In all seriousness, who the heck will win Rookie of the Year?

[PleezeBelieve]

MCW: 16.7 ppg 6.2 apg 6.1 rpg 39%, Philly has lost 25 in a row

Oladipo: 14.0 ppg 4.2 apg 4.1 rpg 41%, Magic 20-52


:confusedshrug:

[fiddy]

id give it to MCW

[Smook A.]

Dipo.

[Myth]

Early on it was clearly MCW, but the losing streak and stretches of missing games have pulled Oladipo even.

[coin24]

MCW or hardaway jr

[JohnFreeman]

MCW I suppose. None of them deserve it

[Magic731]

MCW easily. Philly still lose 25 in a row if you swap MCW and Dipo.

[treadster]

MCW, he have a better year. the W-L record doesn't really mean a thing if both teams suck.

[Olacinco]

MCW easily. Philly still lose 25 in a row if you swap MCW and Dipo.

:facepalm

If dipo replaced MCW he'd be averaging 22/8/6 :facepalm

Sixers would have atleast 5 wins :facepalm

He'd probably have 6 trip dubs by now too :facepalm

[fiddy]

:facepalm

If dipo replaced MCW he'd be averaging 22/8/6 :facepalm

Sixers would have atleast 5 wins :facepalm

He'd probably have 6 trip dubs by now too :facepalm
sure sure :roll: :roll:

[Random_Guy]

Dipo, I would give it to MCW but when you are on the verge of breaking the histroical losing streak, well...~

[DukeDelonte13]

i'd go with MCW but it's a tight race.

[Im Still Ballin]

this has been a TERRIBLE rookie class.

question is though, is it the worst of all time?

[Diegio]

Mcw All Day

[dannywpt]

Can you bring in some PER 36 stats? Doesn't MCW play like 40 mins a game and Oladipo play 20-25 off the bench?

[kc16]

I won't be surprised if they give it to both MCW and Oladipo.

[SexSymbol]

Can you bring in some PER 36 stats? Doesn't MCW play like 40 mins a game and Oladipo play 20-25 off the bench?
That is no way of a plus to oladipo. Playing more - more important, better rookie.

MCW is a clear choice

[jbryan1984]

The class is so bad, Bennett might make all rookie first team

[Jameerthefear]

Any dumbass who is saying "clear choice" is so wrong it isn't funny. Dipo should win.

[JohnFreeman]

Put Dipo on 76ers, and I think he would average 18+

[Basketbolero]

Put Dipo on 76ers, and I think he would average 18+
This. Stats are so inflated on that Sixers team. Oladipo has been better than MCW since January and should be ROY.

[fiddy]

Put Dipo on 76ers, and I think he would average 18+
on 25% fg :bowdown:

[KyrieTheFuture]

Is this the worst ROY winner of the last like 20 years?

[Basketbolero]

Is this the worst ROY winner of the last like 20 years?
Easily. You'd need to go back to 2001 to find something similar. Another Magic player, Mike Miller, won it back then putting up something like 11-4-2 but at least his team was somewhat decent, even if it was only because they had T-Mac.

[RIP CITY]

Not a fan of either players but I'd give it to Oladipo.

[Andrei89]

What a terrible fling rookie class man.

Embarrassing.

I still believe Noel could be special if he heals properly and is not going to get injured again.

Noel would have also won this years ROY.

[SexSymbol]

Is this the worst ROY winner of the last like 20 years?
MCW is one of the best rookies ever.

[Basketbolero]

MCW is one of the best rookies ever.
What? :biggums:

[Jameerthefear]

MCW is one of the best rookies ever.
Lol.

[DukeDelonte13]

What a terrible fling rookie class man.

Embarrassing.

I still believe Noel could be special if he heals properly and is not going to get injured again.

Noel would have also won this years ROY.


that's highly doubtful. Skinny as hell with no offensive game whatsoever. He can be a special player someday but he was not about to come into the league and tear it up. He was not NBA ready prospect by any means.

[Andrei89]

that's highly doubtful. Skinny as hell with no offensive game whatsoever. He can be a special player someday but he was not about to come into the league and tear it up. He was not NBA ready prospect by any means.


I do think he would have averaged 10ppg 10 rpg 2 assists and 2 blocks with pretty good defense and win ROY.

Is just my opinion though.

[Wavves]

My ROY is MCW, but its very close.

[Denitron]

Tony Snell :applause: