Top 25 Shooting Guards of All-Time Voting Part 3: Players 11-15

[L.Kizzle]

Select and rank the next five (players 11 through 15) of the greatest SHOOTING GUARDS of All-Time. A 48 Hour window will be given to make your choices or debate why said player should or shouldn’t be here. After 48 Hours, the top five will be selected and another five will be added to the pool of players.


Players to Choose From:
Bill Sharman
David Thompson
Earl Monroe
Gail Goodrich
Hal Greer
Klay Thompson
Manu Ginobili
Mitch Richmond
Paul Westphal
Pistol Pete Maravich
Reggie Miller
Sam Jones
Sidney Moncrief
Tracy McGrady
Vince Carter


Top 25 Shooting Guards: 1-10
1 Michael Jordan
2 Kobe Bryant
3 Jerry West
4 Dwyane Wade
5 James Harden
6 Allen Iverson
7 George Gervin
8 Clyde Drexler
9 Joe Dumars
10 Ray Allen


Voting Results
Number of Voters - 9
Number of Players Receiving Votes - 10


Allen Iverson (3) 1st Place / (2) 2nd Place / (2) 3rd Place / (1) 4th Place / (1) 5th Place = 58 Points
George Gervin (2) 1st Place / (3) 2nd Place / (2) 3rd Place / (1) 4th Place = 54 Points
Clyde Drexler (3) 1st Place / (1) 2nd Place / (2) 3rd Place / (2) 4th Place = 53 Points
Joe Dumars (1) 1st Place / (1) 2nd Place / (1) 5th Place = 18 Points
Ray Allen (1) 2nd Place / (1) 4th Place / (5) 5th Place = 15 Points
Tracy McGrady (1) 3rd Place / (3) 4th Place - 14 Points
Sam Jones (1) 2nd Place / (1) 4th Place = 10 Points
Pistol Pete Maravich (1) 3rd Place / (1) 5th Place = 6 Points
Hal Greer (1) 3rd Place = 5 Points
Reggie Miller (1) 5th Place = 1 Point



Voting Criteria
Five Seasons or more played in the NBA
1st = 10 Pts
2nd = 7 Pts
3rd = 5 Pts
4th = 3 Pts
5th = 1 Pt

Top-25-Shooting-Guards-of-All-Time-Voting-Part-2-Players-6-10 (http://www.insidehoops.com/forum/showthread.php?487244-Top-25-Shooting-Guards-of-All-Time-Voting-Part-2-Players-6-10)

[Reggie43]

Sam Jones
Hal Greer
Reggie Miller
Sidney Moncrief
Earl Monroe

[SouBeachTalents]

11. McGrady
12. Reggie
13. Vince
14. Manu
15. Moncrief

[dankok8]

11. Vince
12. TMac
13. Reggie
14. Sam Jones
15. Pistol Pete

[L.Kizzle]

11. Vince
12. TMac
13. Reggie
14. Sam Jones
15. Pistol Pete
Vince over McGrady? How come?

[tanibanana]

11. S. Jones
12. H. Greer
13. D. Thompson
14. T. McGrady
15. R. Miller

[L.Kizzle]

11. S. Jones
12. H. Greer
13. D. Thompson
14. T. McGrady
15. R. Miller
Skywalker is one of the most underrated TALENTS ever in the league.
Was probably the size of Russell Westbrook and even more athletic than him.

[tanibanana]

Skywalker is one of the most underrated TALENTS ever in the league.
Was probably the size of Russell Westbrook and even more athletic than him.

Absolutely true. I was into thinking of putting him at #11 just to increase his total votes.. but I decided to stay true to my ranking (which I always take ABA into account).

[Phoenix]

Man, Joe D snuck into the top ten I see.

Tmac
Vince
Reggie
Maravich
Greer

[RRR3]

1. T-Mac
2. Reggie
3. Vince
4. Sam Jones
5. Greer I guess

[L.Kizzle]

Absolutely true. I was into thinking of putting him at #11 just to increase his total votes.. but I decided to stay true to my ranking (which I always take ABA into account).
Thoughts on Paul Westphal
Sidney Monroe
Gail Goodrich
Mitch Richmond

[IGOTGAME]

How did Ray Allen get so overrated? Smh he should be back like three spots

1. Tracy McGrady
2. Manu Ginobili
3. Klay Thompson
4. Reggie Miller
5. Vince Carter

[L.Kizzle]

How did Ray Allen get so overrated? Smh he should be back like three spots

1. Tracy McGrady
2. Manu Ginobili
3. Klay Thompson
4. Reggie Miller
5. Vince Carter
Says Ray is overrated but puts Manu at #2 ...
If anyone is overrated, I think it's Joe Dumars here.

[Phoenix]

Says Ray is overrated but puts Manu at #2 ...
If anyone is overrated, I think it's Joe Dumars here.

Yeah, love Joe D but he's not top 10. Maybe before 2000 but once that decade of great shooting guards hit he dropped a notch or two.

[L.Kizzle]

Yeah, love Joe D but he's not top 10. Maybe before 2000 but once that decade of great shooting guards hit he dropped a notch or two.
Not even. Before 2000.
Jordan
Drexler
Gervin
Pistol
Monroe (1 vote so far ...)
Sam Jones
Sharman
Greer

That's just the 8 from the 50 Greatest List.

Than from his era Miller and Richmond and Sidney Monroe.
And Thompson, Goodrich, Westphal, Scott from previous eras.

[Phoenix]

Not even. Before 2000.
Jordan
Drexler
Gervin
Pistol
Monroe (1 vote so far ...)
Sam Jones
Sharman
Greer

That's just the 8 from the 50 Greatest List.

Than from his era Miller and Richmond and Sidney Monroe.
And Thompson, Goodrich, Westphal, Scott from previous eras.

That's the trick when it comes to comparing guys like Jones, Sharman and Greer from totally different eras. For me, in terms of my experience guys like Jordan and Drexler from his era are obvious and inarguable. Pistol and Gervin were before my time so I rely on available footage for eye test, testimony and stats. Ditto for Moncrief, Thompson and Goodrich. Mitch and Reggie have been hot topics lately in terms of their pecking order.

All that said, wherever you feel Joe ranked before 2000, when you had a decade of Kobe, Wade,Tmac, Vince, Iverson, Ray, etc only a few guys historically were protected from that avalanche.