Team A or Team B?

[D.J.]

Everyone at their peak:


A- Kidd/McGrady/Artest/Webber/Mourning

B- Payton/Carter/Marion/Dirk/Big Ben

[scuzzy]

A

B has limited offense in those matchups

[Gougou]

A

For team B, Dirk need to be on the offense 100%, they can't beat team A if Dirk doesn't do well.

[GoatBoy]

Good choices of players, OP.

I'd give the edge to team A simply because by my estimation they win 3/5 of the positional matchups.

Kidd > Payton
McGrady > carter
Artest < Marion
Webber < Dirk
Mourning > Wallace

Very tough choices on each of the positions, definitely could go either way.

[WillC]

A...

[Asukal]

A easily. The defensive versatility of that lineup is insane and they can score buckets too.

B is good but not as balanced.

[postmupndunkit]

I'll take team C rockon:

Jimmer Fredette
Devin Booker
Klay Thompson
Rudy Gobert
Shaq O'Neal