PDA

View Full Version : Starting Five: One player from each era.



Richesly
12-30-2014, 07:23 AM
Rules:
You make a starting five, and one player has to be from one era each. An example.

PG: late 40s - 60s.
SG: 60s - '75
SF: '75 - '88
PF '88 - 2002
C: 2002 - 2014

It doesn't have to be exactly like that, you can switch the eras in the positions up. I'll start.

C: Wilt Chamberlain(60s - '75)
PF: Bob Pettit(40s - 60s)
SF: Larry Bird('75 - '88)
SG: Michael Jordan('88 - '02)
PG: Chris Paul('02 - '14)

What you guys got?

Rolando
12-30-2014, 07:35 AM
Center: Bill Russell 60's
Power Forward: Tim Duncan 00's
Small Forward: Larry Bird 80's
Shooting Guard: Michael Jordan 90's
Point Guard: Nate Archibald 70's

Decent team....:pimp:

SouBeachTalents
12-30-2014, 07:55 AM
C: Kareem
PF: Duncan
SF: Bird
SG: Jordan
PG: Oscar

SHAQisGOAT
12-30-2014, 08:37 AM
C: Shaq ('88 - 2002)
PF: Pettit (late 40s - 60s)
SF: Hondo (60s - '75)
SG: Moncrief ('75 - '88)
PG: Nash (2002 - 2013)

or

C: Kareem (60s - '75)
PF: Duncan (2002 - 2013)
SF: Bird ('75 - '88)
SG: Jordan ('88 - 2002)
PG: West (late 40s - 60s)

KobesFinger
12-30-2014, 08:45 AM
Olajuwon 90s
McHale - 80s
Durant - 00s
West - 60s
Archibald - 70s

Myth
12-30-2014, 11:13 AM
OP should have made it so that there can't be a single year of overlap between players.

Mass Debator
12-30-2014, 11:29 AM
Magic Johnson (80s)
Kobe Bryant (00s)
Elgin Baylor (60s)
Pau Gasol (09-11)
Shaquille Oneal (90s)

:bowdown:

WillC
12-30-2014, 11:48 AM
OP should have made it so that there can't be a single year of overlap between players.

Agreed.

That's what I've done here. None of these players' careers overlapped:

C - George Mikan (1946-1956)
PF - Bill Russell (1956-1969)
SF - LeBron James (2003-)
SG - Michael Jordan (1984-1993; 1995-1998; 2001-2003)
PG - Pete Maravich (1970-1980)

Mikan and Russell can take it in turns to play power forward. If that doesn't work, I'd replace Mikan with Joe Fulks (1946-1954) who fits in nicely at small forward, LeBron can switch to power forward, and Russell resumes center duties.

Milbuck
12-30-2014, 12:18 PM
Gonna try to stay away from some of the really obvious picks.

PG: Oscar (60s - '75)
SG: West (late 40s - 60s)
SF: Dr. J ('71 - '88)
PF: KG (2002 - 2014)
C: Hakeem ('88 - 2002)

Even less obvious picks, not even close to the best team but a team I'd want to watch all day..obviously fully healthy, with T-Mac, Sabonis, and Hill in there..

(1970s) Pete Maravich
(2000s) Tracy McGrady
(1990s) Grant Hill
(2010s) Kevin Durant
(1980s) Arvydas Sabonis

WillC
12-30-2014, 12:43 PM
Gonna try to stay away from some of the really obvious picks.

PG: Oscar (60s - '75)
SG: West (late 40s - 60s)
SF: Dr. J ('71 - '88)
PF: KG (2002 - 2014)
C: Hakeem ('88 - 2002)

Even less obvious picks, not even close to the best team but a team I'd want to watch all day..obviously fully healthy, with T-Mac, Sabonis, and Hill in there..

(1970s) Pete Maravich
(2000s) Tracy McGrady
(1990s) Grant Hill
(2010s) Kevin Durant
(1980s) Arvydas Sabonis

So you've gone for Oscar Robertson and Jerry West? Two players who played in exactly the same years (1960-74).

You really think Jerry West played in the 1940s? He didn't even play in the 1950s :facepalm

Milbuck
12-30-2014, 12:45 PM
So you've gone for Oscar Robertson and Jerry West? Two players who played in exactly the same years (1960-74).

You really think Jerry West played in the 1940s? He didn't even play in the 1950s :facepalmI just went by the years listed...1940s-1960s and 60s - '75 :confusedshrug:

ArbitraryWater
12-30-2014, 12:54 PM
Gonna try to stay away from some of the really obvious picks.

PG: Oscar (60s - '75)
SG: West (late 40s - 60s)
SF: Dr. J ('71 - '88)
PF: KG (2002 - 2014)
C: Hakeem ('88 - 2002)

Even less obvious picks, not even close to the best team but a team I'd want to watch all day..obviously fully healthy, with T-Mac, Sabonis, and Hill in there..

(1970s) Pete Maravich
(2000s) Tracy McGrady
(1990s) Grant Hill
(2010s) Kevin Durant
(1980s) Arvydas Sabonis

:wtf:

WillC
12-30-2014, 03:08 PM
I just went by the years listed...1940s-1960s and 60s - '75 :confusedshrug:

Yeah. You failed.

BIZARRO
12-30-2014, 03:33 PM
C: Kareem 70's
PF: Wilt 60's
SF: Lebron 00's
SG: MJ 90's
PG: Magic 80's


Moving Wilt to the PF (or Russell) and nobody is beating that team, but Wilt or Russell at PF is kind of cheating.

So:

C: Kareem 70's
PF: Duncan 00's
SF: Baylor 60's
SG: MJ 90's
PG: Magic 80's

Milbuck
12-30-2014, 04:42 PM
:wtf:
....?
Yeah. You failed.
No, I actually didn't. They both fall under the years given. Wasn't my decision to have an entire decade mentioned within 2 eras.

The Red Viper
12-30-2014, 07:08 PM
Hmmm.

C:- Bill Russell. (1961 - 1975)
PF:- Larry Bird. (1976 - 1988)
SF:- LeBron James. (2003 - 2014)
SG:- Michael Jordan. (1989 - 2002)
PG:- Bob Cousy. (1940 - 1960)

Tough choosing between Wilt and Russell, but went with Russell ultimately because I don't really need scoring with MJ, LeBron and Bird. I need some great defense and Russell would provide that. Initially, I had planned to go with Timmy instead of LeBron for the modern era and move Bird back to three but the idea of having LeBron, Mike and Bird on the same court was too tempting. I would definitely pay to watch that team.