Riddle...

[iamgine]

Might be posted before...


Three people; one always tell truth, one always lie, one sometimes truth sometimes lie.

They cannot talk and only give either a thumb or a pinkie as a yes or no. You don't know which finger represent yes or no.


Ask three yes or no questions and find out.

[Jasi]

Does the question need to be addressed at one of them or both (and still count as one question)?

What do we have to find out exactly? Who tells what or what thumb/pinkie means?

[Jasi]

Also can we assume that thumb and pinkie have the same meaning for both?

[iBandwagon]

http://justifiedjerk.com/middle-finger.jpg

[iamgine]

Does the question need to be addressed at one of them or both (and still count as one question)?

What do we have to find out exactly? Who tells what or what thumb/pinkie means?
To only one of them. But you can ask one person more than once.

Who tells what.

[ShackEelOKneel]

To only one of them. But you can ask one person more than once.
Who tells what.

"hint hint"