If carmelo wins a ring as the main guy

[pastis]

all time rank?

top 35?

[Human Error]

Carmelo beating Curry, Durant, LeBron etc as a main man? Not gonna happen.

[Kargo]

That train has left the building, arrived to it's destination, has been taken apart and turned into a restaurant.

[nathanjizzle]

thats a pretty big "if".

[pastis]

thats a pretty big "if".

why? if KD comes to NYC? There is literally just the cavs in the east. and once you reach the finals, EVERYTHING is possible.

ok, main guy is maybe a very big "If". But as a 1b

[GoSpursGo1984]

all time rank?

top 35?

Melo winning as the man

http://knityorkcity.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/I8kq0uJ.gif

[smoovegittar]

He had his chance as the Alpha on the team. Now he has to get real.

[imnew09]

Cant even lead his team to the playoff
Let alone winning a ring LOL

[DrainMD]

why? if KD comes to NYC? There is literally just the cavs in the east. and once you reach the finals, EVERYTHING is possible.

ok, main guy is maybe a very big "If". But as a 1b

If KD went to NY, it wouldnt be an if, KD would be the clear first option. Not 1a/1b.

[Kobe_6/8]

Melo winning a ring as the main guy?

http://www.blogcdn.com/www.mandatory.com/media/2013/02/michael-jordan-laughing.gif

[imdaman99]

As the main guy? :oldlol: I guess stranger things have happened, definitely top 50, closer to top 40

But to be honest, he is no leader. I thought he was developing into 1 but turned into his 4-16 or 4-17 coupled with bad defense self. I'm not gonna say it's more fun to watch the Knicks lose close games without him especially since they are NOT going to KP in the clutch moments of these games. But it would be a good time for KP to learn on the go :confusedshrug: Derek Fisher :whatever:

His best role will be to win as a 2nd option.

[Wally450]

Is he a HOFer?

[Fallen Angel]

No.

[Straight_Ballin]

why? if KD comes to NYC? There is literally just the cavs in the east. and once you reach the finals, EVERYTHING is possible.

ok, main guy is maybe a very big "If". But as a 1b

No, once you reach the finals as a team out of the east, you realize how bad your conference is. Right now there is a player who is the face of the NBA that doesn't know how to lose in the finals. Sure, sample size is small at 1/1 but what happens when Curry is 4/4 and this thread get's bumped? Curry is going to be like MJ, a guy who prevents his competition from winning any rings.

[Done_And_Done]

Carmelo will never win a ring as the go-to guy on his team and I'd be willing to bet copious amounts of money on it.

[TaLvsCuaL]

He is one of the best mid range shooters of all time but He is also a spineless loser. I've been waiting years for Him to do something remarkable but It's so unrealistic at this point. I have already accepted He is idiot that has wasted his talent and has make a fortune letting down his fans. The epitome of a fraud superstar.

[!@#$%Vectors!@#]

If it ever happens he surpasses Lebron because Lebron would have been another Melo if he didn't constantly collude .