teenager surfing the web looking for all time list :(

I just can't believe NBA.com posted this, I mean the guy ranking the players doesn't even follow his own criteria from player to player

KAJ @ 9

:hammerhead:

[Prometheus]

Why exactly?

:biggums:

[TheMarkMadsen]

:biggums: :facepalm


:roll:


This list legitimately pissed me off :lol

[fpliii]

Being on NBA.com unfortunately gives it some sort of credibility, at least to some uninformed teenager surfing the web looking for all time list :(

I just can't believe NBA.com posted this, I mean the guy ranking the players doesn't even follow his own criteria from player to player

KAJ @ 9

:hammerhead:
lol I guess so, but it seems like this comes from a blog on the Orlando Magic sub-site.

Some people here have preferences/agendas, but anyone who isn't an obvious troll on ISH could put together a better list.

[Jameerthefear]

that's by our guy too.......

[Warfan]

:roll:


This list legitimately pissed me off :lol

:lol cant believe this dipshit actually published that

[TheMarkMadsen]

that's by our guy too.......

http://stream1.gifsoup.com/view1/1088087/damn-o.gif

[Psileas]

Who is supposed to be this Cohen guy, anyway?

[JohnFreeman]

Probably one of the worst lists I have seen.

[DMV2]

Who is supposed to be this Cohen guy, anyway?
Probably an intern for the Magic, based on that piece.

[BuffaloBill]

terrible list. lebron belongs nowhere near the top 5 :facepalm

[WallIn]

:oldlol: worst top 10 ever

[ArbitraryWater]

Read this couple months ago, joke list.

Wrong all over the place.

[LAZERUSS]

lol I guess so, but it seems like this comes from a blog on the Orlando Magic sub-site.

Some people here have preferences/agendas, but anyone who isn't an obvious troll on ISH could put together a better list.

You could put the names of every NBA player whoever played, into a hat, and blindly pull them out, and come up with a better list.

[LEFT4DEAD]

You know what the most funny thing on 90% of lists like this one is?
That almost everybod has Magic over Bird even though it was very clear, even among the media at the time that Bird is the better player between those two.

Only thing that I like on that shitty list is that Russell is not listed as top 5 player. Every thing other than that one is a huge miss.