Comprehensive Kobe vs Duncan debate

[Ca$H]

http://thecomeback.com/nba/tale-of-the-tape-kobe-bryant-vs-tim-duncan.html

Now this is a thorough way to compare players.

[Dray n Klay]

Boiled down:


3/5 > 2/5



Give me Duncan

:confusedshrug:

[TheWinningFam]

The bottom line is,

5 mvps>3 mvps

We know this because when we use this metric, the all time list consistently points out that duncan is a consensus 6-10 type player while kobe is 12th.
And there's no mental gymnastics you can do that will deny this fact.

[Ca$H]

The bottom line is,

5 mvps>3 mvps

We know this because when we use this metric, the all time list consistently points out that duncan is a consensus 6-10 type player while kobe is 12th.
And there's no mental gymnastics you can do that will deny this fact.

If that is the case. Kobe(3) = Hakeem(3). Kobe(3) > Big O (1).

[TheWinningFam]

If that is the case. Kobe(3) = Hakeem(3). Kobe(3) > Big O (1).

Exactly, Kobe is 11th at best, you get it now.

[Ca$H]

Exactly, Kobe is 11th at best, you get it now.

tied for 10th actually at worst. Tie breaker should go to Kobe based on 5 titles > 2 titles. 11 All NBA 1st team > 6 All NBA 1st team. 9 1st team All defense > 5 1st team all defense. So Kobe is 10th at worst assuming he can't go higher than any players with more combined total MVPs.

[sunnyboy91]

Kobe is great but I'll take Timmy.

[Mr Feeny]

Kobe is great but I'll take Timmy.

3 fmvps and 2 MVPs 》》 2 fmvps and 1 mvp

3-4 titles as lead dog 》》 1-2 titles as lead dog.

Duncan any day of the week and twice in Sunday.
One is a top 10 player while the other is Kobe Bryant :lol

[Real14]

DUNCAN was nothing but a great system plater who played for one coach his whole career.

Kobe didn't had Phil his whole career.

[fiddy]

3 fmvps and 2 MVPs 》》 2 fmvps and 1 mvp

3-4 titles as lead dog 》》 1-2 titles as lead dog.

Duncan any day of the week and twice in Sunday.
One is a top 10 player while the other is Kobe Bryant :lol
Kobe and its not even close.

[raprap]

DUNCAN was nothing but a great system plater who played for one coach his whole career.

Kobe didn't had Phil his whole career.
Dumbest post in ISH history. From grammar to spelling to the argument. Holy shit.

[sunnyboy91]

3 fmvps and 2 MVPs 》》 2 fmvps and 1 mvp

3-4 titles as lead dog 》》 1-2 titles as lead dog.

Duncan any day of the week and twice in Sunday.
One is a top 10 player while the other is Kobe Bryant :lol
Agreed, but that doesn't make Kobe some sort of scrub to be laughed at. So many great players would love 1-2 titles as lead dog.

I'm not saying that you are, but it seems everyone either overrates Kobe by a lot, or underrates Kobe by a lot.

[sunnyboy91]

DUNCAN was nothing but a great system plater who played for one coach his whole career.

Kobe didn't had Phil his whole career.
:biggums:

[soots]

Duncan was the best Spurs in 2007 and 2014 NBA playoffs/Finals despite who won the FMVP, who are both known to be inconsistent and disappear.

One series was a sweep. One was the greatest deficit in history. Not as if Duncan needed to take over

[SouBeachTalents]

DUNCAN was nothing but a great system plater who played for one coach his whole career.

Kobe didn't had Phil his whole career.

You are a fuccing retard :lol

[MintBerryCrunch]

You are a fuccing retard :lol
Agreed.

[Mr Feeny]

Kobe and its not even close.Duncan is atleast 2 tiers above Kobe.

[Mr Feeny]

Agreed, but that doesn't make Kobe some sort of scrub to be laughed at. So many great players would love 1-2 titles as lead dog.

I'm not saying that you are, but it seems everyone either overrates Kobe by a lot, or underrates Kobe by a lot.

I have no problem saying he's he's a top 15 player. Those who don't think he is are probably underrating him. Likewise, in my opinion anyone who compares Kobe to the greats is overrating him. He's just not at that level.