Which of these recent Big Men are you taking?

[L.Kizzle]

Which of these four big men would you take at their peak?
All four were multiple time All-Stars in past decade or so.

Al Horford
Paul Millsap
David Lee
David West

[SouBeachTalents]

Lol, I'd actually rank them in the exact order you had in the OP

Horford
Millsap
Lee
West

[RRR3]

Millsap and Horford are a tier above the other two. It’s definitely between them. I can’t really decide they are both so useful.

[NBAGOAT]

I’m going millsap. Had like 80% of draymonds impact on defense for a few years in Atlanta. The most versatile of the four here on both ends

[fsvr54]

Millsap was DPOY level his last year on the Hawks. He's also more mobile and can shot create better than Horford.

[Reggie43]

David West easy, great leader, clutch and plays the right way. Heart and Soul of Vogels grit and grind Pacers.

[Gohan]

I’m taking David lee surprising huh?

[L.Kizzle]

I’m taking David lee surprising huh?

David Lee beat out Stephen Curry to make the 2013 West All-Star Team. Lee put up 19/11/4. Steph 22/3/7.
The majority of the coaches thought he was a better player than Steph that season.

[starface]

I'll take the real Playoff P first.

Then West.

Not sure between Horford and Lee. Horford never seems to make the impact I expect when I watch games. Lee always had great hustle and even some nice statistical years, but it never seemed to get his teams anywhere. If I have to pay them the same salary I'll take Horford, if I can get Lee at a discount I'll take him.