Quentin Tarantino's Inglourious Basterds is better than Pulp Fiction

I saw this last night and I loved it. Probably my favorite QT movie and Waltz just may have replaced Bardem as my favorite villain.

[QUOTE=Thugnificent]That does not mean that the movies were bad...
Revolver and RocknRolla weren't simply as hyped as Death Proof.
Ritchie is repetitive, that's true, but all in all I pick him, because he is not as boring as Tarantino.

Plus I'm a hater.:hammertime:

Yes, I admit he borrowed.
Didn't Tarantino build his whole style on borrowing?
Don't critics defend his movies simply by saying "oh, he borrows from..." not that it has anything to do with the value of the picture?[/QUOTE]
It doesn't matter. Tarantino steals EVERYTHING in his movies from somewhere else. EVERYTHING. He's still better than Tarantino and makes more interesting and watchable movies.

LMAO at all this Guy Ritchie crap. Dudes movies suck. You all can keep that British bullchit. He is nowhere even close to QT's level.

[QUOTE=Norcaliblunt]LMAO at all this Guy Ritchie crap. Dudes movies suck. You all can keep that British bullchit. He is nowhere even close to QT's level.[/QUOTE]
Tarantino does 3 things-mastu[B]rbat[/B]ory dialogue, ripoff sergio leonne and rip off bad C-movies.

Kill Bill, the whole thing was just a Sergio Leonne rippoff, and a bad one at that.

[QUOTE=sergiorodriguez]

Kill Bill, the whole thing was just a Sergio Leonne rippoff, and a bad one at that.[/QUOTE]

I always hear great things about Kill Bill, but I was never able to get into it.

I will watch movie tonight.

Very post modern. Excellent indeed.

sickkkkkkkkkkkk movie, brad pitt played that perfect american roll :oldlol: the bar scene when he was talking out of screen was funny

Anyone who's seen me on here knows I've been a huge Tarantino fan and that was honestly my favorite Tarantino movie since Pulp Fiction. I love Pulp Fiction and I think Inglourious Basterds is right up there. This was absolutely amazing.

[QUOTE=DonDadda59]hmmmm, I like both Tarantino and Ritchie. Lock, Stock, and two smoking barrels was great too. Don't think either director is overrated, especially not the work in Pulp Fiction.[/QUOTE]Ditto.

PF was absolutely great! Very unique movie when it came out and done very well. QT started something new those days with reservoir dogs and PF and it wasn't just new in a sense of something different and so, so. It was a genius at work to start a new era of movies. Don't forget that people. Snatch wouldn't even be alive without Quentin and his stuff is more talented and interesting IMO.

i just saw this film and have to say that it sucks. It was just an ego trip for the director. There are many self referential lines in the film where characters say stuff like "I'm working on my masterpiece" and it ends with the lines "this is my masterpiece". What an egotistical bullshi[U]t[/U] movie. This clunker is really getting good reviews?

Quentin Tarantino owes EVERYTHING to Sergio Leone. I don't get why Tarantino gets so much credit for being original when EVERYTHING HE DOES rips off Sergio Leone.

Don't go see this movie. You will be disappointed. It is like watching Quentin Tarantino mastu[U]r[/U]bating

[IMG]http://4gifs.com/gallery/d/124586-1/Bro_Inc.jpg[/IMG]

that's funny...that's exactly how i'd sum up your posting career...dull, overlong, poorly edited egotrip.

At least QT made some money.

he takes from a lot of people. I think you went into it a little standoffish or something because it's a really rich and funny script and I thought the movie was great.

if it wasn't for your love of clint, i would have you killed

Seriously? You had to make another thread for this?

[QUOTE=Kebab Stall]Seriously? You had to make another thread for this?[/QUOTE]
Yeh, it was really that terrible. There is a boring scene in a restaurant where nothing happens that lasts 25 minutes and then a boring scene in a bar that lasts 40 minutes where nothing happens until the end. Someone needs to put this tarantino guy on a leash, it might have actually been an ok movie if it was edited better. And didn't rip off Sergio Leone so blatantly and uncreatively.

But, I plan on watching the movie tomorrow with my brother. :(

[QUOTE=JustinJDW]But, I plan on watching the movie tomorrow with my brother. :([/QUOTE]

your brother is dead justin.

[QUOTE=Lamar Doom]your brother is dead justin.[/QUOTE][IMG]http://ssreporters.files.wordpress.com/2007/12/monkey_shocked2.jpg[/IMG]

hahaha, nice choice

[IMG]http://www.angelfire.com/ca/X8/CrocHand.jpg[/IMG]

[IMG]http://i32.tinypic.com/lgxhi.jpg[/IMG]

pimp

[QUOTE=Lamar Doom][IMG]http://www.angelfire.com/ca/X8/CrocHand.jpg[/IMG][/QUOTE][B][SIZE="7"]NOOOO!!!!!111[/SIZE][/B]


[IMG]http://www.chalonitkafestivalandrodeo.com/images/alligator~43_7nhb.jpg[/IMG]


[B][SIZE="7"]GIVE IT BACK!!!11[/SIZE][/B]

Ricky Rubio = Quentin Tarantino [b]>>[/b] Sergio Rodriguez = Guy Ritchie

(I really do like Guy Ritchie films though)

but this is how the OP works… goes against the grain for the sake of being "different" and "against the institution"

Rage on dude.

[QUOTE=pete's montreux][IMG]http://i32.tinypic.com/lgxhi.jpg[/IMG]

pimp[/QUOTE]
:bowdown: :bowdown: :bowdown:

[QUOTE=sergiorodriguez]Yeh, it was really that terrible. There is a boring scene in a restaurant where nothing happens that lasts 25 minutes and then a boring scene in a bar that lasts 40 minutes where nothing happens until the end. Someone needs to put this tarantino guy on a leash, it might have actually been an ok movie if it was edited better. And didn't rip off Sergio Leone so blatantly and uncreatively.[/QUOTE]

How did you not like the bar scene! That was my favorite.

[QUOTE=TMAC-RAPTORS]How did you not like the bar scene! That was my favorite.[/QUOTE]
cuz it was like 35 minutes in one scene where nothing happened in the plot until the very end

[QUOTE=Sonic R]Ricky Rubio = Quentin Tarantino [b]>>[/b] Sergio Rodriguez = Guy Ritchie

(I really do like Guy Ritchie films though)

but this is how the OP works… goes against the grain for the sake of being "different" and "against the institution"

Rage on dude.[/QUOTE]
wtf idiots. It's people who like Quentin Tarantino and hail him as a cinematic genius who are the ones going against the grain for the sake of being different. Isn't Tarantino the 'rebel film maker' who goes against the grain and does whatver the hell he wants in his films? This thing got panned in Cannes and is getting like 70% reviews now. I'm not going against the grain, people hailing this clunky movie as a masterpiece are.

Seriously Sonic R, I understand why you think Quentin Tarantino is so amazing. I used to think he was amazing when I saw pulp fiction and resevoir dogs when I was 13. But then I saw other movies. And realized that all Tarantino did was blatantly rip off other better movies and directors. Seriously. Educate yourself. Go watch Once Upon a Time in America and the Good the Bad and the Ugly, then come back and tell me what you think about Tarantino.

[QUOTE=pete's montreux][IMG]http://i32.tinypic.com/lgxhi.jpg[/IMG]

pimp[/QUOTE]

:roll:

just saw this movie. pretty fkcing interesting.

this has probably been mentioned, but the acting was very impressive, and the way that screen tarantino blended languages was really cool.

i'm sure that french and german audiences will get to see a different movie than i saw...and vice versa.

[QUOTE=sergiorodriguez]i just saw this film and have to say that it sucks. It was just an ego trip for the director. There are many self referential lines in the film where characters say stuff like "I'm working on my masterpiece" and it ends with the lines "this is my masterpiece". What an egotistical bullshi[U]t[/U] movie. This clunker is really getting good reviews?

Quentin Tarantino owes EVERYTHING to Sergio Leone. I don't get why Tarantino gets so much credit for being original when EVERYTHING HE DOES rips off Sergio Leone.

Don't go see this movie. You will be disappointed. It is like watching Quentin Tarantino mastu[U]r[/U]bating[/QUOTE]

I for one will not say that he is original. I just like the movies he makes. Mostly Jackie Brown. I only like PF some. Death Proof is solid and dogs is awesome... I own the Kill Bill movies, but I haven't had the urge to watch them.

As for as Leone and TBTBTU goes... Isn't that movie a rip off of another movie.... Oh what's it's name? I think it starts with a Y...

It was entertaining despite not being an overtly violent film as advertised. Ironically the Inglourious Basterds of the films title are really totally unnecessary to the main plot of the film. The film builds rich characters of the Nazi's and then makes the Americans look like one-dimensional inhuman killing machines.

It's not better then Pulp Fiction, I'd rank Tarantino's main releases as:

1. Reservoir Dogs
2. Pulp Fiction
3. Inglourious Basterds
4. Jackie Brown
5. Kill Bill Volume 2
6. Kill Bill Volume 1
7. Deathproof

For the Guy Ritchie lovers out there the 3 Guy Ritchie films I've seen would rank in here as follows:


1. Reservoir Dogs
2. Pulp Fiction
3. Snatch
4. Inglourious Basterds
5. Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels
6. Jackie Brown
7. Kill Bill Volume 2
8. Rock'n'Rolla
9. Kill Bill Volume 1
10. Deathproof

[QUOTE=sergiorodriguez]Tarantino does 3 things-mastu[B]rbat[/B]ory dialogue, ripoff sergio leonne and rip off bad C-movies.

Kill Bill, the whole thing was just a Sergio Leonne rippoff, and a bad one at that.[/QUOTE]

And Richie makes movies that flop. Outside of maybe 10 people who gives a crap about Volver and Rocknrolla?

[QUOTE=Hotlantadude81]

As for as Leone and TBTBTU goes... Isn't that movie a rip off of another movie.... Oh what's it's name? I think it starts with a Y...[/QUOTE]

Every director borrows, Leone ripped off Kurusawa obviously.

[QUOTE=sergiorodriguez]wtf idiots. It's people who like Quentin Tarantino and hail him as a cinematic genius who are the ones going against the grain for the sake of being different. Isn't Tarantino the 'rebel film maker' who goes against the grain and does whatver the hell he wants in his films? This thing got panned in Cannes and is getting like 70% reviews now. I'm not going against the grain, people hailing this clunky movie as a masterpiece are.

Seriously Sonic R, I understand why you think Quentin Tarantino is so amazing. I used to think he was amazing when I saw pulp fiction and resevoir dogs when I was 13. But then I saw other movies. And realized that all Tarantino did was blatantly rip off other better movies and directors. Seriously. Educate yourself. Go watch Once Upon a Time in America and the Good the Bad and the Ugly, then come back and tell me what you think about Tarantino.[/QUOTE]

Sorry dude, I'm not a movie snob… I barley watch movies and I regret that I won't be able to get in that deep if I were to watch something else and get back to ya on my thoughts on what ever or who ever… You wanna argue about video games, then I'm your man, but you come onto this forum and peddle your view as if you're some savior of film and that everyone who enjoys Tarantino's work are lemmings, and proceed to belittle the membership of ISH because they happen to enjoy something that you feel is not up to your highbrow standards.

I may be a game snob, but I don't go on trashing all the people who throw their money away every year on stuff like Madden… it is what it is…

I just saw the movie with my brother, and it was pretty ****ing awesome! Especially the ending! The **** went down! :rockon:

Great movie. Loved it...

[QUOTE=Hotlantadude81]I for one will not say that he is original. I just like the movies he makes. Mostly Jackie Brown. I only like PF some. Death Proof is solid and dogs is awesome... I own the Kill Bill movies, but I haven't had the urge to watch them.

[B]As for as Leone and TBTBTU goes... Isn't that movie a rip off of another movie.... Oh what's it's name? I think it starts with a Y...[/B][/QUOTE]

WRONG MORON!!!

The Good the Bad and the Ugly is completely original.

A Fistful of Dollars is the film you are talking about-it is a shot for shot remake of the Kurosawa movie Yojimbo set in the old west. And Leone did not pretend that he wrote that movie. Kurosawa and the Yojimbo screenplay are credited in the movie.

[QUOTE=embersyc]Every director borrows, Leone ripped off Kurusawa obviously.[/QUOTE]
It's not a ripoff IF YOU GIVE KUROSAWA CREDIT FOR WRITING THE SCREENPLAY.

And Leone only did that for one movie.
Tarantino did it for every movie he ever wrote.

[QUOTE=Sonic R]Sorry dude, I'm not a movie snob… I barley watch movies and I regret that I won't be able to get in that deep if I were to watch something else and get back to ya on my thoughts on what ever or who ever… You wanna argue about video games, then I'm your man, but you come onto this forum and peddle your view as if you're some savior of film and that everyone who enjoys Tarantino's work are lemmings, and proceed to belittle the membership of ISH because they happen to enjoy something that you feel is not up to your highbrow standards.

I may be a game snob, but I don't go on trashing all the people who throw their money away every year on stuff like Madden… it is what it is…[/QUOTE]
im not a movie snob either! Im the opposite, I'm saying that people who declare this guy a genius are the highbrow snobs, who just do everything critics tell them, and judge a movie more for intellectual themes rather than it just being a good movie that's fun to watch