How underrated is Omer Asik?

[oarabbus]

I know he was a beast last year and nice in Chicago before that. I'm talking about earlier in the year when he was kind of being a b1tch but ppl were talking about him like he's a scrub.

Finally getting minutes, been averaging 10/13 the last two week and puttin up 12/18 on 59%FG over his last 5 games. Yeah, he sucks on offense, but he'll give you 10 points. Not bad for your team's 4th option on offense. And the guy's defense is ****ing solid, possibly elite.

I was shocked the Mavs / T Blazers didn't make a move for him... pretty much most of the Western teams battling for playoffs could really use him right now, plus a few East playoff teams, and even someone like NO. Imagine Asik next to Anthony Davis...

People shoulda made moves.

[no pun intended]

I don't believe he is underrated. Most teams made a move for Asik, but it was Houston who asked for high draft picks. But I guess you could make the case that Asik is worth more than these picks...

[moe94]

Every team needs an Asik.

[AboutBuckets]

A big reason for people discrediting his value (as a trade asset at least) is the financial burden his contract's 'poison pill' structure imposes. If his contract weren't so insane Morey would have had much better offers on the table. Also doesn't help that this is one of the best draft years for GMs to hang on to their 1st rd picks.

[oarabbus]

I don't believe he is underrated. Most teams made a move for Asik, but it was Houston who asked for high draft picks. But I guess you could make the case that Asik is worth more than these picks...

I think NO or maybe the Suns would have came up trading a draft pick, considering they have plenty of young talent. Asik is a guy who can be a "defensive force" in the playoffs, and would be great for most teams really. I think it's all about how much you value defense vs offense (in his case terrible offense)

There are a good number of Cs better than him, but he is an extremely valuable big man for a playoff team. Or a team looking to make the playoffs in the next 2 years. His rebounding is insane, his defense is excellent. 2 categories that are the most important in a C IMO.

[Dengness9]

Invaluable especially if he comes off your bench.

His ridiculous contract is ****ed up doe

[DMAVS41]

Seems properly rated as everyone likes him.

The real question is why sign Howard if you aren't going to trade Asik...

Seems like they should have gone after other free agents or players if they were keeping Asik.

Really dumb move by the Rockets in my opinion. It's redundant and unless they find a home for Asik this off season...next year will be another wasted year because I don't think the Rockets have enough to currently win.

If they had traded Asik...even for 50 cents on the dollar...the cap space alone for this summer would have been worth it.

I proposed a Marion/Dalembert/Larkin trade for Asik in a trade thread earlier and I still maintain that would have been a great trade for both teams.

[brantonli]

Seems properly rated as everyone likes him.

The real question is why sign Howard if you aren't going to trade Asik...

Seems like they should have gone after other free agents or players if they were keeping Asik.

Really dumb move by the Rockets in my opinion. It's redundant and unless they find a home for Asik this off season...next year will be another wasted year because I don't think the Rockets have enough to currently win.

If they had traded Asik...even for 50 cents on the dollar...the cap space alone for this summer would have been worth it.

I proposed a Marion/Dalembert/Larkin trade for Asik in a trade thread earlier and I still maintain that would have been a great trade for both teams.


The Rockets weren't going to miss out on signing a star FA like Howard just to keep Asik. That's just silly. It's like saying you shouldn't go after Kevin Love when your team has a competent PF already. You do your best to get that all-star, and then worry about roster movements.

And frankly, I think it's actually best if the Rockets keep Asik and Howard, you get 48 minutes of great rebounding and solid inside presence. It was Asik who wanted to be traded so badly, but after the deadline, he realised he had to play better to get his trade worth up, so that the Rockets would be willing to deal him.

Also, for the Rockets to benefit from cap space, they would need to trade Lin and Asik together. Just trading one still only alleviates you of $8 million of cap space. Also, most GMs probably don't actually care about the $15 million Asik gets next year, since cap-wise it's only a $8.3 million hit. It's the owners who care, and the GMs are using it as an excuse to lower their bids for Asik.

[JohnFreeman]

I will take him in SAC

[DMAVS41]

The Rockets weren't going to miss out on signing a star FA like Howard just to keep Asik. That's just silly. It's like saying you shouldn't go after Kevin Love when your team has a competent PF already. You do your best to get that all-star, and then worry about roster movements.

And frankly, I think it's actually best if the Rockets keep Asik and Howard, you get 48 minutes of great rebounding and solid inside presence. It was Asik who wanted to be traded so badly, but after the deadline, he realised he had to play better to get his trade worth up, so that the Rockets would be willing to deal him.

Also, for the Rockets to benefit from cap space, they would need to trade Lin and Asik together. Just trading one still only alleviates you of $8 million of cap space. Also, most GMs probably don't actually care about the $15 million Asik gets next year, since cap-wise it's only a $8.3 million hit. It's the owners who care, and the GMs are using it as an excuse to lower their bids for Asik.

I didn't mean it like they shouldn't have gone after Howard...

It just doesn't make sense to hold onto Asik once you get Howard.

think abou the rockets right now. unless something crazy happens...they aren't winning this year.

what about next year? well, they will have the exact same team and will be able to get better at the trade deadline, but I doubt it's enough to put them over the top.

So it seems by keeping Asik they have sacrificed this year and next in terms of winning the title. Seems odd to me...

[bdreason]

I'm glad the Rockets weren't able to get equal value for him in a trade... because it would have netted them a nice player.


The real issue with both Asik and Lin will be next season, when their poison pill contracts cost the team 15m each. I guess at that point they may be able to move them as large expirers though.

[DMAVS41]

I'm glad the Rockets weren't able to get equal value for him in a trade... because it would have netted them a nice player.


The real issue with both Asik and Lin will be next season, when their poison pill contracts cost the team 15m each. I guess at that point they may be able to move them as large expirers though.

They'll be able to move them at the deadline, but just not sure if that will get them enough to put them over the top.

That is why I thought it was paramount to trade Asik this year. 8 million of cap space is still 8 million of cap space.

But It's going to be tough for them regardless...they are going to have to pay Parsons after next year...and I'm not sure Harden/Howard/Parsons is enough to win.

[Milbuck]

Considering that the guy who is supposed to be our defensive anchor would rather try to be the MLK of marijuana than actually contribute to our ****ing basketball team, I'd do just about anything non-James Harden related for Asik.

[SHABBA]

I will take him in SAC
With Boogie? :biggums:

[Artillery]

Seems properly rated as everyone likes him.

The real question is why sign Howard if you aren't going to trade Asik...

Seems like they should have gone after other free agents or players if they were keeping Asik.

Really dumb move by the Rockets in my opinion. It's redundant and unless they find a home for Asik this off season...next year will be another wasted year because I don't think the Rockets have enough to currently win.

If they had traded Asik...even for 50 cents on the dollar...the cap space alone for this summer would have been worth it.

I proposed a Marion/Dalembert/Larkin trade for Asik in a trade thread earlier and I still maintain that would have been a great trade for both teams.

Agreed. Everybody likes Asik - he was never underrated. Problem is Morey won't trade him unless he gets some kind of Harden type steal again. Morey ALWAYS wants to come out the winner in a trade even if it's a detriment to a player on his team(Asik's been pissed all year). Kind of douchebag of a GM.

Compare that to Spurs front office - they knew Scola had value as a player but couldn't afford him(cheap owner). They did the player a favor and traded him to a division rival for cap relief - got raped in that trade but they gave Luis his NBA career. Put Morey in Buford's place and Scola might never have played for an NBA team.

[Marlo_Stanfield]

if he would come to miami i would fap furiously.
Asik and Lin for Bosh:applause: :applause:
Asik alone would be as valuable or more valuable than bosh.
his rim protection is elite and his defense on centers is probably the best in the entire NBA

[Marlo_Stanfield]

New Orleans should have given us Ryan Anderson for him.





Two good PF's who can't exist together on one team....... So stupid.

Asik/Davis would have been so great and Anderson/Howard would have been perfect too..... They just would have had to throw in a center too. Or it would have had to be a three team deal.

But still it allowed Jones to start to reach his potential so win-win.
do you know the guy in your avy puposely stomped on a homeless guy not to long ago??:biggums:

[Fire Colangelo]

if he would come to miami i would fap furiously.
Asik and Lin for Bosh:applause: :applause:
Asik alone would be as valuable or more valuable than bosh.
his rim protection is elite and his defense on centers is probably the best in the entire NBA

Miami gets raped, Houston becomes a contender.

[Marlo_Stanfield]

Miami gets raped, Houston becomes a contender.
no they wont.
Bosh will play an even smaller role in the Rockets system and will nearly only chuck threes.
Miami gets an elite inside presence with rim protection and Centers cant do shit anymore against them, they wont get outreboundet anymore and they get a good defender( elite team defender), elite fastbreak player, good passer and capable shooter in Lin:coleman:
they would roflstomp the league and win 70 games

[Bandito]

if he would come to miami i would fap furiously.
Asik and Lin for Bosh:applause: :applause:
Asik alone would be as valuable or more valuable than bosh.
his rim protection is elite and his defense on centers is probably the best in the entire NBA
Bosh would probably come back to 20 and 10 seeing as he would not be a third best offensive player anymore and play out of position. He would have more time with the ball in his hands too.

The heat get that defensive and rebounding presence they are lacking but loses in the offensive aspect of the court because Asik is not a mid range shooter and the Heat needs one

Lin is not really a factor.

[JohnFreeman]

Asik for Thompson + Mclemore

[Fire Colangelo]

no they wont.
Bosh will play an even smaller role in the Rockets system and will nearly only chuck threes.
Miami gets an elite inside presence with rim protection and Centers cant do shit anymore against them, they wont get outreboundet anymore and they get a good defender( elite team defender), elite fastbreak player, good passer and capable shooter in Lin:coleman:
they would roflstomp the league and win 70 games

Why would Bosh get a smaller role? He's gonna be the 2nd option, at worst 3rd option which is the same as ini Miami. I'd rather throw the ball down low to bosh than Howard tbh, and Bosh has the ability to let it fly from the outside.

Lin is actually a non factor, his production will literally be like chalmers on this Heat team, a 3 point shooter. Unless you prefer Lin to handle the ball instead of Bron, he's gonna be a spot up shooter.

Asik makes them better defensively but let's not act like there are a lot of elite big men nowadays. I mean, what is Asik going to do vs the thunder, shut down Perkins? Heat loses so much spacing on offense and that limits Bron, and especially wade's ability to create.

And their contract is gonna kill Miami next year.

And Lin is gonna be a non factor. Chalmers may not be as good, but he does what he does well. Miami does not need Lin.

[ImKobe]

I'd love Asik on my team (for a reasonable price, of course).

[Marlo_Stanfield]

Why would Bosh get a smaller role? He's gonna be the 2nd option, at worst 3rd option which is the same as ini Miami. I'd rather throw the ball down low to bosh than Howard tbh, and Bosh has the ability to let it fly from the outside.

Lin is actually a non factor, his production will literally be like chalmers on this Heat team, a 3 point shooter. Unless you prefer Lin to handle the ball instead of Bron, he's gonna be a spot up shooter.

Asik makes them better defensively but let's not act like there are a lot of elite big men nowadays. I mean, what is Asik going to do vs the thunder, shut down Perkins? Heat loses so much spacing on offense and that limits Bron, and especially wade's ability to create.

And their contract is gonna kill Miami next year.

And Lin is gonna be a non factor. Chalmers may not be as good, but he does what he does well. Miami does not need Lin.
Lin is the fasted player in the NBA. hes absolutely deadly on fastbreaks, even in houston. imagine him with Bron and Wade.
even if his impact is minimized hes still and elite team defender( solid man to man), good 3 pt shooter and good to elite passer when he handles the ball. Bron lets Shitmers handle the ball often and do the most stupid shit. Shitmers misses LeBron in the PnR at least ten times per game and that is Lins best aspect of his game.
hes also good at passing in the post, which chalmers is absolutely terrible at.
and finally, Lin thrives in an unselfish atmosphere and with good spacing. he would score 15 PPG and 7-8 APG easily.
Asik alone is nearly worth giving Bosh up. i love Bosh but he just is so absymal at post defense and rebounding the Heat wont always be able to overcome that:coleman:

[ABfor3]

He's been good ever since he put on that Rockets uniform..he really protects the paint really well. He seems to be unhappy still but at least he's playing good so his stock is up. Maybe he'll be traded in the offseason since I don't see the Rockets wanting to deal with any chemistry issues next year.