Is Kobe better than Prime Shaq?

[QUOTE=dubeta]Considering Gasol was the better overall player (Higher Player Efficiency Rating and Win Shares, while being more efficient, getting more rebounds and blocks) it should be that way.[/QUOTE]

Gasol is a big man, of course he gonna get more boards and blocks playing under the basket and his efficiency is going to be higher

but who was the leader of that team? Who set Pau up for those easy baskets? who ran the triangle? who shot 46% through 3 Playoff runs with mostly taking contested mid-range/3pt shots?

I can put up at least 10 games Kobe has from those 3 runs that shit on anything that Pau did.

I guess 08-10 Pau is better than 96-98 Jordan as well?

[QUOTE=dubeta]LOL @ Kobe trolls

Oh dey mad :roll:



PLease tell me how valuable Kobe's 15ppg on 41% shooting was crucial for Shaq's 2000 championship?? :oldlol:
.[/QUOTE]

It was 36%fg.

Is anyone actually trying to argue this? :biggums:

[img]http://www.reactiongifs.com/r/bp.gif[/img]

I don't agree but MarkMadsen making a strong case for who's better All-time.

Single handedly soloing this thread.

[QUOTE=pauk][img]http://www.reactiongifs.com/r/bp.gif[/img][/QUOTE]

De -la
sun de-laaa

[QUOTE=HOoopCityJones]I don't agree but MarkMadsen making a strong case for who's better All-time.

Single handedly soloing this thread.[/QUOTE]

Tbf you and Mark Madsen are the same guy.

[QUOTE=Mr Feeny]Tbf you and Mark Madsen are the same guy.[/QUOTE]

Just like you're the same guy as every Kobe hater on this board. All of you post exactly the same.

I'm positive you're Arbitrary's alt though.

[QUOTE=HOoopCityJones]Just like you're the same guy as every Kobe hater on this board. All of you post exactly the same.

I'm positive you're Arbitrary's alt though.[/QUOTE]

A.W. and I have fallen out plenty of times. Anyone on this board knows we're not the same guy. We do think you know nothing about basketball though, as does the majority of this board. Youre always welcome to run an I.P. check.

Just because multiple people on this board think you're an idiot, it doesn't make them all alts:cheers:

[QUOTE=HOoopCityJones]I don't agree but MarkMadsen making a strong case for who's better All-time.

Single handedly soloing this thread.[/QUOTE]

The dude thinks value is measured by FGA. Wouldn't know a "strong case" if it hit him in the mouth.

Prime Shaq > Kobe, this is worse than the thread trying to create a debate about Duncan's deserved position above Kobe.

[QUOTE=24-Inch_Chrome]The dude thinks value is measured by FGA. Wouldn't know a "strong case" if it hit him in the mouth.

Prime Shaq > Kobe, this is worse than the thread trying to create a debate about Duncan's deserved position above Kobe.[/QUOTE]

One of the Lerbon stans bumped this though, I swear you guys act like Kobe fans just come out the woodwork to gloat about him or something . Some insecure prick always wants to take a shot or bring up so old extreme tired debate when they feel Lebron is having a rough day at ISH.

*Looks a dubeta*

[QUOTE=HOoopCityJones]One of the Lerbon stans bumped this though, I swear you guys act like Kobe fans just come out the woodwork to gloat about him or something . Some insecure prick always wants to take a shot or bring up so old extreme tired debate when they feel Lebron is having a rough day at ISH.

*Looks a dubeta*[/QUOTE]

Oh shit, didn't notice that the thread started in 2010. :oldlol:

I'll be honest though, I look at the LeBron family and Kobe stans with equal amounts of disdain. It's true that dubeta is pretty bad but there are some equally shitty posters on the other side.

[QUOTE=24-Inch_Chrome]Oh shit, didn't notice that the thread started in 2010. :oldlol:

I'll be honest though, I look at the LeBron family and Kobe stans with equal amounts of disdain. It's true that dubeta is pretty bad but there are some equally shitty posters on the other side.[/QUOTE]

Well, MarkMadsen ain't one of them, he actually makes pretty legit arguments. It may not resonate with everyone ,but he's not in the strictly red for a reason . :applause:

[QUOTE=HOoopCityJones]Well, MarkMadsen ain't one of them, he actually makes pretty legit arguments. It may not resonate with everyone , but he's not in the strictly red for a reason. :applause:[/QUOTE]

We can agree to disagree on that one. :cheers:

Not surprised that it was dubeta who bumped it though. :lol

Kobe had greater career with the better prime but not close to peak Shaq.