Where would you put LeBron James on the all time list? Honest answers, please.

Oscar, Isiah Thomas,Moses, and Dr J >> lebron

not top 15 ... Honest answer

[QUOTE=zizozain]Oscar, Isiah Thomas,Moses, and Dr J >> lebron

not top 15 ... Honest answer[/QUOTE]

Look I’m not trying to be a dick but you’re a bit of a moron if you honestly believe gun to your head sure that LeBron isn’t one of the 15 best basketball players of all time...

Like you’re either legitimately a borderline moron or your Kobe/Lakers bias has been so incredibly deep for so long that you can’t put together a rational thought...

You can’t find a single player, GM, coach, scout or media member that will honestly tell you in their heart of hearts that he isn’t top 15.

goat man! goat man!....goat man! goat man!

Lebron is Top 5-7. I think most ATG's rank him there.

Weigthed avreage after 30 votes in number 9.


GOAT: 4 votes for 4 points (each vote 1 point)
TOP 3: 2 votes for 4 points (each vote 2 points... top 3 --> avg: 2)
Top 5: 7 votes for 28 points (each vote 4 points... top 5 but not top 3 --> avg:4 etcetc.)
Top 10: 5 votes for 40 points
Top 15: 4 votes for 52 points
Not top 15: 8 votes for 144 points


Total points: 272
Total answers: 30

Average: 9,07

If he quits on this Laker team and ends up sitting out a good portion of the rest of this season with another "injury", he's outta my top 5.

Average after 35 votes is number 8.

Top 3 without a doubt with a solid case for goat.

On a side note i see people here say someone moves down their list. How is that logically possible? You move up through accomplishments and move down only by virtue of being surpassed, that's the way things always worked i thought.....You Can't un-accomplish something :oldlol:

[QUOTE=sdot_thadon]Top 3 without a doubt with a solid case for goat.

On a side note i see people here say someone moves down their list. How is that logically possible? You move up through accomplishments and move down only by virtue of being surpassed, that's the way things always worked i thought.....You Can't un-accomplish something :oldlol:[/QUOTE]


But it happens all the time.

Shaq is losing ground for example. And no player besides LeBron has a legit case over him in the last 5 years. Still...

[QUOTE=elementally morale]But it happens all the time.

Shaq is losing ground for example. And no player besides LeBron has a legit case over him in the last 5 years. Still...[/QUOTE]
Only with kobestans it happens

[QUOTE=Ben Simmons 25]Look I

I can

I have LeBron as the goat. This is coming from a big time Kobe fan. He is 16-6 vs my idol :(

[QUOTE=elementally morale]But it happens all the time.

Shaq is losing ground for example. And no player besides LeBron has a legit case over him in the last 5 years. Still...[/QUOTE]
i guess it's people being all over the place with these narratives and inconsistency. Russell actually moved up the argument past Wilt 20 years later without playing a single minute, it's ridiculous.

[QUOTE=elementally morale]Average after 35 votes is number 8.[/QUOTE]


you have to factor in the fact that simons alts voted at least 10+ times


:lol