View Full Version : Zach Edey MONSTER 30 points and 21 rebounds performance in March Madness first round
Im Still Ballin
03-23-2024, 03:33 AM
First player since 1995 to record 30+ points and 20+ rebounds in an NCAA tournament game.
Memphis should be all over this guy to replace Steven Adams. He plays just like prime Orlando Dwight Howard on offense. The way Purdue runs that four-out with Edey rolling and sealing in the paint is reminiscent of those Stan Van Gundy teams.
He's bigger, longer, and stronger than Dwight. Less athletic and mobile, but he can hit free throws and is more reliable in post-up isolation situations. And he has the tools to be an effective defender in drop coverage. His 3/4 court sprint and lane agility times are better than Brook Lopez, Steven Adams, DeMarcus Cousins, Rudy Gobert, etc.
This is the third thread I've made about him. It's crazy to me how so many are writing him off as an NBA prospect. I think he's going to be a valuable backup big at worst. And I think he could be a very good starter if he plays for a coach and team that values the type of player he is.
If the league sticks with how it has been officiating things recently? And he plays for a slower-paced half-court team with enough shooting and a commitment to him? 16-20 ppg, 10-15 rpg, 1-2 apg, 1.5-2.5 bpg on 60-65%+ FG and 70-75% FT. Extremely high free-throw rate; teams would have to get a big body just to check him.
Rudy Gobert is smaller and doesn't have a lick of Edey's post-up game and touch and he's been good for 14.5 ppg and 12.9 rpg since 2016-17. But obviously, he's out there for his defense. But if Steven Adams, Zubac, Nurkic, and co. are out there, Zach can be too. He may even be a Lopez-level drop big. Who knows...
He won't be the superstar that leads a team to a championship, but he can be a guy that turns around a franchise. Or at least kickstarts that process. Gets them actually competing for a playoff spot.
So many of these lottery-bound teams draft floaty guards and forwards who have pretty projections and potential and fit the "modern" archetypes. But do nothing but accumulate stats and have no impact on winning let alone culture.
If I was Washington, I'd be all over Edey. Trade down to get two picks and see if I can snag him in the middle of the first round. He can be that big rock inside that sets the tone physically. Does the dirty work setting screens, finishing plays in the paint, and crashing the boards. Gets them playing a respectable brand of basketball.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h42nyVPnfpA&ab_channel=MarchMadness
warriorfan
03-23-2024, 03:49 AM
I don’t know man. He’s really slow.
Im Still Ballin
03-23-2024, 03:55 AM
He moved better in the combine tests than many NBA centers despite outweighing all of them, from 20 pounds to as much as like 80. Now that doesn't guarantee mobility in-game but it at least gives him a great shot to be. He was 306.4 pounds when he did those tests. He's like 290 now I think.
Zach Edey 2023 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 11.37 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.45 seconds
Steven Adams 2014 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 11.85 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.40 seconds
Rudy Gobert 2014 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 12.85 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.57 seconds
Brook Lopez 2009 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 12.77 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.57 seconds
DeMarcus Cousins 2011 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 11.40 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.55 seconds
Hassan Whiteside 2011 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 11.83 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.54 seconds
Nikola Vucevic 2012 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 12.02 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.27 seconds
Bobby Portis 2016 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 11.78 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.56 seconds
Bam Adebayo 2018 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 11.94 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.24 seconds
Nicolas Claxton 2020 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 11.26 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.36 seconds
Xavier Tillman Sr 2021 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 11.80 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.49 seconds
To compare Edey to a true plodding Giant, check out Tacko Fall's numbers:
Tacko Fall 2020 NBA Combine:
Lane agility test: 13.01 seconds
3/4 court sprint test: 3.78 seconds
When it comes to mobility, Zach is much more like Adams, Lopez, and Gobert. And that was at 306 pounds a year ago. He dropped like 15 pounds and has been noticeably more mobile this season.
warriorfan
03-23-2024, 04:03 AM
He moved better in the combine tests than many NBA centers despite outweighing all of them, from 20 pounds to as much as like 80. Now that doesn't guarantee mobility in-game but it at least gives him a great shot to be. He was 306.4 pounds when he did those tests. He's like 290 now I think.
That’s pretty surprising tbh. He looks a lot slower but I will accept that since I haven’t watched a ton of games from him. He’s ****ing weirdly huge.
Carbine
03-23-2024, 08:40 AM
Combine stats mean nothing in the NBA
Westbrook has middling numbers at the combine but he was one of the most electric athletes EVER for the point guard position. That white guy from North Carolina years and years ago had better combine than Amare, one of the best athletes ever for the PF spot.
Just watch the dude play. He's slow.
He will be a good backup I think, but to make three threads about a future backup center is wild
Calm your tits
AlternativeAcc.
03-23-2024, 09:45 AM
It all depends if he can provide elite rim protection at the next level. Otherwise his goofy ass will need to learn Chinese.
SouBeachTalents
03-23-2024, 10:07 AM
Can we pump the brakes on hyping performances against a 16 seed :lol
Kblaze8855
03-23-2024, 10:20 AM
Boban would do 25/14 right now if you play him 30 minutes and ignore he’s slow and can’t switch or show and recover. They won’t. Thats about all the breakdown guys like this require these days. A tanking team might put them out there for the **** of it for 18 minutes, but serious teams intent on playing a style they will believe translates to the playoffs are never going to play this type of person these days.
Im Still Ballin
03-23-2024, 10:48 AM
Boban isn't the best comparison because Zach is much more mobile. He's got the size of Boban with athleticism more in the ballpark of Steven Adams, Ivica Zubac, Rudy Gobert, and Brook Lopez. He just doesn't look like it because he's so much bigger so it's odd and his strides are huge. He covers more ground in a single step; looks like he's moving slower but he's not.
Athletically, Marjanovic has more in common with Tacko Fall and there's a clear difference in how those two get down and move around the court compared to Zach.
tontoz
03-23-2024, 10:51 AM
That’s pretty surprising tbh. He looks a lot slower but I will accept that since I haven’t watched a ton of games from him. He’s ****ing weirdly huge.
I watched him one full game and that was enough for me to lose interest. He was so passive protecting the rim it was embarrasing.
Edey's low steal and foul rate are signs of how passive he is on D. He literally has the lowest steal rate of any draft prospect in either round.
Im Still Ballin
03-23-2024, 11:17 AM
Combine stats mean nothing in the NBA
Westbrook has middling numbers at the combine but he was one of the most electric athletes EVER for the point guard position. That white guy from North Carolina years and years ago had better combine than Amare, one of the best athletes ever for the PF spot.
Just watch the dude play. He's slow.
He will be a good backup I think, but to make three threads about a future backup center is wild
Calm your tits
Sure, there are exceptions; guys have bad combine showings for any number of reasons. But on average the more athletic players tend to perform better in those tests. If they didn't mean anything they wouldn't do them.
He's going to win NPOY and join Ralph Sampson and Bill Walton as the only guys to ever win the award more than once. He already won the Sporting News version, joining the likes of Michael Jordan, Oscar Robertson, Bill Walton, Jerry Lucas, Kareem Abdul Jabbar, Bill Bradley, and Luka Garza (LOL).
I think he's worth multiple threads.
I watched him one full game and that was enough for me to lose interest. He was so passive protecting the rim it was embarrasing.
Edey's low steal and foul rate are signs of how passive he is on D. He literally has the lowest steal rate of any draft prospect in either round.
Steal rate isn't something you'd be looking for in a 7'4" center who'll be playing drop coverage 100% of the time. He's just not that guy (obviously) and that's fine. Low foul rate can also be seen as a positive trait.
tontoz
03-23-2024, 11:22 AM
Sure, there are exceptions; guys have bad combine showings for any number of reasons. But on average the more athletic players tend to perform better in those tests. If they didn't mean anything they wouldn't do them.
He's going to win NPOY and join Ralph Sampson and Bill Walton as the only guys to ever win the award more than once. He already won the Sporting News version, joining the likes of Michael Jordan, Oscar Robertson, Bill Walton, Jerry Lucas, Kareem Abdul Jabbar, Bill Bradley, and Luka Garza (LOL).
I think he's worth multiple threads.
Steal rate isn't something you'd be looking for in a 7'4" center who'll be playing drop coverage 100% of the time. He's just not that guy (obviously) and that's fine. Low foul rate can also be seen as a positive trait.
How many games have you actually watched him play?
Kblaze8855
03-23-2024, 03:01 PM
Boban isn't the best comparison because Zach is much more mobile. He's got the size of Boban with athleticism more in the ballpark of Steven Adams, Ivica Zubac, Rudy Gobert, and Brook Lopez. He just doesn't look like it because he's so much bigger so it's odd and his strides are huge. He covers more ground in a single step; looks like he's moving slower but he's not.
Athletically, Marjanovic has more in common with Tacko Fall and there's a clear difference in how those two get down and move around the court compared to Zach.
this is one of those things where you’re just gonna have to wait and see Something you’ll realize was incredibly obvious in retrospect. I suppose it’s conceivable some coach comes out and decides that on his team it’s 1982 and he can play a brutally slow giant, who bogs down his offense even while being efficient, but very little is going on to suggest that’s about to happen.
do I hope it does, if only to see some variety? Sure. But I’m just shy of bet my life positive that it won’t. I can’t be 100% because you never know. Some Owner might want to be a smart ass and hire Dick Vitale to run his 70s Pistons offense as a means of tanking. But….i don’t see it.
I think you’re at the wishful thinking point of fan hood where the sobering reality of what they want the game to be has not set in. I’m not judging you. I thought Sean may was going to be something. I had a brief affair with Greg Monroe later. I was even keeping a folder on Jahlil Okafor for a minute. So I get it.
It just isn’t gonna happen.
he is a less skilled Boban who moves 6.6mph instead of 5.9. He’d kill small ball if a team wanted to abandon its offense to let him at the same time they threw out the defensive scheme. But unless some coach has a fantasy league with $1 million buy in where he manage to take dude in the last round as a dark horse, I just don’t think you’re gonna see much of him in a league with stretch bigs all over the place.
Imagine the pacers trying to slow down and wait for him to setup in the halfcourt.
There are too many teams he’d totally break just by being on the floor. Get a good look at him now. He’s probably going to Poland.
Im Still Ballin
04-01-2024, 10:42 AM
this is one of those things where you’re just gonna have to wait and see Something you’ll realize was incredibly obvious in retrospect. I suppose it’s conceivable some coach comes out and decides that on his team it’s 1982 and he can play a brutally slow giant, who bogs down his offense even while being efficient, but very little is going on to suggest that’s about to happen.
do I hope it does, if only to see some variety? Sure. But I’m just shy of bet my life positive that it won’t. I can’t be 100% because you never know. Some Owner might want to be a smart ass and hire Dick Vitale to run his 70s Pistons offense as a means of tanking. But….i don’t see it.
I think you’re at the wishful thinking point of fan hood where the sobering reality of what they want the game to be has not set in. I’m not judging you. I thought Sean may was going to be something. I had a brief affair with Greg Monroe later. I was even keeping a folder on Jahlil Okafor for a minute. So I get it.
It just isn’t gonna happen.
he is a less skilled Boban who moves 6.6mph instead of 5.9. He’d kill small ball if a team wanted to abandon its offense to let him at the same time they threw out the defensive scheme. But unless some coach has a fantasy league with $1 million buy in where he manage to take dude in the last round as a dark horse, I just don’t think you’re gonna see much of him in a league with stretch bigs all over the place.
Imagine the pacers trying to slow down and wait for him to setup in the halfcourt.
There are too many teams he’d totally break just by being on the floor. Get a good look at him now. He’s probably going to Poland.
You may be right. We'll see. If he succeeds at the NBA level, it'll be more as a roller which he's actually really good at. Scored at 1.54 ppp as the PnR roll man which was in the 94th percentile in NCAA D1. Was like 100th percentile last year.
Some examples:
https://i.ibb.co/MpBhxfS/8ks1tf.gif
https://i.ibb.co/hcS1Qqc/8ks32q.gif
https://i.ibb.co/XWfjnvT/8ks39s.gif
Also, Jahlil Okafor scored at 0.93 ppp from the post in his lone college season. Zach is up around 1.05 ppp and on much greater volume and facing automatic doubles and triples. More defensive attention than anyone in the college game in a long time. Boban and Okafor are more fluid and skilled but Zach's bully ball is just superior IMO. His foul-drawing rate is just crazy.
ArbitraryWater
04-01-2024, 10:58 AM
thats Zubac
Im Still Ballin
04-01-2024, 10:58 AM
Zach is undeniably more mobile than Brook Lopez, let alone a handful of starting and backup centers in the NBA right now. I can continue to reference combine numbers but I'll just post this GIF:
https://i.ibb.co/TY5VzjF/8l4cdh.gif
Can you nitpick aspects of his defense? Sure. But you can do that for a lot of centers in the NBA. And how Zach is playing for Purdue isn't 100% indicative of how he will on an NBA team. He's being asked to shoulder an incredibly large offensive burden and is more concerned with not getting fouled out or gassing out than contesting every possible shot.
Im Still Ballin
04-01-2024, 11:06 AM
Four rounds into the NCAA tournament, Zach is averaging 30.0 ppg, 16.3 rpg, 1.8 apg, 0.8 spg, 1.8 bpg, 2.0 topg, shooting 65.6% FG and 66.9% TS in 34 minutes per game.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9kQULUo4Ho0&pp=ygUJemFjaCBlZGV5
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bmwEc3CuBQQ&pp=ygURemFjaCBlZGV5IGdvbnphZ2E%3D
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVNJEIZltC8&pp=ygUTemFjaCBlZGV5IHRlbm5lc3NlZQ%3D%3D
ShawkFactory
04-01-2024, 11:11 AM
I watched him one full game and that was enough for me to lose interest. He was so passive protecting the rim it was embarrasing.
Edey's low steal and foul rate are signs of how passive he is on D. He literally has the lowest steal rate of any draft prospect in either round.
I think a lot of that can be attributed to how important it is that he stay on the floor as much as possible. Purdue relies so heavily on him that if he gets into foul trouble then they’re hurting.
I would imagine the coaches tell him not to take unnecessary chances on defense.
Hey Yo
04-01-2024, 11:19 AM
I think a lot of that can be attributed to how important it is that he stay on the floor as much as possible. Purdue relies so heavily on him that if he gets into foul trouble then they’re hurting.
I would imagine the coaches tell him not to take unnecessary chances on defense.
Totally agree with you. Saw many times where he couldve tried to block a shot or a reach in but chose not to because he was probably instructed not to take dumb, silly chance fouls.
First player since Oscar in 1960 to lead the nation in scoring while also getting to the final 4
tontoz
04-01-2024, 11:22 AM
I think a lot of that can be attributed to how important it is that he stay on the floor as much as possible. Purdue relies so heavily on him that if he gets into foul trouble then they’re hurting.
I would imagine the coaches tell him not to take unnecessary chances on defense.
The first half against Gonzaga his defense was so lame even the announcers were commenting on it. If he has to take more than a step to contest a shot it isn't happening. No thanks.
He only averages 2.5 fouls per 40 minutes so he could be a lot more aggressive without worrying about foul trouble.
ShawkFactory
04-01-2024, 02:30 PM
The first half against Gonzaga his defense was so lame even the announcers were commenting on it. If he has to take more than a step to contest a shot it isn't happening. No thanks.
He only averages 2.5 fouls per 40 minutes so he could be a lot more aggressive without worrying about foul trouble.
Again, whatever it is that they're doing is working. If they can still hold teams the way they do, keep him on the court, and win ball games then why ask him to play more aggressively on D?
tontoz
04-01-2024, 02:49 PM
Again, whatever it is that they're doing is working. If they can still hold teams the way they do, keep him on the court, and win ball games then why ask him to play more aggressively on D?
I don't think he actually can protect the rim effectively. You are giving him a pass on the assumption that the coaches are telling him not to contest shots near the rim which is pretty ridiculous. Protecting the rim is typically the top priority of every defense.
Winning in college doesn't mean crap to me. It doesn't seem to matter to the mock drafts either.
Carbine
04-01-2024, 02:55 PM
He's going to have a good career overseas.
Or a forgotten career in the NBA.
tontoz
04-01-2024, 06:18 PM
Edey's defense from the first half vs Gonzaga.
https://youtu.be/S4uI3HY1ZW4?feature=shared
https://youtu.be/alKkPc8MZgc?feature=shared
https://youtu.be/7l8vP3Yswgo?feature=shared
BurningHammer
04-02-2024, 01:26 AM
The Canadian Yao :rockon:
GimmeThat
04-02-2024, 05:25 AM
it's like watching Sidney Crosby not using his stick and just tries to muscle and score.
G0ATbe
04-02-2024, 10:15 AM
A skillset suitable for 90s ball. Not impressed.
BarberSchool
04-03-2024, 12:37 AM
I see :
85% Ivica Zubac
15% Yao Ming
I hear a lot of younger high school & early 20’s dudes, confidently proclaim he isn’t an NBA player, one of them to his credit said Zach would be a good euroleague player. That’s very true.
But I’m not convinced there isn’t a team who wants to incorporate a player like this onto their rotation.
He’s not some incompetent, uncoachable ret@rd.
And dude can manhandle many current NBA bigs, and set insanely great screens.
GimmeThat
04-03-2024, 02:16 AM
But I’m not convinced there isn’t a team who wants to incorporate a player like this onto their rotation.
He’s not some incompetent, uncoachable ret@rd.
And dude can manhandle many current NBA bigs, and set insanely great screens.
how about this, we'll let Zach be your personal physical training coach and guru. And every time you can't lose body fat or gain muscle, you'll sleep in a doggy cage and post those pictures on social media.
let me guess, you just pooped and piss your pants because Zach banging your loose a-hole to help you lose weight probably isn't gonna pass this test.
odd a guy who can't even work at McDonalds got a gimmick called BarberSchool
John8204
04-03-2024, 07:48 AM
He should develop into an Aaron Gordon type...I don't think he's going to win you a title on his own but he should have a roster spot in the next level.
Im Still Ballin
04-04-2024, 01:43 PM
https://twitter.com/DraftExpress/status/1774589213159170393
Zach Edey's 40 points will draw headlines, but his defensive impact was most notable from an NBA standpoint. Helped hold Tennessee to 7 made half-court 2s, stepping outside the paint with impressive mobility and showing excellent timing contesting shots with his 7'10 wingspan.
Zach ranked 13th on ESPN's latest mock draft from Givony and Woo.
Edey put forth one of the best performances in NCAA tournament history while leading Purdue to the Final Four behind the first 40-point, 15-rebound performance since Bo Kimble did so in 1990. This was a career-high scoring effort for Edey in the most important game of his college career.
Perhaps more important (and more notable from an NBA standpoint) was the way Edey shut down the paint, helping hold Tennessee to just seven made 2-pointers in the half court all game. He did an outstanding job of bothering shots with his length, coming up with several impressive possessions operating out of a drop while making the Volunteers think twice about even attempting shots with him in the vicinity.
He stepped outside the paint on several occasions showing impressive mobility in sliding his feet and 7-foot- 4 frame and continued to work hard deep into the second half while playing all but 33 seconds of the 40-minute contest. Clearly battling fatigue, Edey's defensive impact did drop off somewhat in the second half, which is concerning at the NBA level.
Beyond that, Edey's sheer skill-level catching and finishing out of the pick-and-roll, utilizing polished footwork and using both hands finishing inside the paint was impressive to see. He didn't receive anywhere near the same type of whistle as he usually does in Big Ten play, as Tennessee's big men were allowed to grab, hold, push and essentially foul him on every possession. His physicality and competitiveness playing through relentless contact was on display as he drew 22 free throws. He made some smart passes out of double-teams and got his teammates a number of easy baskets with his screening. In the paint, he dominated the offensive glass, as usual, being impossible to dislodge in front of the rim once he established position.
Already coming into this game a projected lottery pick, this was exactly the type of performance that could further propel him into the top 10 for one of the many teams that already has bought into the impact he'll surely make in the NBA. This effort also could go a long way in convincing the holdouts of just how impactful his tremendous size, length, strength, toughness, skill level and intensity can be at the next level. Edey has been viewed by most NBA teams ESPN has spoken with as a lock first-round pick for months now, but his standing has improved considerably with his late-blooming trajectory (he has only been playing basketball since age 15), competitiveness and the fact that he is still a young senior at age 21.
Edey will have another high-profile contest awaiting in Arizona against red-hot DJ Burns Jr. and NC State and, if both Purdue and UConn advance, a dream big-man matchup with Clingan in the championship game. -- Givony
tontoz
04-04-2024, 02:10 PM
ZZZZZ
How many of Edey's points were outside of 5 feet? I'm guessing zero. It will be hard to make a living just off 5 foot jump hooks in the NBA.
I've never seen any 7 footer just routinely let guys shoot inside without trying to contest. That is why he hasn't fouled out of a game in the last two years.
Tankathon moved him up from 33 to 32 in their latest mock. :lol
Im Still Ballin
04-04-2024, 02:27 PM
ZZZZZ
How many of Edey's points were outside of 5 feet? I'm guessing zero. It will be hard to make a living just off 5 foot jump hooks in the NBA.
I've never seen any 7 footer just routinely let guys shoot inside without trying to contest. That is why he hasn't fouled out of a game in the last two years.
Tankathon moved him up from 33 to 32 in their latest mock. :lol
14 of them came from 15 feet.
ShawkFactory
04-04-2024, 02:38 PM
I think we’ll know more if UConn and Purdue meet in the final. Donovan Clingan is the only guy in college who can physically match up, and he’s a legit NBA prospect.
If Edey is able to handle that matchup I think it’ll go along way towards his stock. If Clingan wins, which would not surprise me, then he won’t be drafted in the first round at all.
Im Still Ballin
04-04-2024, 02:42 PM
I think we’ll know more if UConn and Purdue meet in the final. Donovan Clingan is the only guy in college who can physically match up, and he’s a legit NBA prospect.
If Edey is able to handle that matchup I think it’ll go along way towards his stock. If Clingan wins, which would not surprise me, then he won’t be drafted in the first round at all.
It'll be interesting. Clingan is like 250 right now I think while Edey is around 295-300. Zach did well last season against Derrick Lively who is 7'1" and has a 7'7" wingspan.
tontoz
04-04-2024, 02:44 PM
14 of them came from 15 feet.
I didn't watch the game but I heard he got some cheap foul calls. His shot chart tells the story. I seriously doubt NBA teams will let him post up right in front of the rim over and over.
https://hosting.photobucket.com/images/g195/tontoz/IMG_20240404_144059.jpg
Why does Edey make tontoz meltdown so hard?
Im Still Ballin
04-04-2024, 02:47 PM
I didn't watch the game but I heard he got some cheap foul calls. His shot chart tells the story. I seriously doubt NBA teams will let him post up right in front of the rim over and over.
https://hosting.photobucket.com/images/g195/tontoz/IMG_20240404_144059.jpg
Looks kind of like Jokic's shot chart from two years ago:
https://i.ibb.co/X38z3T4/DEN-vs-IND-on-03-31-2022.png
tontoz
04-04-2024, 02:55 PM
Looks kind of like Jokic's shot chart from two years ago:
https://i.ibb.co/X38z3T4/DEN-vs-IND-on-03-31-2022.png
Jokic attempted almost 300 3s two years ago. Jokic has shot over 50% from 10-16 feet the last 3 years.
Im Still Ballin
04-04-2024, 03:05 PM
Jokic attempted almost 300 3s two years ago. Jokic has shot over 50% from 10-16 feet the last 3 years.
And? What's that got to do with anything?
tontoz
04-04-2024, 03:13 PM
And? What's that got to do with anything?
It means that Jokic has variety to his game. He is a good shooter from everywhere. He actually leads the fast break at times.
When Edey dribbles he looks down at the ball like a little kid. I don't see much skill. He just takes advantage of younger/ much smaller players. i don't see a lot that will translate to the NBA.
Im Still Ballin
04-04-2024, 03:38 PM
It means that Jokic has variety to his game. He is a good shooter from everywhere. He actually leads the fast break at times.
Cool. Variety and shooting ability are features, not requirements. Shaq's offensive game was far more one-note and at his best, it could be argued to be as good as anyone's ever. Points scored are points scored; it doesn't matter how they come about as long as they do. Doesn't matter if it's a fancy fade-away shot from 16 feet or a drop-step dunk.
When Edey dribbles he looks down at the ball like a little kid. I don't see much skill. He just takes advantage of younger/ much smaller players. i don't see a lot that will translate to the NBA.
You don't see much skill because you don't understand what it is.
tontoz
04-04-2024, 03:49 PM
Cool. Variety and shooting ability are features, not requirements. Shaq's offensive game was far more one-note and at his best, it could be argued to be as good as anyone's ever. Points scored are points scored; it doesn't matter how they come about as long as they do. Doesn't matter if it's a fancy fade-away shot from 16 feet or a drop-step dunk.
You don't see much skill because you don't understand what it is.
Having watched basketball since the 70s i think i understand it pretty well. Comparing him to Shaq is laughable. Shaq had legit athleticism as well as size. Shaq made HOF bigs look like kids.
Edey is playing against actual kids. Pretty big difference.
But the real dealbreaker for me is his interior defense. The following clips are just from the first half against Gonzaga.
tontoz
04-04-2024, 03:51 PM
https://youtu.be/alKkPc8MZgc?feature=shared
https://youtu.be/XU8uSoWTHUo?feature=shared
https://youtu.be/S4uI3HY1ZW4?feature=shared
tontoz
04-04-2024, 03:53 PM
https://youtu.be/J6FQHzoyU5w?feature=shared
https://youtu.be/7l8vP3Yswgo?feature=shared
https://youtu.be/FwnTXOb0HMk?feature=shared
Im Still Ballin
04-04-2024, 04:01 PM
If you knew what skill was you'd see that Edey has exceptional off-ball movement and positioning. He's legitimately one of the best ever at post-pinning and sealing in the paint.
tpols
04-04-2024, 04:04 PM
how about this, we'll let Zach be your personal physical training coach and guru. And every time you can't lose body fat or gain muscle, you'll sleep in a doggy cage and post those pictures on social media.
let me guess, you just pooped and piss your pants because Zach banging your loose a-hole to help you lose weight probably isn't gonna pass this test.
odd a guy who can't even work at McDonalds got a gimmick called BarberSchool
:roll:
tontoz
04-04-2024, 04:07 PM
If you knew what skill was you'd see that Edey has exceptional off-ball movement and positioning. He's legitimately one of the best ever at post-pinning and sealing in the paint.
:roll:
It isn't hard to pin a 19 yr old he outweighs by 50+ pounds. It isn't so easy in the NBA.
Embiid and Jokic can't routinely post up right in front of the rim because they have grown NBA players guarding them.
If Edey has such good mobility I would think he wouldn't be letting guys score right in front of him.
Im Still Ballin
04-04-2024, 04:09 PM
Zach outweighs the average NBA center by 50+ pounds. I don't think you realize how big he is.
tontoz
04-04-2024, 04:18 PM
Zach outweighs the average NBA center by 50+ pounds. I don't think you realize how big he is.
I understand just fine. Ever heard of Yao Ming? Pretty much the same size, probably bigger legs, who had to rely on skill because he couldn't just post guys up right in front of the rim.
Yao had a legit jumper. He could hit it straight on or fading away.
Most important he didn't just let guys score right in his face.
I've asked you this twice and both times you failed to answer. How many times have you actually watched edey play?
Kblaze8855
04-06-2024, 06:19 PM
Having watched about 5 possessions of defense all I can say is…some team he’s on in the league might give up 190. And he’s way slower than I thought though I’ll wait to offer a serious take. One thing is sure. This ain’t Yao Ming or Rik Smits. He’s not quick even for giant standards. I’ll watch the rest though. Maybe I’ll see something different. Maybe he’s not warmed up yet.
tontoz
04-06-2024, 07:01 PM
Having watched about 5 possessions of defense all I can say is…some team he’s on in the league might give up 190. And he’s way slower than I thought though I’ll wait to offer a serious take. One thing is sure. This ain’t Yao Ming or Rik Smits. He’s not quick even for giant standards. I’ll watch the rest though. Maybe I’ll see something different. Maybe he’s not warmed up yet.
I have heard people try to rationalize his defense by saying the coach doesn't want him to pick up cheap fouls contesting shots.
Contesting shots without fouling us a skill. If the coach doesn't trust a senior to do it then I am going to assume he sucks at it.
I can get over the fact that he can't guard the perimeter but being unable to guard the interior as well is a deal breaker for me.
Good jump hook but I haven't seen any other moves from him on offense.
I have heard people try to rationalize his defense by saying the coach doesn't want him to pick up cheap fouls contesting shots.
Contesting shots without fouling us a skill. If the coach doesn't trust a senior to do it then I am going to assume he sucks at it.
I can get over the fact that he can't guard the perimeter but being unable to guard the interior as well is a deal breaker for me.
Good jump hook but I haven't seen any other moves from him on offense.
Raging about a guy projected to go in the second round this hard is weird. Let ISB be a fan of him.
tontoz
04-06-2024, 07:08 PM
Raging about a guy projected to go in the second round this hard is weird. Let ISB be a fan of him.
Some wizards fans on another board are saying we should draft him with our second first round pick. I've been arguing with them about it for a few weeks :lol and they've got me worked up.
Pretty sure ISB hasn't actually watched edey play.
Some wizards fans on another board are saying we should draft him with our second first round pick. I've been arguing with them about it for a few weeks :lol and they've got me worked up.
Pretty sure ISB hasn't actually watched edey play.
Second round picks are a crapshoot and tbh until you stop letting Kuzma and Poole take shots away from Deni and Coulibaly you’re not going anywhere anyways.
tontoz
04-06-2024, 07:22 PM
Second round picks are a crapshoot and tbh until you stop letting Kuzma and Poole take shots away from Deni and Coulibaly you’re not going anywhere anyways.
Kuzma will hopefully get traded this summer. He almost got traded to Dallas at the deadline.
Poole has done better since he moved to pg. He played most of the season at the 2 and it was a disaster. It seemed he felt the need to shoot it every time he touched it
At pg he has the ball in his hands consistently and doesn't take as many bad shots, but still takes a few. He has been decent at setting up other guys. With that contract we are stuck with him.
Not worried about Deni he's been doing fine. Bilal is awful at finishing inside and very turnover prone. He needs to improve over the summer so he can handle higher usage.
Im Still Ballin
04-06-2024, 07:28 PM
You can disagree about Edey's prospects as a pro. I'm not sure why you have to be so hostile about it. I feel like you have a fetish for a certain aesthetic of player, and if one doesn't fit that mold, you display an irrational hatred for said individual. You act as if it's blasphemous when the general consensus is that he's a borderline lottery pick at this point. Lock for 1st round according to what Givony has heard from executives.
Here's a 3+ minute highlight reel of Edey on defense from Corey Tulaba (No Ceilings):
https://twitter.com/CoreyTulaba/status/1776285331077124682
Not the most popular place to own real estate, but I’m on Zach Edey island. Edey has unquestionably been dominant during his college career but questions remain about his place in the modern NBA. Most of those questions come via the defensive side of the ball, as evaluators ponder whether Edey has the movement skills to not get cooked every possession. I believe that Edey is going to figure it out. Edey is just straight up more mobile than you would think a 7’3” 300+ pound giant would be. Plus, he plays hard and is a smart basketball player. Pair that with a 7’10.5” wingspan and you have a guy who is going to figure it out. Yes, shifty guards with a bag will freeze him from time to time. Guys will make shots over his outstretched contests. Teams will try to find ways to pull him out to the perimeter. This is true of every big man prospect. A DPOY award may not be in the cards, but Edey has shown he’s capable of adjusting to it. Edey will also present as many mismatches on the other end of the floor. He is not done developing as a prospect himself. I’m buying Edey stock.
TLDR — The 2X National player of the Year is good actually.
Jonathon Givony (DraftExpress) has him as a lottery pick at the moment.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GKGDL2KXkAA4Pof?format=jpg&name=900x900
ISB what do you think Edey would put up in the 90s?
tontoz
04-06-2024, 07:33 PM
I've watched him play. I've seen Edey's defense and posted multiple clips of him just letting guys score inside without any contest at all.
Edey was the player of the year last season and was still seen as a second round pick.
Kuzma will hopefully get traded this summer. He almost got traded to Dallas at the deadline.
Poole has done better since he moved to pg. He played most of the season at the 2 and it was a disaster. It seemed he felt the need to shoot it every time he touched it
At pg he has the ball in his hands consistently and doesn't take as many bad shots, but still takes a few. He has been decent at setting up other guys. With that contract we are stuck with him.
Not worried about Deni he's been doing fine. Bilal is awful at finishing inside and very turnover prone. He needs to improve over the summer so he can handle higher usage.
Deni absolutely needs more shots than he’s getting. Poole has been better but still not what I was expecting. I’ve never been high on Poole as a player as I don’t like guys who play the way he does (same reason I get sick of Tyler Herro) but I expected like 25 PPG on 55 TS% or something. He’s nowhere near that.
Carbine
04-06-2024, 07:36 PM
This guy is not good at NBA style basketball. Boban is better and he hasn't really been in any significant bench role in his career let alone being a starter.
Im Still Ballin
04-06-2024, 07:36 PM
I don't know, man. I think you're letting emotions and personal bias cloud your judgment. I mean, one of your critiques of Edey was that he doesn't dribble the ball well. I was kind of confused when you said that because it was such a bizarre criticism to bring up about a 7'4", 300-pound center that plays in the paint.
tontoz
04-06-2024, 07:46 PM
I don't know, man. I think you're letting emotions and personal bias cloud your judgment. I mean, one of your critiques of Edey was that he doesn't dribble the ball well. I was kind of confused when you said that because it was such a bizarre criticism to bring up about a 7'4", 300-pound center that plays in the paint.
Edey's has 5 turnovers in this game already. Maybe it isn't so bizarre.
Im Still Ballin
04-06-2024, 08:05 PM
No, it's definitely bizarre considering Zach averages between 0.25-0.3 dribbles per field goal. I feel like you don't understand his actual game because it's primarily off-ball and requires minimal dribbling.
Like Shaq, Zach does what's known as "doing your work early." I don't know if you've ever actually played competitive basketball - you might not have heard this phrase before. It's when you work for good positioning in the post before you get the ball so that when you catch the ball, you're in a scoring area and can go straight up, without a dribble ideally.
Zach barely dribbles in college and he won't at the professional level. So, yeah: it's a strange issue to have with his game.
tontoz
04-06-2024, 08:19 PM
No, it's definitely bizarre considering Zach averages between 0.25-0.3 dribbles per field goal. I feel like you don't understand his actual game because it's primarily off-ball and requires minimal dribbling.
Like Shaq, Zach does what's known as "doing your work early." I don't know if you've ever actually played competitive basketball - you might not have heard this phrase before. It's when you work for good positioning in the post before you get the ball so that when you catch the ball, you're in a scoring area and can go straight up, without a dribble ideally.
Zach barely dribbles in college and he won't at the professional level. So, yeah: it's a strange issue to have with his game.
There is also something you may have heard of in post play, keep the ball high so the little guys can't get it. When Edey catches the ball in the post he brings it down where anyone can get their hands on it. I've never seen him keep the ball high, turn and shoot over smaller players.
Im Still Ballin
04-06-2024, 08:22 PM
There is also something you may have heard of in post play, keep the ball high so the little guys can't get it. When Edey catches the ball in the post he brings it down where anyone can get their hands on it. I've never seen him keep the ball high, turn and shoot over smaller players.
Then you haven't been paying attention to all my Kevin McHale posts on here and RealGM. I think I've mentioned keeping the ball high a dozen times over the last few years.
tontoz
04-06-2024, 08:24 PM
Then you haven't been paying attention to all my Kevin McHale posts on here and RealGM. I think I've mentioned keeping the ball high a dozen times over the last few years.
Then that just shows you haven't been watching edey play. if you actually watched him play you would know he brings it down every time unless it's an alley oop or a quick pass back out
GimmeThat
04-07-2024, 01:12 AM
the guy is 7'4" and he still needs to lean into his defender every play instead of keep his center of gravity straight up prior to attempting a basketball play
eliteballer
10-14-2024, 11:07 PM
Edey is looking good and athletic.
Im Still Ballin
10-15-2024, 01:52 AM
Edey is looking good and athletic.
Early days but he's shown real promise. Excited to see him with JJJ and Morant.
BarberSchool
10-18-2024, 10:56 PM
Yao Ming lower body stability, height, and touch.
Zubac overall lumbering strength and arm length.
how about this, we'll let Zach be your personal physical training coach and guru. And every time you can't lose body fat or gain muscle, you'll sleep in a doggy cage and post those pictures on social media.
let me guess, you just pooped and piss your pants because Zach banging your loose a-hole to help you lose weight probably isn't gonna pass this test.
odd a guy who can't even work at McDonalds got a gimmick called BarberSchool
Whose alt is this ? Supreme level f@ggotry, can’t be that many people here who could post this batty bwoy projection/admission.:roll:
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2025 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.