Antetokounmpo, Curry, or Doncic - Who should be MVP?

[Stephonit]

If Giannis, Steph, and Luka led their teams to the same record, who would be most deserving of MVP among them other things being equal?

[highwhey]

labron

[Im so nba'd out]

Lebron. Crazy even though he wasnt listed in the poll somehow he still wins

[Ben Simmons]

Depends if Porzingis comes back

[Gus Hemmingway]

I’ll take the guy who won FMVP over LeBron....













:oldlol:

[Bronbron23]

labron

Nah bron could win it if he really wanted to but he'll coast and save his legs for the post season. Answer is luka. Both him and greek wil have comparable numbers but greek already won it twice. If its close tie will go to the guy who hasn't won it yet.

[k0kakw0rld]

Dumb thread. You want us to make that decision based off preseason games? :facepalm

[Stephonit]

Dumb thread. You want us to make that decision based off preseason games? :facepalm

Not at all. I'm taking the temperature before the narratives start getting spun. Who would have performed most impressively if their teams finished with the same record?

[Axe]

Booker

[Stanley Kobrick]

Booker
:cheers:

[highwhey]

Booker

:oldlol:

[Axe]

:oldlol:
Why not? :rolleyes:

[highwhey]

Why not? :rolleyes:

he hasn't done nothing. my utah jazz make the 5th seed every season and i think that's something very special even tho they lose in the first round most of the time, when they happen to make it to the 2nd round, they win 1 game and then go home. to me, that type of mediocrity is special and it's considered something, more than booker can claim.

[Axe]

he hasn't done nothing. my utah jazz make the 5th seed every season and i think that's something very special even tho they lose in the first round most of the time, when they happen to make it to the 2nd round, they win 1 game and then go home. to me, that type of mediocrity is special and it's considered something, more than booker can claim.
Whoa, whoa. :biggums:

Be careful or else, you'll get Xiao Yao Ming swinging in here like tarzan again.

[Stanley Kobrick]

it seems the majority of user prefer Giannis and Luka over Stephen Curry. very interesting

[red1]

lbj

[Bronbron23]

it seems the majority of user prefer Giannis and Luka over Stephen Curry. very interesting

Probably because they'll score around the same but be elite in other areas. For greek its defense and rebounding for luka it's passing and rebounding. Curry is only great at one thing

[Stephonit]

Probably because they'll score around the same but be elite in other areas. For greek its defense and rebounding for luka it's passing and rebounding. Curry is only great at one thing

Even if we are to assume this is true (it isn't) in the given scenario they still helped their respective teams to the same winning record. Why should being good in various skills be given more weight than being great in one?

[Axe]

Curry is only great at one thing
#NotmyMVP

[Stephonit]

No substantive thoughts at this time? Anyone?

[Hakkim90cc]

Curry because Klay is out.

[Kiddlovesnets]

Antetokounmpo has the far better team, and will likely to win 55-60 games, the record is what matters.

[Stephonit]

Antetokounmpo has the far better team, and will likely to win 55-60 games, the record is what matters.

Which doesn't address the question posed. If they were to wind up with the same record who would deserve the MVP?

[OrlandoMagicGuy]

Giannis doesn't deserve anymore MVPs,he openly admitted he was willing to be a second or third option playing next to L46ron and AD.He still has no jumpshot or a postgame.How many more seasons are his fanboys gonna keep giving excuses for him and pointing the finger at his role player teammates?