ISH Vote: #6 Player in NBA History (2016 ISH GOAT List)

[RRR3]

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/564x/63/13/ca/6313cab20c6090c2dc92c475b50b7273.jpg


Wilt Chamberlain was voted the 5th best player in NBA History by ISH. With some last minute changes and confusion, although technically I was merely correcting two inconsistent votes I had mistakenly counted after making a point of not counting inconsistent votes. So, Wilt did win by my guidelines, although I hadn't had consistency as an official guideline until now (didn't think I would have to but its ISH...sigh).




Default ISH Vote: #5 Player in NBA History (2016 ISH GOAT List)


Bill Russell was voted the 4th best player in NBA history by ISH.


The ISH 2016 GOAT List so far


1. Michael Jordan ISH Vote: #1 Player in NBA History (http://insidehoops.com/forum/showthread.php?t=416515)

2. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar ISH Vote: #2 Player in NBA History (http://insidehoops.com/forum/showthread.php?t=416679)

3. LeBron James ISH Vote: #3 Player in NBA History (http://insidehoops.com/forum/showthread.php?t=416705)

4. Bill Russell ISH Vote: #4 Player in NBA History (http://insidehoops.com/forum/showthread.php?t=416758)

5. Wilt Chamberlain ISH Vote: #5 Player in NBA History (http://insidehoops.com/forum/showthread.php?t=416813)




Rules


1. First player to 20 votes wins. Assuming no player reaches 20 votes within 48 hours, the player with the most votes at that time wins, unless there is a tie in which case, voting will be extended another day (and so on).
2. Voters must have at least one thousand posts.
3. Voters may only vote on ONE account. Alts will not be counted.
4. Serious votes only
5. ABSOLUTELY POSITIVELY NO INCONSISTENT VOTES UNLESS YOU GIVE ME A REASONABLE EXPLANATION FOR THE CHANGE.


Voting Tally

Magic Johnson-1 (Nilocon165)

Shaquille O'Neal-1 (SouBeachTalents)

[Nilocon165]

http://www.careerealism.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/create-job-search-magic.jpg

[SouBeachTalents]

Shaq

[Dray n Klay]

Magic Johnson

[Dray n Klay]

LeBron Fam vote for Magic Johnson so he wins the vote and so Kobe has 0% chance of getting picked

[Dray n Klay]

The better we (the LeBron Fam) coordinate voting selections, the better the chance of Kobe not getting selected until his rightful place at #12

[RRR3]

After the way the last thread went and the stress I had ending it (I'm still hoping I wasn't unfair-I know I changed it at the last second but my changes were correcting my own inconsistencies!) I would like to cede ownership of this project to a willing ISHer. Any takers? No trolls.

[RRR3]

Serious Votes Only=Votes that you actually believe in, not votes organized to prevent another player from getting voted in. Dray N Klay's voting rights have been revoked.

[Orlando Magic]

Allen Iverson.

[RRR3]

Allen Iverson.
Why do you keep doing this to me man? Stop it.

[Dray n Klay]

Serious Votes Only=Votes that you actually believe in, not votes organized to prevent another player from getting voted in. Dray N Klay's voting rights have been revoked.


I am serious about my selection. Magic is #5 in my all time selections




You have no right to revoke my vote

[RRR3]

I'll take over.

I'm an expert when dealing with alts. I have a list I've piled together detailing all the ISH poster's alts.

Also I'm not a troll.
You changed your vote from Shaq in number 4 to Magic in number 5 without explanation despite the fact that Shaq had not been voted in. Denied.

[Inferno]

Tough one. I'll go Shaq.

[RRR3]

I am serious about my selection. Magic is #5 in my all time selections




You have no right to revoke my vote
Delete your posts inciting anti-Kobe voting, and give me a good explanation on why you pick Magic and I'll count it.

[TylerOO]

Magic

[Nilocon165]

Allen Iverson.

Why do you keep doing this to me man? Stop it.
Lmao :roll:

[Orlando Magic]

Why do you keep doing this to me man? Stop it.

Iverson, standing at only 5-foot-11 and 170 pounds, was the ultimate warrior on the court and feared no one. Not even the likes of 7-foot giants such as Shaquille O

[RRR3]

I didn't see you posted about me, I only visit these threads to vote.
Your voting hasn't been consistent, man. I can't ignore that.

[RRR3]

LOL I give up. Someone take this shitshow over for me cuz I'm done. Start it over if you want, I can't do this shit. Sorry guys.

[Nilocon165]

LOL I give up. Someone take this shitshow over for me cuz I'm done. Start it over if you want, I can't do this shit. Sorry guys.
I'll run it m8

[Poetry]

LeBron Fam vote for Magic Johnson so he wins the vote and so Kobe has 0% chance of getting picked

Collusion? :biggums:

[Orlando Magic]

LOL I give up. Someone take this shitshow over for me cuz I'm done. Start it over if you want, I can't do this shit. Sorry guys.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/21/Allen_Iverson_headshot.jpg

[ninephive]

Tim Duncan

[JebronLames]

Magic

[Big164]

Kobe bryant

[Lebronxrings]

I counted Magic winning the last thread before OP edited it. :biggums:

With that said, my vote is obvious. The greatest laker: Magic Johnson.

[Lebronxrings]

LeBron Fam vote for Magic Johnson so he wins the vote and so Kobe has 0% chance of getting picked
kobe has 0 chance either way. Even his biggest stans haven't voted for him besides that SexSymbol retard

[Naero]

Magic Johnson - arguably the GOAT team-leader in modern-NBA history.

[longhornfan1234]

Magic.

[NBAGOAT]

I was interested in running a greatest peaks project after this finished but don't think I'll have enough time to deal with all the problems you've had to deal with. I mean we haven't even gotten to the range where most people think Kobe is a legitimate candidate, that would've gotten ugly as hell.

Edit: btw vote is for Magic. It's a shame this was one of the handful of threads I was interested in the past few weeks.

[arifgokcen]

Magic

[plowking]

When did Magic suddenly become a better player than Bird? Because it was never the case when they were playing. Guess one guy being on TV all the time while the other went away from the lights and cameras impacted on everyone.

Bird>Magic.

And I'll vote Shaq.

[Mr Feeny]

When did Magic suddenly become a better player than Bird? Because it was never the case when they were playing. Guess one guy being on TV all the time while the other went away from the lights and cameras impacted on everyone.

Bird>Magic.

And I'll vote Shaq.

Agree that based on impact, Bird was better. But I think there incorporating career achievements here. It helped that he had Kareem, worthy, Cooper and Scott and the inevitable greater number of titles. Most people don't really rank players based on impact even though they should.

If everyone thought like you, Shaq would be much higher in the list and no lower than 3 all time.

[scuzzy]

Magic

Ive been voting magic since #4 and #5

[Prometheus]

Gotta be magic

[aj1987]

Ugh. Should've been Shaq at #5.

Voting for Shaq again.

[MintBerryCrunch]

Shaq

[k0kakw0rld]

Tim duncan and fxck off everybody who voted him out of the top 5.

[Labissiere]

Shaq

[MP.Trey]

Shaq.

[AkronAngel]

Duncan

[ScalsFan21]

I have Shaq, Bird, and Magic all higher than where they'll end up being on this rank, but I'm going to go with Shaq for this one.

[Dragonyeuw]

Top 5 list is solid regardless of the order, but this is where we get into the nitty gritty.

I don't like the late career team-hopping or the bridge-burning, but I can't rank a top 3 peak and 3 titles as lead dog any lower.

Shaq.

[feyki]

Tim Duncan .

[Sakkreth]

Magic

[Hakeem Olajuwon]

the best point guard of all time
the best player after michael jordan
the best passer

http://66.media.tumblr.com/e487dd467bbc20557277f892b16cd2a8/tumblr_n2lahhA2Rp1qcmnsoo1_1280.jpg

earvin magic johnson