Is Isaiah Thomas more talented than LeBron?

[ralph_i_el]

Say they are both 6'4"

All talent the same, Isaiah is a little less quick from being taller, LeBron is a little quicker from being shorter.

[SyRyanYang]

Size is a talent, athleticism is a talent
God you are dumb

[InsanityKills]

Is OP more talented than his Mom at sucking d!ck?

Say they are both hungry for pen!is.

All the mouth talents the same. OP uses his teeth, his mom deep throats.

[ralph_i_el]

shooting.........Thomas
ball handling.........Thomas
on-ball defense........Thomas


Even if size is a talent (it isn't) obviously this is a scenario where they both are the same size.

so as usual, bronstans are dumb as ****

[ShawkFactory]

Eh, weird question. Lebrons abilities at his size is what makes him what he is.

It's a part of athleticism

[Marchesk]

If Muggsy Bogues had been Mark Eaton's size, he would be GOAT.

[JohnFreeman]

This is a thread in the year 2016?

[ralph_i_el]

Eh, weird question. Lebrons abilities at his size is what makes him what he is.

It's a part of athleticism

I understand

I'm talking about actual basketball skills, not running and jumping.

[SugarHill]

shooting.........Thomas
ball handling.........Thomas
on-ball defense........Thomas


Even if size is a talent (it isn't) obviously this is a scenario where they both are the same size.

so as usual, bronstans are dumb as ****
Is being able to run a team and pass a talent? But then LeBron uses his height and size to be able to do a lot of his set ups so if he was a midget, does that also go?

[Fire Colangelo]

Is BBIQ a talent?
Vision?
Passing skills?
Team defense?

LeBron will be kind of doing what Westbrook is doing right now if he was 6'4....

[outbreak]

Would you rather fight One 100 foot tall muggsy bogues or 100 one foot tall muggsy bogues?

[HenryGarfunkle]

Nah, he's not. And who knows how Thomas's shooting would be affected by being taller, having bigger hands, etc. If you say the speed changes that means everything else does too. So Lebron becomes an even better shooter, ball handler, quicker athlete. LeBron wins easily

[Smoke117]

shooting.........Thomas
ball handling.........Thomas
on-ball defense........Thomas


Even if size is a talent (it isn't) obviously this is a scenario where they both are the same size.

so as usual, bronstans are dumb as ****

Saying a PG has better ball handling than Lebrons without bringing their size into equation is just idiotic...for said size Lebrons ball handling is much better. You usually make good post...what brought about this dipshit lame thread?

[ShawkFactory]

I understand

I'm talking about actual basketball skills, not running and jumping.
Well then you get into a different area. The skills Isaih had weren't necessarily talent-based, but were developed throughout his life with hard work.

Talent implies a natural ability.

Discounting size...yes, Isiah was more skilled. A lot of people were. But they needed to be to have a similar effect.

[Fire Colangelo]

Saying a PG has better ball handling than Lebrons without bringing their size into equation is just idiotic...for said size Lebrons ball handling is much better. You usually make good post...what brought about this dipshit lame thread?

I have to agree... this thread was kind of pointless.

You can compare Thomas and Shaq at 6'1 and come to the conclusion that Thomas is better at pretty much everything :oldlol:

[ralph_i_el]

Would you rather fight One 100 foot tall muggsy bogues or 100 one foot tall muggsy bogues?

yes

I am drunk


You usually make good post...what brought about this dipshit lame thread?

I'm watching the republican debate. I've lost all sense of what is true and false.