5 years of a Top 10 GOAT or 10 years of a superstar

[SouBeachTalents]

Pretty simple concept, would you rather have 5 years of a top 10 all time player, or 10 years of a superstar caliber ATG. You're choosing these strictly off which scenario you think you'd win the most titles. To make this fair, you'd have a similar caliber roster throughout each players tenure, there wouldn't be any rebuilding or starting from scratch. Choose from the following

5 years Jordan or 10 years Dr. J

5 years Kareem or 10 years Curry

5 years Shaq or 10 years Robinson

5 years Hakeem or 10 years KG

5 years LeBron or 10 years Durant

5 years Bird or 10 years Dirk

5 years Magic or 10 years Barkley

5 years Duncan or 10 years Moses

5 years Kobe or 10 years Malone

[RRR3]

Which Malone

[Manny98]

I'd rather have 5 years of a top 10 GOAT since their primes would last around 5 years anyway

[Dr Hawk]

Going with 5 years in all cases except maybe in the Bird vs Dirk.

Easiest choices have been Jordan, Hakeem, Shaq and Kobe.

[CAstill]

Pretty simple concept, would you rather have 5 years of a top 10 all time player, or 10 years of a superstar caliber ATG. You're choosing these strictly off which scenario you think you'd win the most titles. To make this fair, you'd have a similar caliber roster throughout each players tenure, there wouldn't be any rebuilding or starting from scratch. Choose from the following

5 years Jordan or 10 years Dr. J

5 years Kareem or 10 years Curry

5 years Shaq or 10 years Robinson

5 years Hakeem or 10 years KG

5 years LeBron or 10 years Durant

5 years Bird or 10 years Dirk

5 years Magic or 10 years Barkley

5 years Duncan or 10 years Moses

5 years Kobe or 10 years Malone

Magic vs Barkley was difficult for me

[LostCause]

Jordan
Curry
Shaq
KG
Durant
Bird
Magic
Duncan
Can go either way in Kobe/Malone

[AirBonner]

LeBron is both

[Turbo Slayer]

LeBron is both

Fax.