Who win : "All Big Men vs All PG" ?

[Tycriss]

-Stockthon
-Paul
-Payton
-Big O
-Magic

VS

-Barkley
-Garnett
-Olajuwon
-Duncan
-O'neal

[Akrazotile]

Very tough to say, I actually wish they would do something like this at the allstar game :oldlol:

[AnaheimLakers24]

basketball is a big mans game. barkely is good enough to play point. team 2 in a clean sweep

[Harison]

Bigs sweep. All they need is several players who can dribble, and good team passing, and bigs team have it. Hell, KG even played as a PG for a while.

Game play would be: PGs shoot contested jumpshots, while bigs just pass to anyone in the paint for a lay-up or dunk.

[the mesiah]

BIGS all day, PG's would have to be ON FIRE from 3pt range to win.

[Draz]

Definitely bigs.

[jayfan]

basketball is a big mans game. barkely is good enough to play point. team 2 in a clean sweep

Hakeem would play the point.

[Connor B]

Stupid question :facepalm

[imdaman99]

Bigs should dominate. How are they gonna cover Shaq? Triple team him? Even if the PGs clog the paint, even boxing out might not do any good. Bigs will win a best of 7 in 5 max.

SFs versus Centers should be good. Plenty of SFs that can and did run point. Although Pippen covering Shaq would be an annihilation, or bran on him...they would run things on the other end. Imagine Chris Mullin getting a screen to take nothing but 3s :eek:

[Knicksfever2010]

full court? Point guards win

half court? big men win

[StephHamann]

imagine a lineup

Noah running point center

Bargani and Dirk providing shooting

duncan as PF

howard as rim protector

:lol

[STATUTORY]

the guards can run a full court press but the bigs can just cherry pick their passes all the way up court

to make it more competitive get Jason Kidd in there instead of Payton

what's Payton gonna do? he's a defensive specialist and there's no one he can defend

[STATUTORY]

imagine a lineup

Noah running point center

Bargani and Dirk providing shooting

duncan as PF

howard as rim protector

:lol

:lol dwight howard would still demand post touches, chemistry issues for sure

[G.O.A.T.]

big

[wally_world]

Isiah
Payton
Maravich
Oscar
Magic

Garnett
Dirk
Hakeem
Duncan
Wilt

I would've went with these 2 lineups. Having Stockton is redundant with the amount of ball handling already available. The bigs will triumph, they will get some steals off full court presses but it won't be enough.

[wally_world]

How bout an all undersized vs oversized matchup?

Isiah (I would put Bogues but he's too far off Magic)
Iverson
Elgin Baylor
Barkley
Ben Wallace

vs

Magic
TMac
Durant
Ralph Sampson
Yao