Log in

View Full Version : Rule-enforced spacing: You didn't need shooters to space the floor in the '80s & '90s



Im Still Ballin
02-21-2022, 11:37 AM
During the era of the Illegal Defense Rules Scheme, there were a number of provisions that restricted help defense. For instance, you weren't allowed to double a player off the ball from the week side. This meant a post-up player couldn't be fronted with an extra defender.

This made the post entry pass easy, and offense efficient from the pivot. By the time the ball was caught on the low block, it was already too late.

Here's the complete rule change that came prior to the 1981-1982 season:



1981-82
• Zone defense rules clarified with new rules for Illegal Defensive Alignments.
a. Weak side defenders may come in the pro lane (16’), but not in the college lane (12’) for more than three seconds.
b. Defender on post player is allowed in defensive three-second area (A post player is any player adjacent to paint area).
c. Player without ball may not be double-teamed from weak side.
d. Offensive player above foul line and inside circle must be played by defender inside dotted line.
e. If offensive player is above the top of the circle, defender must come to a position above foul line.
f. Defender on cutter must follow the cutter, switch, or double-team the ball.
• After the first illegal defense violation, the clock is reset to 24 seconds. All subsequent violations result in one free throw and possession of the ball. If any violation occurs during the last 24 seconds of each quarter or overtime period, the offended team receives one free throw.


The rule changes were introduced in order to open up the paint and increase scoring. The game had become slow, defensive, clogged, and jump-shooting heavy. These changes helped the game explode in the '80s, producing a more commercially viable product.



Illegal Defense Guidelines put in place to increase scoring and open up the paint Passage from Bill Simmons' (Globally known NBA analyst, well respected publically) book Quote: The new wave of coaches made defenses sophisticated enough by 1981 that the league created an “illegal defense” rule to open up the paint.

Here’s how referee Ed Rush explained it to SI:

“We were becoming a jump-shot league, so we went to the coaches and said, ‘You’ve screwed the game with all your great defenses. Now fix it.’ And they did. The new rule will open up the middle and give the great players room to move. People like Julius Erving and David Thompson who used to beat their own defensive man and then still have to pull up for a jump shot because they were being double-teamed, should have an extra four or five feet to move around in. And that’s all those guys need.”


https://streamable.com/u4egnw

https://i.imgflip.com/661az6.gif

https://i.imgflip.com/661cp0.gif

https://i.imgflip.com/661dcr.gif

Compare that to the modern game, which requires shooting to spread the defense.

https://i.imgflip.com/661dzw.gif

The two most important rules changes that shaped the modern game was the removal of Illegal Defense and the hand-checking ban.



2001-02
• Illegal defense guidelines will be eliminated in their entirety.
• A new defensive three-second rule will prohibit a defensive player from remaining in the lane for more than three consecutive seconds without closely guarding an offensive player.

2004-05
• New rules were introduced to curtail hand-checking, clarify blocking fouls and call defensive three seconds to open up the game.


Offenses adjusted by using the 3pt shot to spread the floor. Offenses also became more pick-and-roll oriented, taking advantage of the lack of physicality allowed on the perimeter.

Defenses have adapted to this by switching everything, stifling the flow of offense. Teams look for versatile defenders that can defend multiple positions.

High-quality offenses are able to take advantage of these switches. Finding the mismatch is one of the biggest aspects that separate the good teams from the bad.

FultzNationRISE
02-21-2022, 11:42 AM
Well, guess that about wraps it up.

Lebron > MJ.


Let’s go home yall :cheers:

Micku
02-21-2022, 12:37 PM
I think it's more philosophy in how the game was played more so than the actual rules at the time when we talk about spacing. Although both are important.

While thinking basketball did show the clips that enforce the spacing, it didn't show the clips that they should've obviously use and abuse the rules that enforce the spacing. But because that's just not how the game was played back then. Especially in the 80s. While you still had a stretch 4 from time to time, it usually wasn't stretch out to the 3pt line. Centers would usually stay in the paint while nowadays it's more often you'll get centers that try to pull them out further because of the threat of the 3pt line.

If you watch Bill Simmons and his rewatchables, he'll say how like the Jazz or some other team could've made their offense more efficient if they stretch their offense out to the 3pt line and let Karl Malone go to work.

Of course if you watch MJ vs Pistons at the time, they clog the paint and just double team him or shadow him. Forced him to where the help would be. Shaq was another guy that teams just sent the whole team after. Magic and Bird wasn't treated like that per say, but you still have teams that were more willing to fight for the offensive rebounds than get back. Mostly because nowadays, it's mostly stretched out.

By time the late 90s and early 00s, it was more of a one on one game. But the clips that was shown, even when putting players in isolation, that wasn't really how they played the defense. They should've played like that more tho. Guys like Barkley, Bird, Magic, MJ, Wilkins, Worthy could've abused it more. But you even have Bird talk about that when they set up the play of the island. He always thought that was bad basketball. But anyway, you can see the lack of spacing that the Bulls played against the Knicks or Pistons.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLv2F33snCE

With the Lakers, you can see for Shaq with the island play. They tried to give him room to work, but the 4, Grant, never backs out above the 3pt line.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kW-4VSxCxFA

But with those rules, it does promote one on one play in the post. Although in the 80s, it was more about the fastbreak and post play. The 90s and the early 00s, the game was more slowed and much more one on one.

They still needed shooting tho. Because some teams did try this and their players couldn't shoot when they happen to pass or when the refs would miss the illegal defense. Since taking a 3 pt shot wasn't really used back then, teams often didn't really space it that far out on every play.