Message Board Basketball Forum - InsideHoops

Message Board Basketball Forum - InsideHoops (
-   Fantasy Basketball Forum (
-   -   Dirk for Bosh? Need some help here (

Orealius 11-09-2008 07:40 PM

Dirk for Bosh? Need some help here
I'm being offered Bosh for Dirk. Seems really close to me but i'm not sure what to do. First of all, who would you rather have? Secondly, should I ask for more in a counter to get an upgrade somewhere else? Let's see some opinions/trade suggestions.

9 cats 12 teams H2H league. Notice the roster positions.

His team

PG Jason Kidd (Dal - PG)
SG Ray Allen (Bos - SG)
G Deron Williams (Uta - PG) INJ
SF Jamario Moon (Tor - SF)
PF Rasheed Wallace (Det - PF,C)
F Chris Bosh (Tor - PF,C)
C Andris Biedrins (GS - C)
Util Andrew Bynum (LAL - C)

BN Raja Bell (Pho - SG)
BN Leandro Barbosa (Pho - PG,SG)
BN Charlie Villanueva (Mil - SF,PF)
BN Tyrus Thomas (Chi - SF,PF)
BN Marquis Daniels (Ind - SG,SF)

My team

PG Steve Nash (Pho - PG)
SG Michael Redd (Mil - SG,SF) INJ
G Rajon Rondo (Bos - PG)
SF Gerald Wallace (Cha - SF,PF)
PF Dirk Nowitzki (Dal - PF)
F LaMarcus Aldridge (Por - PF,C)
C Marcus Camby (LAC - PF,C)
Util Mehmet Okur (Uta - PF,C)

BN Spencer Hawes (Sac - C)
BN Rudy Fernandez (Por - PG,SG)
BN Shaquille O'Neal (Pho - C)
BN Marvin Williams (Atl - SF,PF)
BN Francisco Garcia (Sac - SG,SF) INJ

jc23 11-09-2008 09:11 PM

Re: Dirk for Bosh? Need some help here
Bosh is a freak. I'd do it and I don't even know your leagues point system.

kobebryant242424 11-09-2008 11:33 PM

Re: Dirk for Bosh? Need some help here
pull the trigger, Bosh provides more stablility

RapsFan 11-10-2008 11:18 AM

Re: Dirk for Bosh? Need some help here
How does Bosh provide more stability??? :confusedshrug: He missed 15 games a season.

I would rather have Dirk personally. Outside of one bad game, Dirk is getting close to 30 a night, and will give you great %s. Bosh will also, and more bds, but Dirk's bds should end up at 9ish per game. Bosh doesn't steal or blk at all. Dirk at least gives you the 3's.

It's close, but Bosh is the bigger injury risk. Dallas is not in a groove right now, and Dirk is still putting up big numbers.

benJAMin 11-10-2008 12:18 PM

Re: Dirk for Bosh? Need some help here
I'd take the Dirk side myself. They both offer elite, similar numbers in most cats, but Dirk's volume of free throws and his threes make him more valuable IMO.

If you're desperate for a C, Bosh is fine, but I think you're ok with the bigs you have right now. I'd stay put with Dirk.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:45 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. Terms of Use/Service | Privacy Policy