Would you take Russell Westbrook or pre-injury Derrick Rose?

[keep-itreal]

Say you're starting a franchise, which PG would you choose?

[oarabbus]

Derrick Rose, unless I knew how good Westbrook would turn out beforehand, then him.

[JohnFreeman]

Rose

[SamuraiSWISH]

D. Rose pre injury circa 2010 - 2012. Easily. Better temperment for the position, better decision maker. Westbrook isn't far off though given his improvements defensively.

[fiddy]

Rose

[Cocaine80s]

Westbrook

Dude was the best player in the playoffs behind Lebron this year

[Shep]

Rose, but not by much

[TheMilkyBarKid]

Rose.

[buddha]

Westbrook. Nobody wants someone with aspergers leading their team.

[poido123]

Toss the coin.

Westbrook now has defense a level higher than preinjury rose. On the other end they are similar, rose has slightly better court vision.

[NZStreetBaller]

Rose lead his team to the first seed and the ECF without kevin durant.

[keep-itreal]

Rose lead his team to the first seed and the ECF without kevin durant.


:roll: :roll:

[Lebron23]

Derrick Rose.

[Graviton]

Rose lead his team to the first seed and the ECF without kevin durant.
Musta been hard beating the 37 win Pacers and 44 win Hawks. Eastern Conference is serious business. :bowdown:

This year OKC had to face scrub teams like 50 win Grizzlies, 57 win Clippers then 62 win Spurs.

[Collie]

Rose. They're very close as players, but Rose will frustrate me less, and can probably adapt to different lineups better.

[Angel Face]

MVP Derrick Rose would be neck to neck with KD as the best player in the League today if he didn't get injured and rest for 2 years.

1. Kevin Durant / Derrick Rose
3. LeBron
4. Chris Paul