Amare won ROTY over Yao

[TomCat]

because his team made the playoffs.

How come Carmelo didn't win over Bran?

[AI09]

Amare and yaos rookie stats were almost identical both were around 13ppg 8 rpg 1.5bpg nothing to crazy where lebron and Carmelo both put up 20ppg seasons something that hasn't been done in awhile by a rookie let alone 2 of them in the same year.LeBron also had better all around stats. I remember the 2004 rookie class Dwight and Emeka could've been Co ROY but Okafor stats were all better. Sometimes when the production is similar you have to look at who has helped their team more. All in all I think Lebron and Melo should've shared roy honors 1 had better all around stats the other helped carry the team to the playoffs and Denver was really bad at that time.

[FreezingTsmoove]

Wade and Melo were both clearly better players than Lebron

But the fix was in

[Dray n Klay]

Freezingsmoove STILL melting down?

:yaohappy:

[FreezingTsmoove]

Freezingsmoove STILL melting down?

:yaohappy:

get outta here DrayKlay, I dont want to bully you two days in a row

[TomCat]

Wade and Melo were both clearly better players than Lebron

But the fix was in

Wade was clearly better than bron that year

[GINOBILI!]

LeBron was better. Always has been. Plain and simple.

[Edgar Friendly]

Melo was robbed that year, he didn't have the hype train behind him like Lebron, but no one will care because Melo didn't dedicate himself to the game like Bron and Wade did. Imagine if Dumars had drafted him though...

[GINOBILI!]

Melo was robbed that year, he didn't have the hype train behind him like Lebron, but no one will care because Melo didn't dedicate himself to the game like Bron and Wade did. Imagine if Dumars had drafted him though...
According to Darko's excuse, Melo would be worse.

[G-train]

because his team made the playoffs.

How come Carmelo didn't win over Bran?

Amare was clearly a better player than Yao as a rookie.