You have ONE vote for the Hall of Fame. Which of the following makes the Hall?

[sportjames23]

You have one vote and due to your vote, only one of the following will make the Hall:

Duncan
Kobe
Lebron
Wade
Durant
Garnett
Dirk
Nash

Who gets in?

[ILLsmak]

gotta go w/ Duncan from that list. I don't think he's the best player of them, necessarily, but in terms of HoF career it's no contest.

-Smak

[Im so nba'd out]

You have one vote and due to your vote, only one of the following will make the Hall:

Duncan
Kobe
Lebron
Wade
Durant
Garnett
Dirk
Nash

Who gets in?
http://estaticos01.elmundo.es/especiales/2002/05/sociedad/diadeltrabajador/images/grandes/agenda.gif

[24-Inch_Chrome]

Duncan is the best/most deserving player there.

If I had to pick their induction order, my picks would go:

1) Duncan
2) LeBron
3) Kobe
4) Wade/Garnett
5) Garnett/Wade
6) Nash
7) Dirk
8) Durant

[miles berg]

Duncan

Then Dirk or Kobe

Then the other

Then Garnett

[Straight_Ballin]

Duncan gets my vote

[Uncle Drew]

Duncan, no hesitation.

[Draz]

Duncan.

[coin24]

Kobe

Top 3 scorer OF ALL TIME
5 rings
Clutch
Most handsome
President of the big di.ck alphas club


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iY9HjNWbJvA

[k0kakw0rld]

You have one vote and due to your vote, only one of the following will make the Hall:

Duncan
Kobe
Lebron
Wade
Durant
Garnett
Dirk
Nash

Who gets in?
The greatest player 2000s era.

[BigTicket]

I would vote for Duncan

It's close between him and Kobe though.

[k0kakw0rld]

Kobe

Top 3 scorer OF ALL TIME (Missed the most shots in the history of the league)
5 rings
Inefficient Clutch shooter (worst FG% amongs elite players)
Rapist
Owner of my assh0le


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iY9HjNWbJvA


Fixed.

[Smook A.]

Obviously every one of those guys are/were great players and there's no doubt each one of them has a legitimate chance to make the Hall. If I had just one vote, I'd pick Tim Duncan. He's been to the playoffs EVERY year since being selected #1 in '97. He has 5 rings, 2 MVPs and his consistency has been just amazing.

My next two picks would be Kobe, then LeBron.

[Quickening]

Lebron... biggest combination of fmvp and mvps, plus best statistical player... been consensus best player in the league for longer than any of others. Only challenger would be Duncan based on longevity and FMVPs

[fiddy]

Kobe has the edge.

[Prime_Shaq]

Seems like Duncan reigns supreme.

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/87/22/00/872200bdb94bbd773f5a84dd31764561.jpg

[scandisk_]

Kobe duh!

[MP.Trey]

Duncan and only Kobe or LeBron fanboys would say different.

[Captvic]

Timmy D

[Dresta]

yep, clearly Duncan.

[MrC1991]

Duncan without question.

[kells333]

Its between duncan kobe or bron. The rest is just filler. Me personally id take kobe, eye test tells me hes the best player ive ever seen.

[dubeta]

LeBron, just add up the MVP's and FMVP's of each player

[f0und]

duncan

[Springsteen]

Anyone who doesn't say Duncan needs to reevaluate life.

[rmt]

Duncan - best career resume on that list.

[Demitri98]

In this order:

Duncan
Kobe
LeBron
Wade
Garnett
Dirk
Nash
Durant

[Smoke117]

Duncan, obviously.

[Fudge]

Durant, easily.

[GrapeApe]

Why not just ask who has had the best career? Isn't that basically the question being posed? They're all obviously hall of famers. To answer the question though, I'd have to say Duncan.

[sd3035]

Duncan
Kobe































The rest

[Orlando Magic]

Who had the best career? Duncan.
Who was the best player on that list at their peak? LeBron / Duncan. Probably Duncan.
Who was the most famous player on that list? LeBron / Kobe. Probably LeBron.

Comes down to Duncan or LeBron and anyone who doesn't have them as #1 and #2 in either order is really kidding themselves and trapped in the past.

I'd personally take Duncan because Tony Parker and Manu Ginobili are overrated pieces of shit and Duncan carried them to titles regardless. They always have been and always will be. I mean seriously... I'll never get over people thinking Manu was at any point as good as peak McGrady including idiotic posters in this thread. Gotta love ISH. lol.

[305Baller]

Duncan

[Optimus Prime]

Kobe. No doubt. Honorable mention to Duncan.

[Black Mamba's B]

Kobe

[secund2nun]

Easily between Duncan or Lebron. I'd give Duncan the edge but its unfair because he has played much longer.

[secund2nun]

Nash and Kobe would be last. Worst players on the list easily.

[JellyBean]

You have one vote and due to your vote, only one of the following will make the Hall:

Duncan
Kobe
Lebron
Wade
Durant
Garnett
Dirk
Nash

Who gets in?


Kobe....13th pick in the 1996 NBA draft. His own teammates (1996-97 Lakers) and coach (Dell Harris) tried to sabotage this young man's career until they realized that nothing was holding this young man back. Warrior. Gladiator. Tough as Nails player. All-Time Great.

[dubeta]

Kobe....13th pick in the 1996 NBA draft. His own teammates (1996-97 Lakers) and coach (Dell Harris) tried to sabotage this young man's career until they realized that nothing was holding this young man back. Warrior. Gladiator. Tough as Nails player. All-Time Great.

6-24

[ShawkFactory]

Duncan and only Kobe or LeBron fanboys would say different.
Kobe Bryant certainly has an argument.

[OnFire]

Close between Duncan and Kobe, then a decent gap. Not in skill or real HOF credentials but since you can only pick 1.

[Jacks3]

duncan is a boring **** that nobody really cares about.

it's the basketball hall of FAME.

lebron and kobe were not only incredible basketball players, but they were/are basketball icons. far more spectacular than dunkedon.

so yeah, it's clearly between kobe and lebron.

i'm not sure. lebron is the better player, but kobe is the biggest name of the post-jordan era. very close.

[ShawkFactory]

duncan is a boring **** that nobody really cares about.

it's the basketball hall of FAME.

lebron and kobe were not only incredible basketball players, but they were/are basketball icons. far more spectacular than dunkedon.

so yeah, it's clearly between kobe and lebron.

i'm not sure. lebron is the better player, but kobe is the biggest name of the post-jordan era. very close.
You are stupid.

[24-Inch_Chrome]

Kobe Bryant certainly has an argument.

Compared to Duncan he really doesn't.

[Genaro]

Kobe
Won as much as anyone in the list.
81 points
3rd all time scoring leader