ISH Top 10 All-Time List (Cast Your Vote)

[russwest0]

I will be hosting our ISH Top 10 all time (P.S. F*ck the clowns at Real gay men) :rockon: :rockon: :rockon:

To start vote for your #1 player of all time here by simply posting his name.

Players will be chosen for a spot whenever they appear to be the majority consensus for that spot. When no consensus can be reached we will pick the two highest voted players and have everyone pick one out of those two until a consensus is reached.

Begin by casting your vote for number one.

Current vote totals for #1 ranked player of all time:

Michael Jordan, SG - 16 Magic731, DaSeba5, miles berg, r0drig0lac, stalkerforlife, played0ut, zoom17, Young X, B-hoop, Dro, Smook A., Cold soul, poido123, Destroyer9, scandisk_, jcsrplumply
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, C - 3 DFish24, bballnoob1192, robert_shaww
Bill Russell, C - 2 fpliii, T L P
Matt Bonner, PF - 2, AI Thorton, JerrySeinfeld
Patty Mills, PG - 2 Brizzly, BuffaloBill
Shaquille O'Neal, C - 2 - Lord Bean, Cocaine80s
Kobe Bryant, SG - 1 GODBe
George Mikan, C - 1, Rodmantheman

[fpliii]

Bill Russell

[DFish24]

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar

[Cocaine80s]

No one will respect this thread if it's made by a troll. A respectable green poster should remake this thread and we shall cast our votes in there

[DFish24]

No one will respect this thread if it's made by a troll. A respectable green poster should remake this thread and we shall cast our votes in there

Fpliii maybe?

[russwest0]

No one will respect this thread if it's made by a troll. A respectable green poster should remake this thread and we shall cast our votes in there

A "troll" can't count make a thread and count votes? :lol :lol :facepalm :facepalm

Don't worry bro, you don't have to participate anyways. Ain't nobody trying to see Lavine get votes as the G.O.A.T

[Cocaine80s]

A "troll" can't count make a thread and count votes? :lol :lol :facepalm :facepalm

Don't worry bro, you don't have to participate anyways. Ain't nobody trying to see Lavine get votes as the G.O.A.T
Lol at 5 starring your own thread
1 starred *****ot

[fpliii]

Lol at 5 starring your own thread
1 starred *****ot
I five starred it too. Why hate on russwest? :biggums: He's a chill dude even if you disagree with him.

[AI Thornton]

I vote Matt Bonner.

[bballnoob1192]

No one will respect this thread if it's made by a troll. A respectable green poster should remake this thread and we shall cast our votes in there
:coleman: half the green ****** are alt spammers.

anyways i vote kareem

[T_L_P]

Russell

[Cocaine80s]

I five starred it too. Why hate on russwest? :biggums: He's a chill dude even if you disagree with him.
Not sure if srs

[JerrySeinfeld]

Jordan.

[Magic731]

Michael Jordan.

[russwest0]

Not sure if srs

bro you care way too much about this shit, which is surprising considering how many red bars you have. Most of us decked out in red don't give a shit about the system

[russwest0]

Rodmantheman voted for Westbrook but deleted his post, but that's okay I'll just leave it up there as my vote :applause:

[Rodmantheman]

Rodmantheman voted for Westbrook but deleted his post, but that's okay I'll just leave it up there as my vote :applause:

Mikan:rockon:

[russwest0]

Mikan:rockon:

changing votes? lol ok

[DaSeba5]

Jordan

http://gifrific.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/Michael-Jordan-Dunk-on-Patrick-Ewing.gif

[miles berg]

Michael Jordan

[JerrySeinfeld]

changing votes? lol ok

I would like to change my vote to Matt Bonner.

[miles berg]

Jordan

http://gifrific.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/Michael-Jordan-Dunk-on-Patrick-Ewing.gif

One of the greatest plays in NBA history.

My jaw still drops 20 years later.

[r0drig0lac]

MJ

[stalkerforlife]

Jordan.

[played0ut]

MJ

[stalkerforlife]

Bill Russell

You try so hard to seem different and smart, but you make yourself look silly. You've never even seen a full Russell game. He played in an era where dudes held second jobs because the pay was so bad. Forget international competition, there were barely any Americans that gave a damn about the sport. There were 8-10 teams in the league during his career.

I GUARANTEE you Jordan, a SG, would DEMOLISH Russell IN THE POST.

[played0ut]

How does this work?



How do you factor in votes for other #1 candidates and calculate them to figure out #2-5 or so?

[Magic731]

So Jordan looks to be running away with first place, when does it get locked in and we move onto number 2?

[russwest0]

How does this work?



How do you factor in votes for other #1 candidates and calculate them to figure out #2-5 or so?

the votes for #1 do not carry over to the votes for #2. We will just do a whole new vote then.

[DaSeba5]

Hey can we do more than a top 10? It would be fun to vote on a top 20 or 30, or something like that.

[fpliii]

So Jordan looks to be running away with first place, when does it get locked in and we move onto number 2?
Not sure, russwest is running the show here. Maybe 48 hours for each? :confusedshrug: Or first to a majority after enough votes (say after 30 total votes)?

[zoom17]

MJ

[Magic731]

Not sure, russwest is running the show here. Maybe 48 hours for each? :confusedshrug: Or first to a majority after enough votes (say after 30 total votes)?
Sounds good, I'd say 24 hours is enough though. Thread has potential if monitored correctly.

[russwest0]

yeah 30 total votes seems pretty fair, as long as we have a consensus.

I'd still like to see more people vote before deciding #1 already.

[Lord Bean]

Shaquille O'Neal

[DaSeba5]

Not sure, russwest is running the show here. Maybe 48 hours for each? :confusedshrug: Or first to a majority after enough votes (say after 30 total votes)?

A day or 30 votes is fine. Plus when this thread is done, the next one should have the best picture of the player voted on in the previous thread.

[Young X]

nadroJ leahciM

[russwest0]

Hey can we do more than a top 10? It would be fun to vote on a top 20 or 30, or something like that.

Yeah, after doing the top 10 I can just carry it over into a new thread or something

[Brizzly]

Patty Mills

[B-hoop]

MJ

[Dro]

Jordan....

[played0ut]

You try so hard to seem different and smart, but you make yourself look silly. You've never even seen a full Russell game. He played in an era where dudes held second jobs because the pay was so bad. Forget international competition, there were barely any Americans that gave a damn about the sport. There were 8-10 teams in the league during his career.

I GUARANTEE you Jordan, a SG, would DEMOLISH Russell IN THE POST.

You have a legit question. But Context. Research. Anecdotes from ex-NBA players/coaches.

i.e Red Auerbach said he'd pick MJ over Russell, but would pick Russell over KAreem/Wilt.




Maybe you think athletically Russell can't hack it. Here's Russell going coast to coast.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2AlFrOj5Mc

vs

Joakim Noah coast to coast
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UPfU0NhDxrc





You would agree that Russell doesn't lack in the athleticism department, i'm positive. Now skill.

[quote=article]

[played0ut]

yeah 30 total votes seems pretty fair, as long as we have a consensus.

I'd still like to see more people vote before deciding #1 already.

I personally think we should go by 3-4 tiers. It would be 'fairer' to the NBA players.



i.e Magic vs Timmy vs Shaq for #5, for example.

Magic has most hardware. Timmy most consistent. Shaq best peak. What do the voters value more? :confusedshrug:

They all have more hardware than Wilt. Do we penalize Wilt for playing against the Celtics? Wilt had GOAT peak.




Do we put Kobe lower than Shaq because Shaq had more impact in the 1st three-peat? Or do we put Kobe higher because of longevity and overall hardware? :confusedshrug:

[TheMarkMadsen]

I used to rank Rusell very high.. Until I saw him play. Then I realized that the offense he was playing against was sooo bad, completley lacking in fundementals especially when it comes to foot work/ using your off hand when you go up for a lay up.

[Smook A.]

Michael Jeffrey Jordan

[BuffaloBill]

Patty mills

[Cold soul]

Jordan.

[russwest0]

Updated the OP with the current vote counts.

[Cocaine80s]

bro you care way too much about this shit, which is surprising considering how many red bars you have. Most of us decked out in red don't give a shit about the system
****ing come at me bro ill kick ur ass

[Cocaine80s]

Btw i vote SHaq

[russwest0]

for future reference, I'm going to color the name of the last tallied I vote I did in red. And I'll be going in order of whoever posted in these threads, just in case people want to look ahead and count the votes before I've added them

[stalkerforlife]

No offense to white people, as I am white, but I saw about 8 of them on the court in the Russell highlights.

[russwest0]

****ing come at me bro ill kick ur ass

4628 N. James Ct, Oklahoma City, OK.

I'll be waiting :cheers:

[stalkerforlife]

4628 N. James Ct, Oklahoma City, OK.

I'll be waiting :cheers:

:lebronamazed:

My nig ga :roll:

[GODbe]

Kobe Bryant

[poido123]

Homer pick here

Jordan number 1 :lol

[robert_shaww]

kareem abdul jabbar.

[Destroyer9]

MJ

[scandisk_]

H
I
S

A
I
R
N
E
S
S

[jcsrplumply]

Michelle Jordan

[Cousin Oliver]

Kiki Vandeweghe


:bowdown:

[FKAri]

Kobe "rapist" Bryant

[Round Mound]

Wilt

[MagicMoose]

Kareem