Is Jermaine O'neal a top 5 big man?

[poorlilrich]

With his length, athleticism, and bball IQ he is a beast on the defensive and offensive end. Someone in an another thread made the argument that he is better than Yao. Is he a top 5 big man in the NBA?

Here is how I see it

1- Dirk
2- Duncan
3a- Yao
3b- KG
5-Jermaine or Bosh or Shaq or Amare or Howard ...

[L.Kizzle]

I would say hes right at number 5.

[Shep]

Someone in an another thread made the argument that he is better than Yao
:D

1. kevin garnett
2. dirk nowitzki
3. tim duncan
4. jermaine o'neal

[Zan Tabak]

Here is how I see it

1- Dirk
2- Duncan
3a- Yao
3b- KG
5-Jermaine or Bosh or Shaq or Amare or Howard ...

Can't really argue with that list...Jermaine seems right anywhere between 5 and 8 ....but I would take Howard over all of them just cause of age and unlimited potential...

[DeuceWallaces]

Yeah, but O'Neal is a playoff soft-serve. He maybe 5-8 regular season but he's 12-15 come playoff time.

[haterofhaters]

Can't really argue with that list...Jermaine seems right anywhere between 5 and 8 ....but I would take Howard over all of them just cause of age and unlimited potential...

Potential is an interesting word. Possibility.. Not that i'm comparing the two, but Eddie Curry has the potential to grab 10 boards a game.

[haterofhaters]

Yeah, but O'Neal is a playoff soft-serve. He maybe 5-8 regular season but he's 12-15 come playoff time.
that's being generous.

[Zan Tabak]

Potential is an interesting word. Possibility.. Not that i'm comparing the two, but Eddie Curry has the potential to grab 10 boards a game.

True ..But Howard is way more athletic then Curry ever was...but I guess only time will tell..

[haterofhaters]

True ..But Howard is way more athletic then Curry ever was...but I guess only time will tell..

yeah that's true. Dwight has freakish athleticism, all that is yet to be seen is if he will expand his offensive game.

[AirGauge23]

I think Shaq is proving he deserves to be on that list also.

[Nero]

TD, Dirk, KG, Shaq, Yao, Dwight, Bynum,Boozer, Amare, Brand, Bosh, Camby are all better. Jermaine is about 13th. Probably would take Okafor over him too but have barely seen him play. The league is loaded with good PF/FC/C.

[mid80sjordan]

TD, Dirk, KG, Shaq, Yao, Dwight, Bynum,Boozer, Amare, Brand, Bosh, Camby are all better. Jermaine is about 13th. Probably would take Okafor over him too but have barely seen him play. The league is loaded with good PF/FC/C.
...

[kentatm]

the short answer is NO

[PHXsunsROCK1105]

With his length, athleticism, and bball IQ he is a beast on the defensive and offensive end. Someone in an another thread made the argument that he is better than Yao. Is he a top 5 big man in the NBA?

Here is how I see it

1- Dirk
2- Duncan
3a- Yao
3b- KG
5-Jermaine or Bosh or Shaq or Amare or Howard ...

Um. :roll: Awesome. That's probably the best joke I've heard in a while.

[qwerty]

no. but he is pretty underrated this season.

[Aussie Dunker]

i hope the person who sayd bynum was better than jermaine is in a straight jacket...

[DreamRockets]

top 5 ?

soft, too perimeter oriented, biggest playoffs chokeaholic in the league, top 5 my ass.

[The Italian]

No he is not.

1. Dirk
2. Duncan
3. KG
4. Yao
5. Shaq

Those 5 are all unquestionalby better then him. Add to the mix Bosh, Howard, Boozer, Okafor and Amare who all have an argument at being better then him and he is not top 5.

I would rank him at 7 or 8. I would take Amare over him and possibly Bosh too.

[different107]

No, I would say 9-12 though

[CavaliersFTW]

he still is :D

[b1imtf]

he still is :D
You liked the idea :oldlol:

[IncarceratedBob]

Best center in NBA history with the last name O'Neal not named Shaq

[East_Stone_Ya]

cavsfag :facepalm

[Doctor Rivers]

Goat