Rank the Harry Potter films

[GIF REACTION]

1. Prisoner of Azkaban
2. Chamber of Secrets
3. Part 1
4. Philosophers Stone
5. Part 2
6. Goblet of FIRE
7. 5th movie
6. 6th movie

[Akrazotile]

1. Prisoner of Azkaban
2. Chamber of Secrets
3. Part 1
4. Philosophers Stone
5. Part 2
6. Goblet of FIRE
7. 5th movie
6. 6th movie

Im going:

1. Prisoner of Secrets
2. Part 2
3. 5th movie
4. Goblin of FIRE
5. 6th movie
6. Philosopher Store
7. Chamber of Azkaban
8. Part 1


But it's really close.

[West-Side]

1. Prisoner of Azkaban
2. Chamber of Secrets
3. Part 1
4. Philosophers Stone
5. Part 2
6. Goblet of FIRE
7. 5th movie
6. 6th movie

1) Deathly Hallows, Part 2 (Last)
2) Prisoner of Azakban (3rd)
3) Goblet of Fire (4th)
4) Philosophers Stone (1st)
5) Chambers of Secrets (2nd)
6) Half Blood Prince (6th)
7) Order of Phoenix (5th)
8) Deathly Hallows, Part 1 (7th)

Part 1 & Half Blood Prince were extremely dark movies, and honestly I didn't pay closely to the entire dialogue. It was very slow and serious. I'd have to watch them again to properly evaluate. Take those two movies aside, I easily consider Order of Phoenix the worst one overall, but it is still an enjoyable watch.

Part 2 was hands down the best for me. Just from start to finish, I was intrigued by everything that was happening. All the twists and turns, the final battle and the showdown between Harry & Lord V. Just epic stuff.

[West-Side]

Im going:

1. Prisoner of Secrets
2. Part 2
3. 5th movie
4. Goblin of FIRE
5. 6th movie
6. Philosopher Store
7. Chamber of Azkaban
8. Part 1


But it's really close.

It's Prisoner of Azakaban and Chamber of Secrets. :oldlol:
I'm surprised you have the Order of the Phoenix so high up. And Chamber of Secrets so low. For the longest time I felt like COS was one of the 3 best movies in the series until I recently watched them all again within a week's time. Chamber did fall a bit on my list but it was still very very good.

[rufuspaul]

1. Half Blood Prince
2. Prisoner of Azkaban
3. Deathly Hallows 1
4. Deathly Hallows 2
5. Goblet of Fire
6. Sorcerer's Stone
7. Chamber of Secrets
8. Order of the Phoenix

[Akrazotile]

It's Prisoner of Azakaban and Chamber of Secrets. :oldlol:
I'm surprised you have the Order of the Phoenix so high up. And Chamber of Secrets so low. For the longest time I felt like COS was one of the 3 best movies in the series until I recently watched them all again within a week's time. Chamber did fall a bit on my list but it was still very very good.


I was just being facetious since I haven't seen them. I do think they're probably more my style than the comic book and star wars stuff, which I just can never get into. But I feel like since I missed all the Harry Potter stuff on the first go-round, there's just too much of it now to start investing myself in.

[ROCSteady]

1. Chamber of Secrets
2. Half Blood Prince
3. Goblet of Fire (minus the haircuts)
4. Deathly Hallows Part 1
5. Sorcerer's Stone
6. Deathly Hallows Part 2
7. Prisoner of Azkaban
8. Order of the Phoenix

[Shade8780]

lotr >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> harry potter

[ROCSteady]

"Three movies of ppl walking to a fckin volcano. Even the trees walked."

[Derka]

1. Prisoner of Azkaban
2. Deathly Hallows 2
3. Sorceror's Stone
4. Order of the Phoenix
5. Goblet of Fire
6. Chamber of Secrets
7. Half-Blood Prince
8. Deathly Hallows 1

[Shade8780]

"Three movies of ppl walking to a fckin volcano. Even the trees walked."
that's because it's hard for inferior minds like you to understand a trilogy like tlotr

enjoy your harry potter kiddy wizard stuff

[ROCSteady]

Inferior Mind?

Boy, I watch films and movies alike, they are NOT the same. I can dissect a film far more profoundly than your nerdy ass can read shit on a Star Wars message board and regurgitate it here or elsewhere.

A Star Wars nerd calling a fan of anything kiddy stuff is seriously LOL

How unaware are you? The concepts of Star Wars were the original 'Kiddy Stuff Ideas' franchise.

I hope you posted that ironically considering how vehemently you're defending a movie that was 7/10 quality.

[Shade8780]

Inferior Mind?

Boy, I watch films and movies alike, they are NOT the same. I can dissect a film far more profoundly than your nerdy ass can read shit on a Star Wars message board.

A Star Wars nerd calling a fan of anything kiddy stuff is seriously LOL

How unaware are you? The concepts of Star Wars were the original 'Kiddy Stuff Ideas' franchise.

I hope you posted that ironically considering how vehemently you're defending a movie that was 7/10 quality.
you're the one who called tlotr boring

tlotr won 15 academy awards

harry potter won none

tlotr > harry potter

superior intellectuals > inferior babies

[ROCSteady]

That was a quote from a comedy movie you simpleton. Hence the " "

Lord of the Rings were masterly crafted, it's undeniable. They were made extremely well. Plenty of Oscar winning films are still boring.

The Oscars are somewhat of a sham anyways. True movie watchers and film critics know the Oscars is rigged with a certain formula.

I enjoy Harry Potter more than LOTR. That's not to say they are as well made as a series but Harry Potter had much more moving parts that made it a more difficult task to keep up with anyways.

[imdaman99]

I don't know shit about the Harry Potter universe but I enjoyed almost all the movies. The last one was my fav because it was nonstop action. My least fav was part 1 of the last one. That one was the setup to the last when shit hit the fan.

[Shade8780]

point being, it's a trilogy for superior intellectuals like me

i don't find it boring, it's very entertaining if you actually pay attention

[Nick Young]

These movies just weren't as good as the books.

That said, Deathly Hallows Part 2 is clearly the best movie for me.

The battle of Hogwarts scene where it's a long continuous shot with a shit ton of callbacks to all the previous films with every monster making a return and the emotional music as Harry, Hermione and Ron are running to where Snape is was incredible.


The Snape revelation scene was well done.

The end fight with Voldemort was great, not too long, not too short.


To me it's the movie that felt the most like the book.


Prisoner of Azkaban was my favorite book, Deathly Hallows was my second favorite.


Order of the Phoenix and Goblet of Fire, I thought these were awful movies.

[Nick Young]

"Three movies of ppl walking to a fckin volcano. Even the trees walked."
holy shit this idiotic Kevin Smith logic.

You know Clerks 2, and the discussion he wrote about Lord of the Rings was the same moment everyone realized that Kevin Smith was a fat useless hack whose opinions mean jack shit.

Lord of the Rings is hands down the best movie trilogy ever.

These movies were perfect, the extended editions were even better.

[ROCSteady]

There's nothing superior about you slick.

All your talking points about anything I've seen all over the net from nerds who think the have some sort of gift when they're discerning PG and PG-13 tentpole blockbusters made for mass consumption. Somehow that's superior intellect lol.

Star Wars is great fun but the movies are simplistic. They're not nuanced BY DESIGN. LOTR are well made films but they're tedious at times. Probably has to do with a mostly drab setting but it is what it is.

[ROCSteady]

holy shit this idiotic Kevin Smith logic.

You know Clerks 2, and the discussion he wrote about Lord of the Rings was the same moment everyone realized that Kevin Smith was a fat useless hack whose opinions mean jack shit.

Lord of the Rings is hands down the best movie trilogy ever.

These movies were perfect, the extended editions were even better.

:roll:

You can't even facetiously quote something that pokes fun at LOTR without ppl coming to dismantle. I don't even like Clerks 2.

Only real nerds with insecurity issues come to compare nerd franchises when one of them wasn't even part of the discussion in the first place.

It's nerdy enough I ranked 8 Harry Potter movies but now it's HP vs. LOTR. Fckin shade and his obsessive fanboyism.

STAR WARS FORCE AWAKENS WAS ONLY PRETTY GOOD!

[Shade8780]

why are you talking about star wars?

if you were paying attention, you'd know this is about lotr and harry potter

lotr >> harry potter

[ROCSteady]

Because you put yourself on some fan pedestal of a franchise that is written the opposite of what a 'superior intellectual' would be drawn to. The plots, ideas and concepts are all arbitrary broad stroked simpleton stuff in reality.

It's only shy socially awkward internet dwellers that has made Star Wars more complex than it actually is.

[Shade8780]

i'm not the guy who said the phantom menace was a good movie

it's a movie for inferior minds after all

[ROCSteady]

I said it had multiple good things going for it.

It does. There's real gravity to some of the situations presented.

I liked Force Awakens but that movie barely presented anything nuanced. The enjoyable pace was so fast it didn't shine light into much of anything outside a line or two exposition then moved on.

Not intellectually provoking at all unless you're already invested in the ideas

[Nick Young]

1A Lord of the Rings
1B Star Wars

























8th Man off the bench-Harry Potter movies



And I'm a massive HP book fan, read them all atleast 7 times each.

[West-Side]

I recently watched all 8 Harry Potter movies within a span of 10 days.
Honestly was blown away. It felt like an epic adventure for me. I really enjoyed these films. However, when I watched them sporadically I didn't feel the same connection, not even close.

LOTR is a different beast altogether. But Harry Potter series is a damn good watch, and I'd recommend it to anyone.

Overall if I had to rank both of these collections;

Harry Potter - 88 / 100
LOTR - 98 / 100

Star Wars - 82 / 100

[Shade8780]

I said it had multiple good things going for it.

It does. There's real gravity to some of the situations presented.

I liked Force Awakens but that movie barely presented anything nuanced. The enjoyable pace was so fast it didn't shine light into much of anything outside a line or two exposition then moved on.

Not intellectually provoking at all unless you're already invested in the ideas
sorry mate but im talking about lotr, not a movie for five year olds

i let you enjoy your baby films with cartoon rabbits and midichlorians, let me enjoy my superior intellectual films like empire strikes back and fellowship of the ring :cheers:

[Shade8780]

1A Lord of the Rings
1B Star Wars

























8th Man off the bench-Harry Potter movies



And I'm a massive HP book fan, read them all atleast 7 times each.


great minds think alike

keep intellectualing my friend :cheers:

carefree
wherever we may be

[Nick Young]

great minds think alike

keep intellectualing my friend :cheers:

carefree
wherever we may be
The Force is with us bro.

[ROCSteady]

sorry mate but im talking about lotr, not a movie for five year olds

i let you enjoy your baby films with cartoon rabbits and midichlorians, let me enjoy my superior intellectual films like empire strikes back and fellowship of the ring :cheers:

Is this guy serious? I am for sure a movie geek but some of y'all need some self awareness.

[ROCSteady]

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/67/fc/a8/67fca857fee50058f2812015b1fa9ea7.jpg

:lol

[SexSymbol]

1) Prisoner of Azakban (3rd)
2) Deathly Hallows, Part 2 (Last)
3) Half Blood Prince (6th)
4) Chambers of Secrets (2nd)
5) Deathly Hallows, Part 1 (7th)
6) Goblet of Fire (4th)
7) Order of Phoenix (5th)
8) Philosophers Stone (1st)

[SexSymbol]

1A Lord of the Rings
1B Star Wars

























8th Man off the bench-Harry Potter movies



And I'm a massive HP book fan, read them all atleast 7 times each.

Harry Potter movies are better than Star Wars.

[ArbitraryWater]

I dont know, but I loved them all :applause: :bowdown: