Current Blake or Prime Stat?

[TrueBlue89]

Who's the better player? Who would you rather build your team around?

[iTare]

Close but ill take Blake.

[ArbitraryWater]

Blake has been an arguable top 5 player for 3 straight years now, Stat was at the low end of the top 10 a few years, Blake is an all-around better player, less reliable on his set up guy, proven by his stretch in 2014 where he kept the Clippers record afloat, and catapulted him onto THIRD on the MVP ranking, a feat Stoudemire never has come close to.

[Al Thornton]

blake is better. amare was great but he was playing in the dantoni/nash system and was surrounded by shooters. blake is playing with deandre so the spacing is really bad and yet he still dominates. also when blake is motivated he can play pretty good defense

[raprap]

Blake all day. Better shooter, passer, defender and can start the break with his ball handling skills.

[Prime_Shaq]

STAT was a better scorer but Blake is better at every other aspect basically

[Hamtaro CP3KDKG]

Stat until i see Blake performing as well and consistent in the playoffs against top competition.

Amare was averaging 37/10 55%FG against prime Timmy

[houston]

blake of course

[FKAri]

Blake. Amare needed to be spoonfed by Nash. He had 0 post moves and played no D. A godlike PnR player tho.

[LoneyROY7]

Joke question.

Amare was spoon-fed during all his years in Phoenix. Blake can run an entire offense himself.

Oh and Blake is a much better defender.

[Real14]

2011 Amare.

[LoneyROY7]

I think people forget just how bad Amare was on defense. :oldlol:

[Pushxx]

Blake by a little.

[Wally450]

Blake. Amare needed to be spoonfed by Nash. He had 0 post moves and played no D. A godlike PnR player tho.
Why was he putting up numbers in NY before Carmelo arrived then?

[4 Inches]

Blake and it ain't even close. Amare was a fg% padder getting fed easy buckets by Nash. The boy had a few nasty posters doe.

[Draz]

Blake

[Kawhi]

Stat until i see Blake performing as well and consistent in the playoffs against top competition.

Amare was averaging 37/10 55%FG against prime Timmy
Which was exactly their plan. The Spurs didn't give a shit about Stoudemire. The only thing they wanted to do was stop Nash.

[MMKM]

Prime stat. Current Blake is a whiny little flopsicle.

[MMKM]

And current Blake has no bounce.

[LoneyROY7]

Prime stat. Current Blake is a whiny little flopsicle.

A whiny little flopsicle that's better at the game of basketball then Amare was. :applause:


And current Blake has no bounce.

:roll: