Vince Carter or Paul Pierce?

[TAZORAC]

Leave the championships out of it...who was the better player?

I think Vince Carter was a better player in his prime, but Pierce had the better career.

[FKAri]

Even when doing a prime for prime, I'd go with Pierce. Carter could really get going and surpass Pierce when his jumper was falling and if he was facing a certain kind of defense. However, Pierce was more reliable when you needed a score even in the toughest of circumstances. Stability vs volatility when it's this close, I'll go with stability.

I will add that I don't think Carter reached the prime he could have had due to injuries. I guess Nets was his prime but his best season was 2001, his second year.

[theman93]

The Truth

VC in a dunk contest though

[2much_knowledge]

Vince!!! But is close

[SATAN]

The guy who didn't fake an injury because he shit himself

[King Kawhi]

I personally prefer Paul Pierce.