Top 5 PG in NBA history...

[Spaulding]

Magic
Isiah
Oscar
Stockton
Frazier

Without Oscar and Magic I have a top 5. Why? Magic and Oscar are not true PGs. Plus any basketball fan knows those 2 played and defended any position.

Isiah
Stockton
Frazier
Payton
Kidd

[ekosky]

Magic
Isiah
Oscar
Stockton
Frazier

Without Oscar and Magic I have a top 5. Why? Magic and Oscar are not true PGs. Plus any basketball fan knows those 2 played and defended any position.

Isiah
Stockton
Frazier
Payton
Kidd
http://media.giphy.com/media/fFwOzwhCO1FMA/giphy.gif

[TheMarkMadsen]

Magic
Zeke

Oscar
Frazier
Nash

[warriorfan]

Curry has already surpassed Steve Nash

[K Xerxes]

Inb4 Chris Paul mention and subsequent meltdown

[Milbuck]

Chris Paul.

[AnaheimLakers24]

Magic and kobe 10 rings
or
magic and fisher 10 rings

no one else matters

[fpliii]

Neither is top 5, but Kidd and Penny were a couple of my favorites to watch.

[K Xerxes]

Not gonna bother ranking those I haven't watched, so gotta go with Stockton, Payton, Kidd, Nash and Paul.


Neither is top 5, but Kidd and Penny were a couple of my favorites to watch.

Why not Kidd? Who do you rank above?

[SHAQisGOAT]

Magic
Oscar
Isiah
Frazier
Stockton

[fpliii]

Not gonna bother ranking those I haven't watched, so gotta go with Stockton, Payton, Kidd, Nash and Paul.



Why not Kidd? Who do you rank above?
I'm not big on rankings, but everyone who does them is going to have Magic/Oscar (or West, some consider him a PG, and Oscar a SG...way before my time so I won't comment on it). If people have 3 of Stockton/Nash/Frazier/Paul there isn't any room for Kidd.

[24-Inch_Chrome]

Magic
Zeke

Oscar
Frazier
Nash

I'd bump Oscar up with Magic/IsIah but I can dig this. Big Nash fan though, so I'll cop to bias.

[Fallen Angel]

Magic
Oscar
Stockton
Isiah
Frazier

[RRR3]

Chris Paul.
This.

[Spaulding]

http://media.giphy.com/media/fFwOzwhCO1FMA/giphy.gif

Perhaps I should have stated it better. Magic and Oscar we're not your typical point guards. I don't think it's fair to stick those two in one position. They are both well rounded top 10 players.

[Straight_Ballin]

Magic, KJ, and Zeke all say high.

Come talk to me when anyone else on the list can average 20/10 on 50% fg% for a full season.

[Kobe_6/8]

Magic
Isiah
Oscar
Stockton
Frazier

Without Oscar and Magic I have a top 5. Why? Magic and Oscar are not true PGs. Plus any basketball fan knows those 2 played and defended any position.

Isiah
Stockton
Frazier
Payton
Kidd

They may not be 'true PGs', but they play PG better than any of those 5.

Edit: Isiah > Oscar.

[K Xerxes]

Magic, KJ, and Zeke all say high.

Come talk to me when anyone else on the list can average 20/10 on 50% fg% for a full season.

Chris Paul in 09...

[FreezingTsmoove]

Magic
Oscar
Isaiah
Curry (Tons of records broken)
Kidd

[TheBigVeto]

1. Stockton
2. Nash
3. Robertson
4. Cousy
5. Magic

[kennethgriffin]

lol @ ISH constantly leaving out Jerry West on PG lists

http://www.basketball-reference.com/players/w/westje01.html


read his profile/listed positions

he was listed at PG 12 out of 14 seasons


he averaged 7 apg career, almost 10 apg for 2 years, over 8apg 4 times


gail goodrich played shooting guard every season he was on LA


http://www.basketball-reference.com/players/g/goodrga01.html

[Lakers Fan]

Magic
Oscar
Stockton
Isiah
Cousy

[T_L_P]

Chris Paul in 09...

23/6/11/3/.599 TS%, All-D team. :bowdown:

[Prime_Shaq]

Magic
Zeke
Oscar
Frazier
Nash

[stalkerforlife]

CrapGm actually has a 'legitimate' argument that Billups is better than Zeke.

I hate that poser site.

[FKAri]

CrapGm actually has a 'legitimate' argument that Billups is better than Zeke.

I hate that poser site.

It's better than this one for actual discussion...

[GoSpursGo1984]

Chris Paul.
http://www.thefunnyblog.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/you-have-tried-cute-husky-funny-blog.jpg

[stalkerforlife]

It's better than this one for actual discussion...

Reported.

[StephHamann]

Kobe Bryant

Fisher was a spot up 3 point shooter, Kobe was the true PG.

He even invented a great new pass, the Kobe-Assist.

:applause:

[ScarSymmetry]

Curry has already surpassed Steve Nash

:facepalm

[ClipperRevival]

So CP3 is being held back by most because he has choked in the playoffs I'm assuming. And that is correct. He needs to go further than the 2nd round to move up. But in terms of just playing PG, he might've been the most efficient PG ever (regular season of course). All of the advanced analytics back this up. The guy maximizes possessions and almost never turns the ball over. He really had no weakness in his game and to me, he was the most complete PG ever if you actually break down his weaknesses. I can't think of one except his height and maybe unwillingness to shoot more, which can hurt your team at times when the team needs the offense. Of course there is also the choking issues, which is huge.

[StephHamann]

So CP3 is being held back by most because he has choked in the playoffs I'm assuming. But in terms of choking, he might've been the most efficient choker ever (regular season of course). All of the advanced analytics back this up. The guy maximizes choking. He really had no weakness in his choking game and to me, he was the most complete choker ever if you actually break down his weaknesses.

[Kvnzhangyay]

Reported.

He's not wrong, but who cares? This site is hella funny with people like Euroleague running around :roll:

[ClipperRevival]

So CP3 is being held back by most because he has choked in the playoffs I'm assuming. But in terms of choking, he might've been the most efficient choker ever (regular season of course). All of the advanced analytics back this up. The guy maximizes choking. He really had no weakness in his choking game and to me, he was the most complete choker ever if you actually break down his weaknesses.

:oldlol:

I'm not defending the guy. If he doesn't have a couple of deep playoff runs, his legacy will suffer and rightfully so. But I'm just talking about his game and breaking it down. He's about as complete as any PG I can think of.

[houston]

Magic
Oscar
Isiah
Frazier
kidd