PDA

View Full Version : Overrated-Underrated Player Scale



coolhandsteve
10-08-2014, 03:30 PM
1- Underrated AF
2- Lowkey underrated
3- Properly rated
4- Lowkey overrated
5- Overrated AF

For these players..

Dwight Howard
Rajon Rondo
Steph Curry
Tony Parker
Damian Lillard
LaMarcus Aldridge
Andre Iguodala
Serge Ibaka

..which rating would you give them?

oarabbus
10-08-2014, 03:32 PM
1- Underrated AF
2- Lowkey underrated
3- Properly rated
4- Lowkey overrated
5- Overrated AF

For these players..

Dwight Howard
Rajon Rondo
Steph Curry
Tony Parker
Damian Lillard
LaMarcus Aldridge
Andre Iguodala
Serge Ibaka

..which rating would you give them?

Dwight Howard - 2 been this way since he played for the Lakers
Rajon Rondo - 3 I think everyone knows he's a good player but has been out for a long time
Steph Curry - 2 no bias :D
Tony Parker - 3 (properly rated but not enough recognition)
Damian Lillard 4 he's good, very good... but people talk about him like he's a top 3 PG sometimes
LaMarcus Aldridge - 2
Andre Iguodala - 3
Serge Ibaka - 3

Jlamb47
10-08-2014, 04:47 PM
1- Underrated AF
2- Lowkey underrated
3- Properly rated
4- Lowkey overrated
5- Overrated AF

For these players..

Dwight Howard - 3
Rajon Rondo - 2
Steph Curry - 3
Tony Parker - 2
Damian Lillard - 3
LaMarcus Aldridge - 3
Andre Iguodala - 3
Serge Ibaka - 2

..which rating would you give them?
sss
k

Real14
10-08-2014, 04:48 PM
put Melo in there too.

Melo- 1

SexSymbol
10-08-2014, 04:53 PM
1- Underrated AF
2- Lowkey underrated
3- Properly rated
4- Lowkey overrated
5- Overrated AF

For these players..

Dwight Howard
Rajon Rondo
Steph Curry
Tony Parker
Damian Lillard
LaMarcus Aldridge
Andre Iguodala
Serge Ibaka

..which rating would you give them?

Dwight Howard-4, just doesn't really impact the game that much. Offensively quite a shitty player, defense makes up for it though
Rajon Rondo- 2best court vision in the NBA without any competition
Steph Curry-3, everybody recognizes he's a star, not a superstar, nobody really underrates him
Tony Parker-1, TOP 60 player ever
Damian Lillard -4, hailed as the clutch god after last years PO's
LaMarcus Aldridge - 3, was underrated before last season, got some recognition during it
Andre Iguodala- 3, he's not that good of a player to be underrated or overrated by very much
Serge Ibaka - 3, save as iguadala

Jlamb47
10-08-2014, 04:54 PM
Dwight Howard-4, just doesn't really impact the game that much. Offensively quite a shitty player, defense makes up for it though
Rajon Rondo- 2best court vision in the NBA without any competition
Steph Curry-3, everybody recognizes he's a star, not a superstar, nobody really underrates him
Tony Parker-1, TOP 60 player ever
Damian Lillard -4, hailed as the clutch god after last years PO's
LaMarcus Aldridge - 3, was underrated before last season, got some recognition during it
Andre Iguodala- 3, he's not that good of a player to be underrated or overrated by very much
Serge Ibaka - 3, save as iguadala

Dwight is top 3 centers on offense in the NBA

Cousins
Howard/B Lopez

mehyaM24
10-08-2014, 04:58 PM
Dwight Howard (properly rated)
Rajon Rondo (lowkey overrated, cant shoot)
Steph Curry (lowkey overrated, got exposed this last world tournament)
Tony Parker (underrated AF--best spurs player along with manu for half a decade now)
Damian Lillard (properly rated)
LaMarcus Aldridge (properly rated)
Andre Iguodala (lowkey overrated)
Serge Ibaka (lowkey underrated)

SexSymbol
10-08-2014, 05:02 PM
Dwight is top 3 centers on offense in the NBA

Cousins
Howard/B Lopez
Jefferson, Horford are better
Pekovic and Gasol have much better arsenal, they're just not needed to do that much.
Duncan has been playing as a C for half a decade at least, so he's better too.

Dwight's productivity on offense is probably top 3, it's just that his productivity isn't that impactful when you factor in his terrible FT shooting and him being one of the worst post up guys in the league ATM.