Collison & Fernandez for Shaq & Yi
 

Who wins this trade?

Re: Collison & Fernandez for Shaq & Yi
 

Hard to be sure, dispite my love for Fernandez, I like the Shaq and Yi side a little better. It is a relatively even trade though. I guess it depends on what your team already looks like.

Re: Collison & Fernandez for Shaq & Yi
 

This is my roster:

Chris Paul, Nor PG
Rudy Fernandez, Por SG
Vince Carter, NJ SG
Nick Collison, OKC PF
Pau Gasol, LAL PF
Al Horford, Atl C
Russell Westbrook, OKC PG
David Lee, NY PF
Paul Pierce, Bos SF
Michael Finley, SA SG
Mehmet Okur, Uta C
Kevin Love, Min PF
Mike Dunleavy*, Ind SG

Re: Collison & Fernandez for Shaq & Yi
 

Nobody. Its a crapshoot.

Shaq could play 65 games or 40. Fernandez could shine in Portland or lose mins when everyone gets healthy. Collison could be a double-double guy or could get lost. Yi could be great Friday and horrible on Saturday.

If I was held at gunpoint, I'd take the Shaq side.