What would you take? 27/9/8 or 27/6/6?

[PickernRoller]

Player A: 27/9/8, eliminated from the playoff hunt 5 games after the all-star break.

Player B: 27/6/6, carried his team to the playoffs.

[kennethgriffen]

whatever one doesn't throw teammates under the bus, alienate coaches and at least tries somewhat on defense

[StrongLurk]

Bran

[PickernRoller]

We're not mentioning names here.

Trying to gauge impact value.

[StrongLurk]

We're not mentioning names here.

Trying to gauge impact value.

Too late.

Bran >

[3ball]

whatever one doesn't throw teammates under the bus, alienate coaches and at least tries somewhat on defense
This

And I'll take the stats that occurred while the team played playoff-bound basketball, rather than padding that occurred while the team was playing lottery basketball

[Mask the Embiid]

If player B carried his team to a championship....maybe it would be a tougher choice.But even still, id probably still take player A if he had player B's team


im rollin' with A :applause:

Everything screams that player A is the actual better basketball player than option B. W's L's have more do to with player B's supporting cast

[PickernRoller]

If player B carried his team to a championship....maybe it would be a tougher choice.But even still, id probably still take player A if he had player B's team


im rollin' with A :applause:

Everything screams that player A is the actual better basketball player than option B. W's L's have more do to with player B's supporting cast

Fair... fair...

What if I told you Player B had two of its starters miss 60+ games combined during that season and the back ups to said players missed 90 games? Any difference in opinion then?

[superduper]

I would take whichever one activated their playoff mode recently.

Who was that again?

[Mr Feeny]

Player A is much better obviously. Sounds like player B might have had a better team to carry him.

Whats their efg% and fg% and PER for the season btw?

[3ball]

If player B carried his team to a championship....maybe it would be a tougher choice.But even still, id probably still take player A if he had player B's team


im rollin' with A :applause:

Everything screams that player A is the actual better basketball player than option B. W's L's have more do to with player B's supporting cast
So why did lebron lose in 2011, 2009, and 2014?

Teamwork and brand of ball obviously matters, and lebron causes a weaker brand and teamwork, so he must team-hop for extra talent to win

Can you imagine the panic in lebron's camp when they realized that AD wasn't coming, and they had to rely on Lebron's shit brand of ball to win??? :facepalm :oldlol:

Btw, logical fans know that his cast was sufficient in 17' and 10' too... But it's really hard to win when ur team is getting massively out-assisted and playing an inferior way