If Lebron wins another title, does he surpass Magic?

[Kiddlovesnets]

Right now the top 3 of all time are MJ, Kareem and Magic, though Lebron can potentially challenge the top 3 if he wins the title. We can analyze Lebron vs Magic at the current stage for some insights into this question:

Titles: Magic(5) > Lebron(3)
FMVPs: Magic(3) = Lebron(3)
Finals Winning Percentage: Magic(55.5%) > Lebron(33.3%)
MVPs: Magic(3) < Lebron(4)
Scoring: Magic(19.5ppg) < Lebron(27.1ppg)
Playmaking: Magic(11.2apg) > Lebron(7.4apg)

As we can see, Magic is a clear winner right now, he is better at 3 criteria(Titles, FMVPs, Finals Winning Percentage) for top 5 players comparison, while Lebron is better at 2 criteria(MVP, Scoring). If Lebron wins a title, he will have 4, and will still be below Magic. The Finals Winning Percentage will not get much better either, while the MVP this year was already handed to Giannis. For Lebron to make a case of surpassing Magic, he has to win the FMVP. With the 4th FMVP, Lebron will win the FMVP criterion against Magic, and they will be tied 3-3. In this case, it will be a hot debate who is the greater player on the all time list. If Anthony Davis wins FMVP, Lebron will not be able to surpass Magic, since Magic will still have an edge over him on the above 6 criteria(winning 3-2).

What do you think? Does Lebron surpass Magic with another FMVP ring?

[TheCorporation]

Win or lose, he's still the GOAT

https://i.postimg.cc/0j6rkSHY/20200818-141141.jpg

[1987_Lakers]

lol, he surpassed Magic years ago.

[light]

Bron passed Magic several years ago

[SouBeachTalents]

Is this thread from 2016?

[keep-itreal]

He surpassed Magic a long time ago . He's #2 best of all time behind MJ. If he wins 2 or 3 more rings with the Lakers it will be

1A: MJ
1B: Lebron

[starface]

“Does he” surpass Magic :roll:

You a funny one, OP

[starface]

He surpassed Magic a long time ago . He's #2 best of all time behind MJ


You funny too.


:crazysam:

[TheCorporation]

Zero votes for a dumbass thread :lol

Nice work :lol

[SaltyMeatballs]

He passed Magic in 2016, as well as many other greats. LeBron solidified himself as a top 3 player ever after beating the 72-10 Warriors

He's up there with MJ and Kareem now. I got him at 2 behind Mike

[TheCorporation]

1 star thread and zero votes :lol

[TheCorporation]

Roundball deleted his comment!

I was gonna add:

And don't forget Kareem Davis led his team in Finals scoring 5 times. 3rd most ALL TIME! TOP 3 GOAT

[Kiddlovesnets]

lol, he surpassed Magic years ago.

Nah LeBron is still a poor man’s magic right now, which is why the comparison with MJ is meaningless until he at least surpasses magic.

[And1AllDay]

Win or lose, he's still the GOAT

https://i.postimg.cc/0j6rkSHY/20200818-141141.jpg

issa wrap

:hammertime:

[Smook A.]

Nah LeBron is still a poor man’s magic right now, which is why the comparison with MJ is meaningless until he at least surpasses magic.

How is LeBron a poor man's Magic? He does everything better than him excpet playmaking where Magic has a little edge.

[BigtimeNBAFan]

How is LeBron a poor man's Magic? He does everything better than him excpet playmaking where Magic has a little edge.

Yeah I don't think Magic would even admit he was better than Lebron.

[And1AllDay]

Yeah I don't think Magic would even admit he was better than Lebron.

magic knows the order

bran
kobe
magic
kareems
mike

[ThatCoolKid]

Low IQ thread. OP dumb as bricks.

[Kiddlovesnets]

How is LeBron a poor man's Magic? He does everything better than him excpet playmaking where Magic has a little edge.

Did you not read this thread? Magic is better at 3 things(number of titles, finals winning percentage, passing skills) while Lebron is better at 2(number of mvps and scoring ability). For this reason magic is ahead of Lebron right now, and we can call magic the rich man’s Lebron.

[And1AllDay]

Did you not read this thread? Magic is better at 3 things(number of titles, finals winning percentage, passing skills) while Lebron is better at 2(number of mvps and scoring ability). For this reason magic is ahead of Lebron right now, and we can call magic the rich man’s Lebron.

https://i.postimg.cc/XYbbNkJh/most-win-shares-bran.png

my b