Higher All-Time: Pippen or Giannis

[dankok8]

Who's higher on the all-time list right now?

[SATAN]

One carried the phony goat to six championships while the other is generally regarded as talented but unskilled. :confusedshrug:

[SaintzFury13]

Giannis will without question go down as the better player when his career is finished. But right now? It's Pippen.

[dankok8]

Vote people!

[Magic Is Magic]

Giannis will without question go down as the better player when his career is finished. But right now? It's Pippen.

I will cosign this.

[HBK_Kliq_2]

Its like asking after 2001 does Shaq have a better career then Pippen? Most would say yes I think.

Giannis has double the mvps, more finals mvp, more defensive player of the years. Giannis career is clearly better and should be more compared to Jordan.

I don't value regular season totals that much, otherwise a guy like john Stockton would be like top 15 goat and even a guy like Carmello Anthony has career scoring totals of a top 10 or top 15 goat but is never even on top 50 lists, tony parker has more career playoff points then Larry Bird.

A prime of about 9-10 years is all you need, not this total scoring points shit. Kawhi and Giannis are well on their way.

[TheCorporation]

Its like asking after 2001 does Shaq have a better career then Pippen? Most would say yes I think.

Giannis has double the mvps, more finals mvp, more defensive player of the years. Giannis career is clearly better and should be more compared to Jordan.

I don't value regular season totals that much, otherwise a guy like john Stockton would be like top 15 goat and even a guy like Carmello Anthony has career scoring totals of a top 10 or top 15 goat but is never even on top 50 lists, tony parker has more career playoff points then Larry Bird.

A prime of about 9-10 years is all you need, not this total scoring points shit. Kawhi and Giannis are well on their way.


A Kawhi fan that doesn't value consistency or longevity. Imagine that :lol

[Phoenix]

Its like asking after 2001 does Shaq have a better career then Pippen? Most would say yes I think.

Giannis has double the mvps, more finals mvp, more defensive player of the years. Giannis career is clearly better and should be more compared to Jordan.

I don't value regular season totals that much, otherwise a guy like john Stockton would be like top 15 goat and even a guy like Carmello Anthony has career scoring totals of a top 10 or top 15 goat but is never even on top 50 lists, tony parker has more career playoff points then Larry Bird.

A prime of about 9-10 years is all you need, not this total scoring points shit. Kawhi and Giannis are well on their way.

Considering what Kawhi's career totals are likely to be, not surprising you'd die on that hill.

That said, the rest of your post didn't have me reaching for Advil and a bottle of 150 proof rum for once.

[000]

A Kawhi fan that doesn't value consistency or longevity. Imagine that :lol

:roll:

[ClipperRevival]

LOL. This board is mentally ill. You can make a poll with Pip and anyone else in history and this board will make it close.

Pip is THE most overrated player EVER. Not even close.

[Manny98]

Giannis is a two time MVP and DPOY and has lead a team to a championship as a first option

That alone shits on Pippens entire resume

Like ClippersRevival said Pippen is getting massively overrated nowadays

[dankok8]

LOL. This board is mentally ill. You can make a poll with Pip and anyone else in history and this board will make it close.

Pip is THE most overrated player EVER. Not even close.

I agree with you but a forum top 50 should represent the opinion of this forum. If most of this forum is Lebron stans then so be it! Mind you, RealGM is also full of people who stan Lebron and generally underrate Lebron's teammates and overrate Jordan's teammates in their agendas. It's not unique to this board although the level of trolling here is unique!

[Nike D'Antoni]

Has any opinion changed? Seeing Giannis vs Barkley/Malone thread.

[SouBeachTalents]

I just don't see any argument for Pippen outside of 2nd option titles. Giannis imo is a top 25 player now, Pippen's in the 30-35 range.

[1987_Lakers]

I know it's an older thread, but why even make it? That's like asking who is higher all-time between Gary Payton & Luka. We all know Luka will eventually have the greater career once he is retired if he plays to his current level for years to come.

[Xiao Yao You]

Pippen always was highly overrated. Giannis is the best player in the game today

[Xiao Yao You]

I know it's an older thread, but why even make it? That's like asking who is higher all-time between Gary Payton & Luka. We all know Luka will eventually have the greater career once he is retired if he plays to his current level for years to come.

Luka will put up bigger numbers. Got a lot to prove otherwise

[Full Court]

If he were to retire right now, I'd have to say it would go to Giannis. He's just got too many accolades that Pippen doesn't. FMVP, MPVs, DPOYs, etc.

[L.Kizzle]

Giannis.
Giannis is in season ten, not season 3. He's secured his spot.

[basketballcat]

The 90s GOAT, of course. :violin:

[Axe]

One carried the phony goat to six championships while the other is generally regarded as talented but unskilled. :confusedshrug:
:roll:

[Jasper]

pip is a top 50 / end discussion

[3ba11]

Giannis will without question go down as the better player when his career is finished. But right now? It's Pippen.


1 goat-level FMVP ring > 6 Horry rings

(and actually, pippen is 0/6 in matching Horry's gamescore from the 95' Finals, aka he's 0/6 in matching Horry's overall boxscore & efficiency of 18/10/3/2/3 on 50%.... that's a low bar that everyone with a meaningful sample size will exceed, except Pippen)