ISH's #7 Player of Alltime

Oscar Robertson

[QUOTE=Inception28]As much as I love Shaq my vote goes to Tim Duncan.[/QUOTE]
Same here, Duncan.

Oscar Robertson

shaq

[B]This was hard for me but[B] Timmy.[/B]


[SIZE="4"]Shaq has the better peak but he's half the player Duncan is on defense.
Plus, Duncan is the GOAT at his position.[/SIZE]
[/B]
[IMG]http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue/files/2008/04/l83729-2.jpg[/IMG]

If you want great team chemistry, an ultimate team player, an unselfish leader, and a much better defender along with superior intangible assets, you gotta go with Tim Duncan over Shaq.

Statistically, Shaq is probably better, as he was a more dominant scorer and only a slightly worse rebounder. Shaq has never shot below 50% in his career, while Tim has a few times. Shaq's prime years are also more impressive.

IMO, Tim Duncan achieved more with a worse supporting cast. He never had Kobe Bryant or Dwyane Wade on his team.

This is a hard choice, but I'm voting for Tim Duncan.

[QUOTE=OmniStrife][B]This was hard for me but[B] Timmy.[/B]


[SIZE="4"]Shaq has the better peak but he's half the player Duncan is on defense.
Plus, Duncan is the GOAT at his position.[/SIZE]
[/B]
[IMG]http://tucsoncitizen.com/morgue/files/2008/04/l83729-2.jpg[/IMG][/QUOTE]

what about hakeem? nothing he can't do better than duncan.

Update for the vote so far


17 - Shaquille O'Neal
10 - Tim Duncan
6 - Hakeem Olajuwon
3 - Oscar Robertson



[QUOTE=Fazotronic]what about hakeem? nothing he can't do better than duncan.[/QUOTE]
Duncan was a better and a more willing passer than Hakeem. Duncan also made his teammates better than both Hakeem and Shaq did. That being said, I don't think Duncan had a better peak than Hakeem did. If we were just talking about peaks, Hakeem would be top 3 or 5 on my list and he would have a case for #1.

shaq

[QUOTE=Inception28]Update for the vote so far


17 - Shaquille O'Neal
10 - Tim Duncan
6 - Hakeem Olajuwon
3 - Oscar Robertson




Duncan was a better and a more willing passer than Hakeem. Duncan also made his teammates better than both Hakeem and Shaq did. That being said, I don't think Duncan had a better peak than Hakeem did. If we were just talking about peaks, Hakeem would be top 3 or 5 on my list and he would have a case for #1.[/QUOTE]

Where did you get the 17th vote for Shaq from?
and the 6th vote for Hakeem?

My count is this
[QUOTE=Deuce Bigalow]16 - Shaquille O'Neal
10 - Tim Duncan
5 - Hakeem Olajuwon
3 - Oscar Robertson

Total - 34 votes[/QUOTE]

[IMG]http://i40.tinypic.com/25q8wnp.png[/IMG]

One of these two.


7-8 respectively

[QUOTE=Deuce Bigalow]Where did you get the 17th vote for Shaq from?

My count is this[/QUOTE]
Shaq is pretty much going to win either way. How much longer do we have to vote?

[QUOTE=Inception28]Shaq is pretty much going to win either way. How much longer do we have to vote?[/QUOTE]

12 ET, that is for all of them except if the voting isn't even close

Tim Duncan

[QUOTE=Deuce Bigalow]12 ET, that is for all of them except if the voting isn't even close[/QUOTE]

deuce

this one's a rap

let's get into #8 while we chillin
on a sunday watchin football