![]() |
OT: Michigan or Florida?
Who do you believe deserves to play OSU in the Championship game? IMO, Michigan might be more deserving to get a rematch, but I really don't want to see those 2 teams play again. I'd really like to see what Florida's defense can do against OSU's offense. It should be a good game, although Florida needs to bring their A game. They have played like crap so many times this year.
|
I want to see michigan, representing the big 10
I can understand why people outside of the big 10 would prefer florida though. I do honestly think that michigan is the better team though, and if you want to see the 2 best teams in the country playing in the title game, you want to see a rematch of OSU/michigan |
We need an OSU vs Michigan rematch.
|
Gimme FL, Michigan already had their chance at OSU. Would love to see a matchup of two team that rarely plays each other.
|
.
Quote:
link Florida deserves it more. however, if Michigan getting in makes a playoff happen sooner, ill take them. |
Florida's win over Arkansas is whatever. USC beat them 50-14.
|
Basically, Florida has the advantage in quality opponents while Michigan has the edge in convincing wins. Neither team has an argument capable of ending the debate. I'd pick UF because we've already seen Michigan lose to OSU but that's picking a team for a reason that really has nothing to do with who "deserves" to play for the Championship more. Neither team deserves it more, they both just deserve it. Oh well, hope there's a playoff system one day. Slightly off-topic, but something that I'll find ironic if voters give UF the edge based on not wanting to see a rematch: The University of Florida's sole Football National Championship came from a rematch against an opponent that had beaten them in the regular season, FSU, in 1996.
|
Quote:
Not the same Arkansas team...D-McFadden(aka their offense) wasn't healthy. I hate the Gators as a Canes guy/alumn but they derserve it.. Michingan had a crack at it already..And their most impressive win is against the overrated Notre Dame... And The Big Ten SUCKED this YEAR. USC losing to UCLA nipped all that hype they were getting (ROFL).. You gotta Give the SEC/Florida a chance...They got screwed the last time (Auburn)... |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Personally, if Florida lost last night I would have no problem with a UM vs. OSU rematch. But they didn't lose. |
Yeah, it was the pre-BCS days, which were arguably worse (on the plus side, no one harbored any illusions that the system wasn't screwy, as opposed to the present day where the BCS cultists act like this system solves everything). I just bring it up because it proves that a rematch is not necessarily the wrong decision. But if Florida gets left out and wins the Sugar Bowl while OSU goes out and beats Michigan again the BCS will continue to look like crap. Well, it will probably look bad no matter what happens.
|
Quote:
|
Id have to say the Florida Gators.
Wish there was a 1 game playoff to decide though, this seems unfair to one team. But Florida as a conference champ gets my pretend vote. |
You can make a case for both. I dont know who to pick.:confusedshrug:
|
I'd go with Michigan, but I can't rationally argue against Florida either. Won't be cryyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyin! either way
*jacks Alicia Silverstone's purse* |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:15 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. Terms of Use/Service | Privacy Policy