Do some idiots really rank Bron over Duncan ?

[Duderonomy]

TD
never missed the playoffs.
Never had any talented players he couldn't gel with.
Never asked to be traded or get his boys roster spots
Won atleast 50 games or lockout equivalent each season.
Won over 1,000 with one franchise.
https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn%3AANd9GcS3tS5n9dp792tAd9QhWGEQlHe4pPE 1Mhapdaj4tSo2eXh3jWNW

[Gileraracer]

Except some (obviously complete empty) stats there is absolutely NO argument for Lebron > Duncan.


Never had to collude with multiple superstars
Never threw his teammates under the bus
Never complained about the lack of help
and
so
on

[FKAri]

TD gets unnecessary hate for being a phaggit.

[superduper]

Except some (obviously complete empty) stats there is absolutely NO argument for Lebron > Duncan.


Never had to collude with multiple superstars
Never threw his teammates under the bus
Never complained about the lack of help
and
so
on

Unfortunately 80% of this forum bases its basketball opinion on $tats and the Bible of BasketballReference

[Gileraracer]

PLus


5 rings with one team >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3 rings with 3 teams

[knicksman]

TD gets unnecessary hate for being a phaggit.

I guess thats the reason why lebron lost to him twice. Coz lebron is the greatest coward in history.

[stalkerforlife]

You'd have to be a complete moron to have Bran over Duncan.

Duncan made SA the best franchise in sports for 15 years after dwelling in obscurity.

[FKAri]

I guess thats the reason why lebron lost to him twice. Coz lebron is the greatest coward in history.
TD was so cowardly that he refused to come out of the closet. Even when he's out of the league he still can't do it. But LeMcMahon lost to TD because TD's a phaggit. He lost to TD because it was the best plot line available.

[Kevin$Durant]

not on my watch

[bullettooth]

TD gets unnecessary hate for being a phaggit.

https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-uDqhHhdrk0M/U3rWkIJ3BhI/AAAAAAAAGys/NE8BdJdFg2M/s280/4.gif

[tontoz]

Not a fan of comparing bigs to wings in general.

[aj1987]

Do some idiots really rank Duncan over LeBron?

LeBron is cemented in the top 3. Duncan is ~7th.

[AirTupac]

aj go back to eating fried rats and centipedes you mongrel. Duncan by all accounts has and is a better player and champion than Bron :oldlol:

[Phoenix]

Wherever he ranks in relation to Bron, I do find Duncan is becoming criminally underrated nowadays. Didn't have the best numbers, flashiest personality, or most aesthetically pleasing game. He 'only' anchored a franchise for 19 seasons that produced 5 championships. He's not the guy you can market to the casual masses though, so :confusedshrug:

[k0kakw0rld]

I love Timmy but No way he ranks higher than LeBron.

Most people have him behind Shaq and Kobe though. Which makes absolutely 0 sense.

[sdot_thadon]

I'm pretty sure most "idiots" consider him better, most smart people do too. Bron is by most recognized as top 5 minimum. Td a little lower.

[G0ATbe]

He's below LeBron, but comfortably above Kobe imo.

[SpaceJam2]

Do some idiots really rank Duncan over LeBron?

LeBron is cemented in the top 3. Duncan is ~7th.

This

[SpaceJam2]

He's below LeBron, but comfortably above Kobe imo.


Yep
Bron top 3
TD top 7
Kobe top 12-15

[305Baller]

Duncan has more titles than LeBron obviously he is ranked higher

[SpaceJam2]

Duncan has more titles than LeBron obviously he is ranked higher

Yep :lol

11 beats 6 :applause:

[bullettooth]

Yep :lol

11 beats 6 :applause:

Ok, let's play that game:

Suppose we use your retard logic that most rings defines who's the GOAT and we list only legit all-time HOF greats. We thus have a greatest ever list that consists of the following:

1. Bill Russell - 11 rings
2. Sam Jones - 10 rings
3. John Havlicek - 8 rings
4. Michael Jordan - 6 rings
5. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar - 6 rings
6. Scottie Pippen - 6 rings
7. Bob Cousy - 6 rings
8. Magic Johnson - 5 rings
9. Kobe Bryant - 5 rings
10. Tim Duncan - 5 rings
11. George Mikan - 5 rings
12. Robert Parish - 4 rings
13. Shaq - 4 rings

And then finally coming in at 14... LeBron James with only 3 rings. Same as Larry Bird. Who I'd take over LeBron any day.

But since we have trolls like Wheels that like to include guys like Robert Horry in the list, then LeBron doesn't show up at all on the list until #28:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NBA_players_with_most_championships

[sdot_thadon]

Ok, let's play that game:

Suppose we use your retard logic that most rings defines who's the GOAT and we list only legit all-time HOF greats. We thus have a greatest ever list that consists of the following:

1. Bill Russell - 11 rings
2. Sam Jones - 10 rings
3. John Havlicek - 8 rings
4. Michael Jordan - 6 rings
5. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar - 6 rings
6. Scottie Pippen - 6 rings
7. Bob Cousy - 6 rings
8. Magic Johnson - 5 rings
9. Kobe Bryant - 5 rings
10. Tim Duncan - 5 rings
11. George Mikan - 5 rings
12. Robert Parish - 4 rings
13. Shaq - 4 rings

And then finally coming in at 14... LeBron James with only 3 rings. Same as Larry Bird. Who I'd take over LeBron any day.

But since we have trolls like Wheels that like to include guys like Robert Horry in the list, then LeBron doesn't show up at all on the list until #28:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NBA_players_with_most_championships
So basically what you're saying is both points of view aren't logical and shouldn't be what you base your list on? Thanks for the tip. :applause:

[TheMan]

Do some idiots really rank Duncan over LeBron?

LeBron is cemented in the top 3. Duncan is ~7th.
:oldlol:

[tpols]

And most importantly duncan dominated bran h2h in the playoffs.

[SpaceJam2]

So basically what you're saying is both points of view aren't logical and shouldn't be what you base your list on? Thanks for the tip. :applause:

Exactly. Clearly he did not get the message :lol

But thankfully you did and now that you've spelled it out for him, hopefully he'll be able to comprehend

[SamuraiSWISH]

And most importantly duncan dominated bran h2h in the playoffs.
OLD Duncan for 2/3 of their series encounters

[tontoz]

I think most people see Duncan as the GOAT 4 and Lebron as the GOAT 3.

If you polled GMs as to which player they would rather have coming into the league, I think you would get mixed results.

[aj1987]

aj go back to eating fried rats and centipedes you mongrel. Duncan by all accounts has and is a better player and champion than Bron :oldlol:
AirRetard, you have the intelligence of a mentally challenged rodent. Please kill yourself and let the sane people talk. :cheers:


:oldlol:
You must be AirRetard level stupid, if you think Duncan isn't at least #7. :oldlol:


I think most people see Duncan as the GOAT 4 and Lebron as the GOAT 3.

If you polled GMs as to which player they would rather have coming into the league, I think you would get mixed results.
Probably 1% of the basketball community has Duncan at #4. Even if you just look at just hardcore basketball fans, most of them would have him out of the top 5. The top 5 is usually: #1 MJ, #2 KAJ, #3 LeBron, #4 Magic, #5 Bird.

[Sportal]

As an individual? LeBron >

Team achievements? Duncan >

[aj1987]

As an individual? LeBron >

Team achievements? Duncan >
That's not saying much since Horry >> Duncan when it comes to team achievements.

I agree with you that LeBron is/was a better player than Duncan though.

[And1AllDay]

AirRetard, you have the intelligence of a mentally challenged rodent. Please kill yourself and let the sane people talk. :cheers:


You must be AirRetard level stupid, if you think Duncan isn't at least #7. :oldlol:


Probably 1% of the basketball community has Duncan at #4. Even if you just look at just hardcore basketball fans, most of them would have him out of the top 5. The top 5 is usually: #1 MJ, #2 KAJ, #3 LeBron, #4 Magic, #5 Bird.

I think he means Goat 4 as in PF and 3 as in SF

Btw keep kicking azz AJ, AirRetard is close to the worst

[superduper]

Duncan is absolutely a more complete team oriented 5v5 basketball player in every sense and both sides of the court.

[Real14]

I can't stand the big boringmental Duncan but even I agree with this most definitely :applause:

[Rico2016]

Duncan is absolutely a more complete team oritented 5v5 basketball player in every sense and both sides of the court.

Do you rank TD over LBJ?

What is your top 5?

[tpols]

OLD Duncan for 2/3 of their series encounters


of which they shouldve won both given how lebron played. Its almost unbelievable how much duncans defensive presence limited him.

[Pointguard]

To make it simple, name me a great player that obviously made his coaches look better while winning it all three times. Now name me all the times a great coach manifested the best qualities in a great player.

[tontoz]

Probably 1% of the basketball community has Duncan at #4. Even if you just look at just hardcore basketball fans, most of them would have him out of the top 5. The top 5 is usually: #1 MJ, #2 KAJ, #3 LeBron, #4 Magic, #5 Bird.


That isn't what i was saying.

I was saying the general consensus is Duncan is the best ever at the 4 (pf) and Lebron the best ever at the 3 (sf).

But if you asked GMs which player they would take to start a team the results would be mixed.

[knicksman]

well, these idiots wouldnt be making multiple alts if their opinions are respected. Theres a reason why they have different opinions than the players

[knicksman]

That's not saying much since Horry >> Duncan when it comes to team achievements.

I agree with you that LeBron is/was a better player than Duncan though.

AJ, evaluating players isnt as easy as reading stats or else most of ISH could be scouts right now. So think before you speak simpleton

[aj1987]

That isn't what i was saying.

I was saying the general consensus is Duncan is the best ever at the 4 (pf) and Lebron the best ever at the 3 (sf).

But if you asked GMs which player they would take to start a team the results would be mixed.
I honestly doubt it. If you asked 10 GM's who they'd pick to start a franchise, I'd guarantee that LeBron would be picked by 9.


AJ, evaluating players isnt as easy as reading stats or else most of ISH could be scouts right now. So think before you speak simpleton
Go jump off a cliff, you autistic ****.