NBA All-Time Greats Pick 'Em

[SouBeachTalents]

Just bold or list the ones you'd pick, then we'll tally the votes up and see who comes out on top in each matchup

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[Roundball_Rock]

Mine (based on careers, not primes):


Just bold or list the ones you'd pick, then we'll tally the votes up and see who comes out on top in each matchup

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[the mesiah]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBronvs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[scandisk_]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

:pimp:

[GODbe]

Just bold or list the ones you'd pick, then we'll tally the votes up and see who comes out on top in each matchup

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

Why have LeBald paired up against Kobe though? Godbe's been manhandling and embarrassing him for years. And career wise it's not even close. Easiest choice on here.

[riseagainst]

Why have LeBald paired up against Kobe though? Godbe's been manhandling and embarrassing him for years. And career wise it's not even close. Easiest choice on here.

:oldlol:
:roll:

[f0und]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[K Xerxes]

In what? Greatest career? In-court ability? One v one?

[MrC1991]

Wilt
Bird
Hakeem
LeBron
Oscar
Malone
Baylor
Dirk
Isiah
Pippen
Wade
Payton

[Kvnzhangyay]

Just bold or list the ones you'd pick, then we'll tally the votes up and see who comes out on top in each matchup

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

Most of these pretty easy imo

[SexSymbol]

Just bold or list the ones you'd pick, then we'll tally the votes up and see who comes out on top in each matchup

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd
*****

[That_Admiral]

Russell
Bird
Shaq
Kobe
Oscar
Barkley
Dr. J
KG
Isiah
Pippen
Barry
Payton

[Psileas]

Going mostly by career

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[LAZERUSS]

We KNOW how the Hakeem-Shaq and Russell-Wilt H2H's went:

http://www.basketball-reference.com/play-index/h2h_finder.cgi?request=1&p1=onealsh01&p2=olajuha01

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Aoy3YD7IdypTdEpOeFRwY29NRTUtWVlFWVJ5TkFDY 3c#gid=0

Both were one-sided.

[SouBeachTalents]

Results thus far

Russell vs. Wilt- Wilt 6-4
Magic vs. Bird- Bird 7-3
Hakeem vs. Shaq- Hakeem 7-3
LeBron vs. Kobe- Tied 5-5
Oscar vs. West- Oscar 7-3
Malone vs. Barkley- Malone 6-4
Baylor vs. Dr. J- Dr. J 8-2
KG vs. Dirk- Dirk 6-4
Isiah vs. Stockton- Tied 5-5
Havlicek vs. Pippen- Pippen 7-3
Wade vs. Barry- Wade 6-4
Payton vs. Kidd- Tied 5-5

[JimmyMcAdocious]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[Harison]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[goldcrow]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[LAZERUSS]

Going mostly by career

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

100% agreed.

The only real close battles would be the Baylor-Dr. J and Oscar-West match-ups. And possibly a peak Barkley-K. Malone.

West was a better playoff performer than Oscar, albeit, he had better teammates in his prime.

[SexSymbol]

100% agreed.
What's the point of replying to yourself?

[MP.Trey]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe so far...
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[LAZERUSS]

What's the point of replying to yourself?

What's the point of making a senseless post?

:facepalm

[Uncle Drew]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[Sakkreth]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[ImKobe]

Just bold or list the ones you'd pick, then we'll tally the votes up and see who comes out on top in each matchup

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

:lebronamazed:

[LeBird]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

Probably a slight bias towards players I saw more of.

[COnDEMnED]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

[ArbitraryWater]

Just bold or list the ones you'd pick, then we'll tally the votes up and see who comes out on top in each matchup

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

..

[SouBeachTalents]

Russell vs. Wilt- Wilt 11-8
Magic vs. Bird- Bird 12-7
Hakeem vs. Shaq- Shaq 11-8
LeBron vs. Kobe- LeBron 10-9
Oscar vs. West- Oscar 13-6
Malone vs. Barkley- Malone 11-8
Baylor vs. Dr. J- Dr. J 17-2
KG vs. Dirk- Dirk 12-7
Isiah vs. Stockton- Isiah 12-7
Havlicek vs. Pippen- Pippen 13-6
Wade vs. Barry- Wade 12-7
Payton vs. Kidd- Payton 10-9

[Champ]

Russell vs. Wilt
Magic vs. Bird
Hakeem vs. Shaq
LeBron vs. Kobe
Oscar vs. West
Malone vs. Barkley
Baylor vs. Dr. J
KG vs. Dirk
Isiah vs. Stockton
Havlicek vs. Pippen
Wade vs. Barry
Payton vs. Kidd

Would have liked to see Moses vs. Kareem added to this, but I digress.