Reminder: ISH already voted on the top 3 goats

[Mr Feeny]

They were the three J's. The same 3 J's that espn voted for.

James, Jordan and jabbar.

In any order :rockon:

Go with the knowledgeable minds of ish who let you know what's what:applause:

[Screamin A Smit]

Our guy is Top 3 all time :banana:



Meanwhile Wilt is barely Top 10 (if that)

[Old Man River]

bird and duncan are better than jabbar

[Mr Feeny]

Ish certainly know who the 3 GOATs are :applause:

[kamil]

bird and duncan are better than jabbar

Bird is also better than LeBron*

[Big164]

The median IQ of this site is like 75, I wouldn't trust it with anything.

Kareem lost to the 1974 Celtics. A C team without Russell or a Bird or even a paul pierce....let that sink in

[SouBeachTalents]

The median IQ of this site is like 75, I wouldn't trust it with anything.

Kareem lost to the 1974 Celtics. A C team without Russell or a Bird or even a paul pierce....let that sink in

That team had Hondo/Cowens/White, 3 MVP/FMVP winners, and they won another title 2 year later. Certainly not a team to dismiss. Besides Kareem was by far the best player in that series, would honestly have an argument for FMVP

[egokiller]

The median IQ of this site is like 75, I wouldn't trust it with anything.

Kareem lost to the 1974 Celtics. A C team without Russell or a Bird or even a paul pierce....let that sink in

I was told that someone who had 40 alts voted for Lebron all 40 times. That would explain why such a beta would ever be considered top 3 all time.

[k0kakw0rld]

bird and duncan are better than jabbar
The shit you smoking is too loud for your own good.

[GrapeApe]

They were the three J's. The same 3 J's that espn voted for.

James, Jordan and jabbar.

In any order :rockon:

Go with the knowledgeable minds of ish who let you know what's what:applause:

Um, I certainly don't recall "in any order" being stipulated on ISH or ESPN. Clearly there's a very specific order.

[hold this L]

How did Lebron make it top 3 with only 3 ships? I still think he is 6-7th overall but can understand top 5 comments. Top 3 though?

:coleman:

[KirbyPls]

How did Lebron make it top 3 with only 3 ships? I still think he is 6-7th overall but can understand top 5 comments. Top 3 though?

:coleman:

Probably has something to do with things beyond rangzzz, like how good he is as a basketball player? :confusedshrug:

Personally, I think top-5 is more realistic than top-3, but on pure ability alone and postseason production one can argue top-3 persuasively.

[hold this L]

Probably has something to do with things beyond rangzzz, like how good he is as a basketball player? :confusedshrug:

Personally, I think top-5 is more realistic than top-3, but on pure ability alone and postseason production one can argue top-3 persuasively.
Well rings do matter when you add that into the argument though. Top 3 is pretty ridiculous no matter how much of an argument you can make, since he couldn't win for half his career before creating a super team with two other amazing players just to do it.. and then it was 2/4 with such a great team. Even though I think top 5 is still a stretch, I can still see peoples' point of view. Top 3 is just stanning to unhealthy levels though, but I expect this out of the 3 users with 50 accounts here or the morons at ESPN who call themselves sports journalists.

To me when he likely wins his 4th, he will end up being top 4-5 and if he wins another one top 3 or top 2. If he wins 3 more though..

https://media.giphy.com/media/VB5WwlZIt8eRy/giphy.gif

[Nick Young]

1. Kobe