Was Elgin Baylor as good as a prime Lebron James?

[Marchesk]

Elgin was putting up historical numbers in the 61-63. He's having one of the best performances from a 6'8 and under player in 20 years.

[RRR3]

No.



/thread

[AirBonner]

Op doesn’t even compare stats and for good reason because LeBron is goat

[Round Mound]

The 50s and 60s Charles Barkley....:bowdown:

[FourthTenor]

OP, I don't have no beef with you normally.

But if you want me to personally fvck you up?

Keep talkin that mess about King GOAT The Hung.

See what happens.

[AirBonner]

OP, I don't have no beef with you normally.

But if you want me to personally fvck you up?

Keep talkin that mess about King GOAT The Hung.

See what happens.

:applause::oldlol:

[SouBeachTalents]

No

He was better

[Axe]

Depends on which of them was more dominant

[Whoah10115]

1. Bird
2. LeBron
3. Havlicek
4. Baylor
5. Barry
6. Erving
7. Durant
8. Pippen
9. Dominique
10. Pierce

I don't know.

[Marchesk]

Op doesn’t even compare stats and for good reason because LeBron is goat

For the years in question, Elgin was putting up 34+/14+/4+ assists for regular and playoff seasons. Kind of like uh ... I don't know ... comparing Giannis this season to some great player in the past.

[FourthTenor]

1. Bird
2. LeBron
3. Havlicek
4. Baylor
5. Barry
6. Erving
7. Durant
8. Pippen
9. Dominique
10. Pierce

I don't know.


So, Imma give you the benefit of the doubt that you made an accidental mix up with those #1 and 2 spots.

And when I come back here tomorrow, I hope I’ll see it corrected.

Because if I dont... I think youll end up having some serious regrets.


Have a nice day. :cheers:

[Marchesk]

1. Bird
2. LeBron
3. Havlicek
4. Baylor
5. Barry
6. Erving
7. Durant
8. Pippen
9. Dominique
10. Pierce

I don't know.

Sounds legit. Except I'd replace Pippen with Ewing.

[Whoah10115]

Sounds legit. Except I'd replace Pippen with Ewing.

:oldlol:

[r0drig0lac]

So, Imma give you the benefit of the doubt that you made an accidental mix up with those #1 and 2 spots.

And when I come back here tomorrow, I hope I’ll see it corrected.

Because if I dont... I think youll end up having some serious regrets.


Have a nice day. :cheers:

lmao

[Smoke117]

1. Bird
2. LeBron
3. Havlicek
4. Baylor
5. Barry
6. Erving
7. Durant
8. Pippen
9. Dominique
10. Pierce

I don't know.

Rick Barry at 5? :oldlol:

[TheCorporation]

You tell me

https://i.postimg.cc/hPQF8Hnc/you-tell-me.png

[Marchesk]

You tell me

https://i.postimg.cc/hPQF8Hnc/you-tell-me.png

We gonna pretend like Baylor got to play remotely as many playoff games as Lebron? Remember how Lebron can score 60 "anytime he wants to" in the regular season (aka when playing Charlotte)? Baylor did that in a finals against the greatest dynasty in sports history.

[Round Mound]

You tell me

https://i.postimg.cc/hPQF8Hnc/you-tell-me.png

Acculative Longevity Stats...< Per Game, Dominance and Efficiency Stats.

[Roundball_Rock]

OP is satirizing the "Wilt and Giannis" thread.

[TheCorporation]

We gonna pretend like Baylor got to play remotely as many playoff games as Lebron? Remember how Lebron can score 60 "anytime he wants to" in the regular season (aka when playing Charlotte)? Baylor did that in a finals against the greatest dynasty in sports history.

12 playoffs is okay I guess, LeBron has made 13 so that's a knock on Baylor (no longevity, sorry). He also wasn't a consistent gifted Finals scorer.

He only led his team in Finals scoring 3 times in his career, LeBron did it 8 times. If Elgin led in Finals scoring more he would have more points, but 3 wont cut it. That's Kobe level. Not GOAT level.

[TheCorporation]

Acculative Longevity Stats...< Per Game, Dominance and Efficiency Stats.

Longevity? :lol

Playoffs made
LeBron: 13
Jordan :13
Baylor: 12
Bird: 12
Kareem: 16?
Kobe: 15
Shaq: 16

The list goes on my friend.

#Sorry

[Whoah10115]

Rick Barry at 5? :oldlol:

I said I don't know. He has reasons on the day.

[GimmeThat]

he's more like James Harden if Harden didn't have to run the offense

[kawhileonard2]

Only Bird and Kawhi at SF was better.

[FourthTenor]

12 playoffs is okay I guess, LeBron has made 13 so that's a knock on Baylor (no longevity, sorry). He also wasn't a consistent gifted Finals scorer.

He only led his team in Finals scoring 3 times in his career, LeBron did it 8 times. If Elgin led in Finals scoring more he would have more points, but 3 wont cut it. That's Kobe level. Not GOAT level.



https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/71sz3WCmsOL.png



We STAY winning :pimp: :rockon:

[bullettooth]

He was better than LeBron. Dude won ZERO rings out of 8 tries compared to LeBron's 3/9.

[FromDowntown]

https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/71sz3WCmsOL.png



We STAY winning :pimp: :rockon:

Winners win :rockon:

[3ball]

.
Greatest pure scorers of all-time

Jordan
Elgin
Bird
Kobe
K Malone
Harden
KD
Gervin
Ingram

If you don't like Elgin at #2, you could bump him down a spot or two, but he's right up there

[AirBonner]

.
Greatest pure scorers of all-time

Jordan
Elgin
Bird
Kobe
K Malone
Harden
KD
Gervin
Ingram

If you don't like Elgin at #2, you could bump him down a spot or two, but he's right up there

LeBron #1 in playoff points. Pretty good for a non shooter

[MrFonzworth]

.
Greatest pure scorers of all-time

Jordan
Elgin
Bird
Kobe
K Malone
Harden
KD
Gervin
Ingram

If you don't like Elgin at #2, you could bump him down a spot or two, but he's right up there

:coleman:

[Manny98]

1. Bird
2. LeBron
3. Havlicek
4. Baylor
5. Barry
6. Erving
7. Durant
8. Pippen
9. Dominique
10. Pierce

I don't know.
Imagine having Bird ahead of Lebron in 2020 :lol

[Roundball_Rock]

.
Greatest pure scorers of all-time

Jordan
Elgin
Bird
Kobe
K Malone
Harden
KD
Gervin
Ingram

If you don't like Elgin at #2, you could bump him down a spot or two, but he's right up there

Brandom Ingram behind Gervin, KD, Harden. :lol

[TheCorporation]

Brandom Ingram behind Gervin, KD, Harden. :lol

:lol What a loon

[TheCorporation]

LeBron #1 in playoff points. Pretty good for a non shooter

Not bad at all

Should hit 7k this year
No one else even has 6k

:lebronamazed:

LeBar

[Lebron23]

Lebron is the greatest small forward of all time. Even Larry Bird said it.

[houston]

1. Bird
2. LeBron
3. Havlicek
4. Baylor
5. Barry
6. Erving
7. Durant
8. Pippen
9. Dominique
10. Pierce

I don't know.



no grant hill???

[Shooter]

You tell me

https://i.postimg.cc/hPQF8Hnc/you-tell-me.png

#19???? Issa wrap

OP back to the drawing board :lol

[ImKobe]

#19???? Issa wrap

OP back to the drawing board :lol

Less Playoff games/rounds in that era lol, why compare point totals? Kareem & MJ would both probably be ahead of Lebron if the 1st round was the same in their eras.

[FourthTenor]

Less Playoff games/rounds in that era lol, why compare point totals? Kareem & MJ would both probably be ahead of Lebron if the 1st round was the same in their eras.


Why??

Lol.


Gee, I dunno. :confusedshrug:

Maybe it’s because Lebron’s got 12 inches of certified premium beefsteak packed in his downstairs business :hammerhead:



Smarten up. This is your warning.

[Roundball_Rock]

no grant hill???

He didn't have the longevity. Maybe top 15 all-time SF since at some point his brilliance over 5-6 years trumps other guys being stars but not superstars for 10-11 years.

[Whoah10115]

no grant hill???

Grant at his best could have been #7 (don't care who thinks otherwise), but I don't know if overall I could take him ahead of either Nique or Pierce.

He's my #11.