MVP Rose vs Trae Young vs Luka Doncic

[Taurus]

Is it fair to say that both Trae and Doncic are currently better than Rose was in his MVP season?

Rose was 22 years old when he won MVP, as are Trae and Doncic currently

[PeroAntic]

They are not. MVP Rose was a unique phenomenon, a force of nature. Nobody played like him before or after. He defied the laws of physics and paid the price for that.

If the NBA was the Matrix, Trae and Luka would be agents, while Rose would be Neo.

[Axe]

I'm kinda starting to agree that 2011 was one of the weakest mvps ever. :(

[Vino24]

Prime Derrick Rose would be a bench pg for current Trae

[Manny98]

Trae
Rose
Luka

Rose has been to the conference finals only once in 7 trys

Trae is the best shooter and the best passer out of the 3 and is the most clutch

It's clear who you would want on your team

[Taurus]

For me they're all comparable, however I give the edge to Young because his current playoff run is better than any of Rose's runs.

And although Doncic's playoff resume is a little empty, he's had the misfortune of playing the Clippers first round twice

[HylianNightmare]

That's Dwight's mvp anyway

[Axe]

For me they're all comparable, however I give the edge to Young because his current playoff run is better than any of Rose's runs.

And although Doncic's playoff resume is a little empty, he's had the misfortune of playing the Clippers first round twice
PA in shambles upon reading this.

[Bronbron23]

They are not. MVP Rose was a unique phenomenon, a force of nature. Nobody played like him before or after. He defied the laws of physics and paid the price for that.

If the NBA was the Matrix, Trae and Luka would be agents, while Rose would be Neo.

This rose was the craziest thing I've seen. Trae and luka are both very talented but they also have the advantage of playing in the easiest era ever. They get alot of points and assists that are a result of the defensive rules that are in place. Don't get me wrong they're still nice with it in any era but they aren't putting up these numbers in more difficult era's

[Gohan]

rose is better period.

[tontoz]

I would definitely take Luka and Trae over MVP Rose. Don't even have to think about it.

[Sportal]

Damn... I love me some Rose... But I just don't see him beating those 76ers in Young's place... But if you give John Collins to the Mavs instead of Porzingis the Clippers.get beat.

[HBK_Kliq_2]

Yes, they are better playmakers and they are also better shooters (Trae mid range and luka 3's).

We still have to see a lengthy playoff run from luka to clearly more evaluate him as a playoff performer. I would still rank them:

1) trae
2) luka
3) rose

[Ice Trae]

I prefer Trae due to his supreme passing ability

[PeroAntic]

MVP Rose was before the league became soft and all about spacing, and he was still shredding defences. next