The Top 100 Greatest NBA Players Of All Time According To ISH

[QUOTE=ALlArOuNDPIaya]And how do we decide who's "smart"[/QUOTE]

People who have contributed positively the most or L.Kizzle can decide since this was his idea....he can choose who should do it again...its actually all up to him

Ben Wallace, Paul Pierce, Ray Allen should not be on the list IMO...maybe the only one i can see a case for is Allen.

[QUOTE=lurch67]My beef is Barkley at 21 while Rodman is at 47. Yeah, Barkley put up more points, but Rodman was a part of 2 dynasties and had more boards. Basketball is more than just offense.[/QUOTE]




THANK YOU!!!!!:bowdown:

[QUOTE=Dbrog]Ben Wallace, Paul Pierce, Ray Allen should not be on the list IMO...maybe the only one i can see a case for is Allen.[/QUOTE]




just because he's like 2nd on the alltime 3's list... i do agree... is he second now?

[QUOTE=catzhernandez]just because he's like 2nd on the alltime 3's list... i do agree... is he second now?[/QUOTE]

Yuppers. 2nd place with 1,920 3's made. :)

also...
- Holds NBA record for most seasons leading the league in three-point field goals made with 3 (2001-02 with 229, 2002-03 with 201, 2005-06 with 269)
- Shares NBA record for most three-point field goals made in one half with 8 (April 14, 2002 vs. the Charlotte Hornets).

[QUOTE=Korki Buchek]This may be true, but I'm equally sure that if Barkley was on the 95-96 Bulls roster, they wouldn't have won 72 games.[/QUOTE]

True, probably 75.

[QUOTE=Dbrog][B]Ben Wallace,[/B] Paul Pierce, Ray Allen should not be on the list IMO...maybe the only one i can see a case for is Allen.[/QUOTE]

4 defensive player of the year awards dont count for anything?

Using the same 100 players voted in, I came up my own 100 greatest players list:

What do y'all think? I did this in about 15 minutes just of of memory. I'll probably go over it later.



[B][U]L.Kizzle

[QUOTE=L.Kizzle]Using the same 100 players voted in, I came up my own 100 greatest players list:

What do y'all think? I did this in about 15 minutes just of of memory. I'll probably go over it later.



[B][U]L.Kizzle

So now T-mac is 33 spots higher than VC?

right.....

[QUOTE=i seen hippos]So now T-mac is 33 spots higher than VC?

[B]right.....[/B][/QUOTE]
excellent dr. evil impression, hippos.

[QUOTE=L.Kizzle]8. Oscar Robertson[/QUOTE]
Didn't you originally begin voting for Robertson around #3? I think #8 is more reasonable--putting him below Russell and Kareem.

You still have Julius Erving ahead of Moses Malone. I'd like to hear a good argument for that one.

It seems you've rethought Dave DeBusschere, as well.

You lowered the rankings of the few 40s/50s players I managed to rally for, so I obviously don't approve of that.

Those are a few things that jump out to me.

[QUOTE=L.Kizzle]Using the same 100 players voted in, I came up my own 100 greatest players list:

What do y'all think? I did this in about 15 minutes just of of memory. I'll probably go over it later.



[B][U]L.Kizzle

[QUOTE=D-Fence]Didn't you originally begin voting for Robertson around #3? I think #8 is more reasonable--putting him below Russell and Kareem.

You still have Julius Erving ahead of Moses Malone. I'd like to hear a good argument for that one.

It seems you've rethought Dave DeBusschere, as well.

You lowered the rankings of the few 40s/50s players I managed to rally for, so I obviously don't approve of that.

Those are a few things that jump out to me.[/QUOTE]



[QUOTE=Glove_20]Even worse than ISH's list....[/QUOTE]
D-Fence and Glove_20, I did this in about 10-15 minutes, I didn't really go back and look over the list yet.