Who would you rather rank Wilt - Jerry West or Chris Broussard?

[3ba11]

The top 75 should be voted on by a select group of the most credible people that have seen both Wilt and Lebron play, like Jerry West, Bill Russell and Pat Riley.

Why do we have to say a player is top 75 just because a bunch of Joe the Plumbers with journalism degrees say so?

It's literally the dumbest shit in the history of the world

[RRR3]

Are you seriously mad LeBron made the top 75

[Phoenix]

Pippen being in the top 75( was in the top 50 actually back in 97) has skullfukked OP.

[Kobe_Bryant]

players and coaches are the only ones that should ever vote on any award or list

[HBK_Kliq_2]

I agree. The top 75 is a joke. It's no more credible then inside hoops list or realgm list, it's probably worse actually due to more ego driven people having votes.

[StrongLurk]

Jerry West, Bill Russell and Pat Riley would ALL rank Lebron MUCH higher than OP does...what a fukin moron.

[2ball]

I have LeBron at 20 due to team hopping and stacking the deck which I think is fair

[8Ball]

I have LeBron at 20 due to team hopping and stacking the deck which I think is fair

I have LeBron at 1 due to being the best basketball player that ever lived.

[3ba11]

I have LeBron at 1 due to being the best basketball player that ever lived.

He literally can't win if he scores too much because it's such a shitty brand (ball-dominance) and his high scoring games have too much of this shitty strategy

Since he can't win with high scoring, he needs 1b sidekicks that can match or exceed his scoring for entire playoff runs (11', 16', 20'), and infact needs elite 1st options to play 2nd and 3rd option (super-teams)

[3ba11]

.
Thread Cliffs


Media awards have completely distorted the top 75 and should be eliminated altogether going forward

[8Ball]

Jordan got swept with high scoring vs Boston.

[8Ball]

.
Thread Cliffs


Media awards have completely distorted the top 75 and should be eliminated altogether going forward

Shaq thinks LeBron will be the best ever.

[3ba11]

Jordan got swept with high scoring vs Boston.


Jordan's rookie 8 seed lost by less to the goat Celtics than Lebron's 2-time defending champion super-team lost to the ancient Spurs in 2014

Let that sink in

[Stephonit]

The top 75 should be voted on by a select group of the most credible people that have seen both Wilt and Lebron play, like Jerry West, Bill Russell and Pat Riley.

Why do we have to say a player is top 75 just because a bunch of Joe the Plumbers with journalism degrees say so?

It's literally the dumbest shit in the history of the world

West was Wilt's teammate and Russell was Wilt's rival. They may have biases that would unduly skew an evaluation.

[3ba11]

West was Wilt's teammate and Russell was Wilt's rival. They may have biases that would unduly skew an evaluation.


the journalists have more biases and I trust older players' integrity especially with track records of Riley, Russell, West, etc

Ii.e. Stephen A had a bias for his local Philly beat

[RRR3]

the journalists have more biases and I trust older players' integrity especially with track records of Riley, Russell, West, etc

Ii.e. Stephen A had a bias for his local Philly beat
Why do you even care unless you’re upset about T-Mac or Dwight missing it? That would make sense but I don’t think you’re mad about that. So why be upset? The 75 was in literally no order.

[3ba11]

Why do you even care unless you’re upset about T-Mac or Dwight missing it? That would make sense but I don’t think you’re mad about that. So why be upset? The 75 was in literally no order.

It's a dumb idea to make a list like that as an official NBA-backed list that goes on the website as the historical record......................

........when it's done by a bunch of Joe the Plumbers with journalism degrees

[8Ball]

Jordan's rookie 8 seed lost by less to the goat Celtics than Lebron's 2-time defending champion super-team lost to the ancient Spurs in 2014

Let that sink in

Jordan ball = high scoring and first round knockout and 8 seeds.

Pippen ball = 55 games without jordan.

[RRR3]

It's a dumb idea to make a list like that as an official NBA-backed list that goes on the website as the historical record......................

........when it's done by a bunch of Joe the Plumbers with journalism degrees
This isn’t an “official top 75” there are no official top 75s. The NBA doesn’t determine anything no matter what they put out, it’s still just opinions.

[Gohan]

As long as ezail made it im cool